Needed to move the color of some Minwax stain, tried Transtint then read that it is not compatible but then didn't really expect it to be. Drove 30 miles to get some Mixol and found that to be incompatible, went to Sherwin Williams and got some of their universal colorant and found it to be incompatible. Tired of burning gas so I gave the sample to SW and asked them to mix me some. Anyone had any luck moving the color of Minwax? Maybe it's time to move to a better product.
I mix different colors of Minwax together, seems like their colors are a bit off right out of the can. I tried a little can of Cabot's once, color was better but it was much muddier stain, lots of pigment, almost like thinned gel stain.
Could not quite get there mixing the Minwax stains, needed a tad of yellow. Thought I could quickly add a little yellow dye and be good to go, not. I mix Minwax stains all the time and have no trouble, it was when I introduced something new that I had a problem.
Try a little Transtint in acetone, it should then go into the oily carrier of the Minwax. I've done this tinting heavier drying oils and abandoned it because it makes the dried oil finish softer. Should be ok with stain though, if it works.
I tried mixing Minwax stains with some success but found better ways to get a color I'm after (if I have to use Minwax).
I've found, for example, if I wanted the color to be a little more yellow, I apply a wipe-on coat of something like Golden Oak and then the main Minwax color over that. Sometimes it works better in reverse so I test which way before committing to the project.
Something I found that works even better is what I just did on a grand piano top I was refinishing that needed to match the base. I was coloring curly walnut veneer and started with a coat of New England Maple dye (amber). Once dry I applied a coat of Minwax Special Walnut. Almost a match, I knew the Waterlox topcoat would add the last bit of amber to make a perfect match. Besides, I think you get a better color and clarity applying a stain over a dye.
Are we talking about Minwax solvent based stain? It seems to be a mixture of dye(soluble colorant) and pigment (colorant particles). Any dye soluble in a hydrocarbon solvent(mineral spirits) is going to dissolve in Minwax stain which is formulated in mineral spirits or its close cousins. And any pigment designed to disperse in a hydrocarbon solvent is going to disperse in Minwax stain, if you have the mixing capability to disperse it. And, any solvent based stain is going to behave the same. Alcohol and water dyes will no be soluble in a hydrocarbon based stain.
Oil soluble dye is available from Moser's whose products are available from Woodworkers Supply. Ditto for oil dispersable pigments but dispersing pigments takes some vigorous mixing.
As others have stated, an alternative would be to spray on a coat of yellow dye stain and then overcoat with the pigment stain.
Undercoats of dye can be a very useful technique and combined with a wash coat can give
Undercoats of dye can be really useful for changing colors rather than trying to mix colors to get it all in one coat. In addition if you use a wash coat over the dye before using a pigmented stain you can get finishes with more depth and complexity. Does take a bit of testing on scrap but often it ends up being easier to use several steps rather than trying for an all in one color.
Ray, a few years ago I purchased a "kit" of oil based (not acrylic) artist oil paints. It is obviously a pigment mix in oil but is compatible with Minwax stains. Can't remember the last time I used it, think it was on an old chair I repaired - had to replace a couple of rungs and repair a leg. As I recall it worked well. Per normal procedure - try a small batch on scrap first. By the way the artist oils also work well to "touch up" scratches, although I am not real good figuring out which colors to blend to perfectly match a finish and takes me a while. I bought a color wheel some time ago, but not sure where its at!
My wife is an artist and I've been surprised at how many of the products she uses are familiar to us woodowrkers. Some of them have fancy names, but the ingredients are pretty basic (BLO, alkd resin, etc.). I read an article in FWW about making stain from oil paints and have used the technique a few times. Made some glazes with it too.
I try not to stain much, but I have had much better luck with water based dye than products like Minwax. Lee Valley has the Lockwood powders. I like those because I can mix colors and vary concentrations to get what I am after. One thign I learned is to keep good notes and record your final mix somewhere (and on the jar).
I did mix up some dye, both lemon yellow and also amber and coated the wood. Then put the stain over that, problem was it was to nice. Nice and bright with plenty of depth. What I am trying to match is pretty muddy and everything in the room was stained with it. Since it is for a church I don't want to have something that stands out like a sore thumb. My cousin works weekends for SW and is a wiz at color matching, ball is in her court. We will see what she comes up with tomorrow.