Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Looking for help

Posts

Looking for help

#1

Looking for help

Gary Smyth

I ran across this drop leaf table. In an older home belonging one of the local older families (the street name is their name). The color, scalloped corner, then legs, were classic. I bought. Perhaps I acted too quickly. After I paid we took the stuff on it off and the flaws availed themselves. First the split top. It is half way across the center. The split was probably caused owing to the top being secured using slotted screws. According to the owner the crack has been there since delivered from her grandmother’s house when she was a child. She believes that some of the white marks are from her kid’s pizza on paper plates and the white rings from hot tea. There is one leg that is ¼” shorter than the others. And, one leg has a crack where connected by a pegged mortise to the apron. Here’s the rub.

Restoration may be beyond the effort and value. What started out as a bargain ended up with costs spiraled because I screwed up thinking that I could fit it into my car—nothing worked, the legs were too long/widely spaced and couldn’t overcome the frame of the car. Several calls and no one could aid for transport so I had to rent a van -- the van rental cost more than the table. With the faults now what to do? Stop further expenses? The leg pad is not a problem. The white marks -- I just don’t know what to do about them. The screwed on top will be corrected to allow top movement and there are several ways to deal with that. The split is the perfect candidate for a “Dutchman” (if I can find some suitable wood) but I’ve never done that. I’m concerned my ability to do a precise fit. And if done, what do I do about the top finish. I’m asking for opinion. I think that the table is mid-late 19th century. I also can’t determine the wood. Whatever the wood top wood, would it be called quilted? Flame? Does a “Dutchman” go all the way through (or only partly through) the top? Anyone care to opine age? Wood name? Anything you might care to address would be appreciated.


Re: Looking for help

#2

Re: Looking for help

John Veerkamp

I think it's worth some effort to restore. I think the wood is tiger maple probably needs to be stripped(I know sacrilege).

If the top is wide enough one good fix for the split is to rip that section down the middle of the crack, removing enough wood to create a solid piece. Edge glue and refinish. hardly noticeable.

Re: Looking for help

#3

Go easy first

Yonak

Gary, it may be worthwhile to try some of the less radical methods of repair before resorting to the more radical ones. You could always re-evaluate in case they don't work.

For instance, it couldn't hurt to try the hot iron, with or without steam, and white towel method of removing the white spots. Here's one person's successful solution :

http://tipnut.com/diy-how-to-remove-white-heat-stains-on-wood-table/

..And gentle finish restoring before stripping.

Also, maybe you could try to break the table at the split and carefully re-glue it. If successful, the repair could be nearly invisible and you wouldn't lose table width. Maybe someone would know of a method to remove the dark staining at the split . ..Possibly bleach ? I don't know. (..Or, maybe, it's just dirt .. I can't tell from the photo.)

Re: Looking for help

#4

Re: Looking for help

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It's not necessarily the slotted screws as such - but the failure to make the holes big enough to allow movement. If you do repair it, you should use a fastening method - buttons, for instance - that will allow movement.

Re: Looking for help

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re:Well....

Jesper, Denmark

The first question is whether you like the table and have a use for it? I think its kinda nice and a bit unusual.

Forget about value. You have paid for it and it's transportaition and it's not an "investment".

The fixes of all the various faults are none too difficult, even if you have to completely take it apart and re-do it.

You know that you can get good advice from here as the project progresses, so if there are things you have not done before, you will learn how to and in the end have a nice table, which you have a special relationship to.

Re: Looking for help

#6

Suggestions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1. Determine its value (quality antique shop or furniture conservator).

2. Don't screw it up more than it is. Inexperienced "fixing" invariably leads to a more expensive fixing later. When I did antique work it usually cost more to undo amateur repairs than the original repair would have cost.

3. get an estimate from an experienced antique furniture restorer/conservator on what it would take to put it in what ever condition you wish to have it, either to use or resell.

With those three suggestions implemented proceed to deciding what you are going to do with it- use it or sell it.

More information:

The table appears to be hand made, maybe refinished with lacquer at some time, it is cherry or maple (can't tell from picture), and it is quite a nice table.

Don't try to fix the crack, especially as you suggested.

It is doubtful the screws has anything to do with the top splitting. Tops are normally held on by pocket screws.

The white rings are easy to fix. The table could be made presentable with a modest amount of work.

This table may be a better candidate for conservation than restoration to "new" condition, but an experienced repair shop can provide a better answer to that question.

Re: Looking for help

#7

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If the table is not worth much (it is factory made, unfashionable design, etc.) then you might use it as a learning experience at restoring antiques. The apparent good grain matching on the top suggested to me that it might be hand made, and hence of more value and worth preserving/conserving.

As someone else suggested, proceed cautiously. Fix the white spots first. The details of the fix will depend on whether it is shellac or lacquer. Basically the fix is to redissolve the finish by spraying solvent on it, available from refinish supply places in aerosol cans. Then clean up the finish with paste wax, with or without 4/0 wool. I can't suggest what to do with the split without examining it, but a Dutchman is not the fix I would use.

The splits are most likely a result of it getting wet and then drying quickly. Or, if it is hand made it could have been made with insufficiently dry wood.

Re: Looking for help

#8

First

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I'd find out what the finish is. Given the apparent age implied by your story, I would expect that it's orange shellac; very widely used until lacquer took over after WW-I. Some DNA on a paper towel rubbed on the underside of a leaf will confirm this if the towel comes away with color. If not, try some lacquer thinner. If the finish is shellac, an alcohol rubdown is easy to remove the old film (and the white areas as well) and then refinish with the same thing.

If the crack bothers you, a rip and re-glue is easy and you have sufficient width to allow a 1/8" rip and joint to do the repair. Done carefully, this may not require refinishing of the top. An alternative is to inlay a butterfly (not a dutchman) that is not more that 2/3 the thickness of the top.

Figure 8's or "Z" clips as methods for attaching the top work well, although a fixed block and screw at the center point on each end will hold the top in position while allowing the outside dimensions of the top to change.

Re: Looking for help

#9

Re: Looking for help

Ralph Lipeles

White marks are often caused by water stains. They are easily removed by rubbing with 0000 steel wool saturated with alcohol.

Ralph Lipeles

Re: Looking for help

#10

What is the wood?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't think it is hard maple. Neither the wavy "curl" nor the grain suggests hard maple to me. The curl is more characteristic of birch or cherry. The grain also suggests birch or cherry. I can't tell anything from the color as it is cherry red in one picture and maple yellow in another. Birch is a bit uncommon in furniture but if I had to make a guess from the pictures that is the wood I would guess, but it could well be cherry.

Gary, where might this table have been made? Is the top made up of only two boards?

Re: Looking for help

#11

More

Gary Smyth

Thanks to all. I'm going to work on the white marks with heat and oil as soon as I let the wood acclimate inside. I added a few more photos. I’ll look for someone to trust to check if the table has age. I’ll not drastically alter anything without further research. Locals may not be the hot bed to get an accurate response. Pictures sent away may be the only way to go. The table is not for resale. I’ll find a place for it. I look for handmade furniture and this one passed my first go round, so I’ll be careful to not experiment with it until I know more. I still cannot tell the wood mostly because the wood of the top and that of the sides are two different shades -- the top is darker. Pictures this time were taken with full sun. At this point I’m favoring those responses favoring birch because with age I’m thinking that cherry would have turned more brownish red than what appears. In full sun the look is more yellow than brownish red. Shellac seems to be the finish but only on the “show” faces. I used denatured alcohol (in an unseen place) to see if it would dissolve with no decision yet. I can’t tell if its finish or dirt. A hinge is shown one side. I've not seen this before. It was placed using a saw and chisel and one half is completely hidden and set inside each leg. That means that the hinge is screwed cross grain and is held mostly by the inset.

Re: Looking for help

#12

Dale Lenz

Re: More

Dale Lenz

The wood near the hinge does look like quarter-sawn cherry, shows some ray flecks. It's up to you of course, but I would not try to make the table look brand new. I'd leave the crack intact and put 1-2 butterfly/dutchman on the bottom of the top, across the crack. To error on the safe side, I would make the screw's shank hole larger to allow for wood movement. Please keep us informed of your progress.