Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Hickory log going to the mill *LINK*

Posts

Hickory log going to the mill *LINK*

#1

Hickory log going to the mill *LINK*

Tom Dunlap

This spring a hickory in the backyard died. My landlord waited until last week to have me remove the tree. The butt cuts on the top and bottom of the trunk show that there has been some borer damage to the sapwood. Along with that maybe some spalting/decay going on but the trunk seems solid.

The log is about 14" at the stump so it's not going to yield a lot of lumber. Small logs like this are a real shake of the dice. Will it be worth the gamble and effort to get some interesting lumber? Since that's the case, in the past I've had the sawyer flitch cut:

http://www.wooden-box-maker.com/images/flitch-cut.jpg

It's quick and I can take care of any custom cutting later. Having the wany edge fits my goal of respecting the spirit of the tree.

I realize that cutting for grade will yield more stable lumber:

http://www.wooden-box-maker.com/images/cut-for-grade.jpg

I might have some slabbed off 3/4" thick and most in 1.25"

Are there any hints or pitfalls specific to hickory that I should be aware of before putting the log on the carriage? I don't have any specific uses planned for the wood.

In the end any wood I have milled might just end up as really nice firewood. Of course, I'd rather see it as projects like in my camper.

tom


ToyBox

Re: Hickory log going to the mill *LINK*

#2

Re: Hickory log going to the mill

Dick Coers

I brought home a couple hickory turning blocks this weekend, and it was end grain checking within hours. I hadn't planned on turning it right away, so probably will be used by the neighbor for doing some ribs.

Re: Hickory log going to the mill *LINK*

#3

Re: Hickory log going to the mill

bill tindall

I would not bother with a log this small. Hickory logs are cheaqp to buy.

Re: Hickory log going to the mill *LINK*

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: Hickory log going to the mill

Dale Lenz

Hate to be a Nay-Sayer. But a hickory that died last spring will be full of borers, probably power post beetles, by now. I would advise to use it for heat /smoke wood.

Re: Hickory log going to the mill *LINK*

#5

Valuable feedback

Tom Dunlap

Even though I've made my living working with trees I don't know the specifics of some species or how the trees that I know in one region differ from the same species in another region.

This was the first hickory that I've ever removed. I know it's reputation as lumber and how it grows as a tree so to speak but not about it's characteristics as lumber.

There are borer holes like I said. If I do mill the wood I'll have low expectations of it being lumber. The cost of milling isn't that high so I might give it a try. when it does get stacked it will be well away from any valuable wood. I;ve read about powder post beetle and I sure don't want that bugger around.

There are some other logs here that may go to the mill too. I always need some rough lumber for projects so it would be nice to have a stash. There is always a bit of keeper-wood in any log.

Thanks for the local insights,

Tom

Re: Hickory log going to the mill *LINK*

#6

Re: Valuable feedback

Bill Tindall

It is a lot of work going from log in woods to stacked lumber. The result should be worth the effort. A log that is going to yield less than 50bdft of low grade lumber would not reach my threshold. Around here I could buy 50 bdft of #2 common poplar for $20.

Poplar is versatile "stash" lumber. I have never found any good use for hickory except cant hook handles.

Re: Hickory log going to the mill *LINK*

#7

Re: Valuable feedback

Keith Newton

Tom, I'm with Dale and the others, in advising against sawing. I have a mill sitting out on my parking lot, so it wouldn't cost me anything but a little gas.

I will occasionally cut a dead tree, with insects in the sapwood, but Hickory isn't one of them. When I do, I usually saw the sapwood off, leaving the rest of what has decay and insect resistance. Hickory heartwood does not fall into that category, so the heartwood may already be infested already.

You mentioned keeping a live edge. At this point, the bark may be falling off, due to insects, but who want that? Since you are into harvesting your own trees, if you want to keep the live edge, it is easiest to get the bark off in early spring, but still not so bad through the Summer, then most resistant during Winter, although it can still be done on some species.

Also, if it is Shagbark, I might add, that it has about the highest ratio of shrinkage between tangental, and radial, and a large number in both axis. This property gives it the propensity to warp, cup twist greater than any other wood E of the Rockies.

Re: Hickory log going to the mill *LINK*

#8

Re: Valuable feedback

Tom Dunlap

The log is still on the ground...which makes it closer to being firewood than sawlog :) It won't move for another ten days at least, I have contract work coming up.

When I remove trees I rarely have the luxury of the calendar. I'm driven by the customer's checkbook. If it's full now I do my best to help spread the wealth!

David Bromberg wrote:

Wealth is a disease and I am the cure.

Re: Hickory log going to the mill *LINK*

#9

disagree

Bill Tindall

" This property gives it the propensity to warp, cup twist greater than any other wood E of the Rockies."

surely that distinction belongs to black gum. Before I knew better I bought some and it lifted the 500 bdft of walnut I had on top of it, and it had interlocked grain. It looked pretty but was utterly useless

Re: Hickory log going to the mill *LINK*

#10

I believe grey elm would give it a run.


Re: Hickory log going to the mill *LINK*

#11

Dale Lenz

In the future...

Dale Lenz

hickory should make a great flooring wood/ a workbench top wood. As Bill says tool handles. Just built a fire rake handle a few weeks ago with hickory/pecan.

Re: Hickory log going to the mill *LINK*

#12

Don't write off all hickory...

Grant in Iowa

Tom,

The wisdom of Bill and others about your particular log is sound. It doesn't make a lot of sense from a return on invested time standpoint. That doesn't mean that you should always write off hickory as a furniture wood, nor that this particular log should be written off as firewood. I attach this image of a harvest table I built as witness to my statement:


The table has found a place in two different homes and has served very well as a dining table in each. After about 8 years of daily use, the wood in this tabletop is still attractive, durable, and stable. The owners have both known where the trees grew, and were both involved in harvesting the logs.

Due to sun exposure and the effects of the urethane finish, the sapwood in the image has blended with the amber of the heartwood, but the table is still a success garnering many positive comments from those who are seated at it for the first time.

I for one will harvest good hickory logs as they are available to me. A log that may be housing an insect infestation should certainly be properly treated and quarantined, however.

There are those who insist on "perfect lumber" containing no insect holes, knots, or odd grain for their projects. This approach makes sense for those who make their living making production style furniture. After 28 years of hobbyist woodworking I tend toward bringing home some gnarly stuff at times. It is these pieces that can make an interesting piece a one of a kind. I grow weary of simply copying the mundane with characterless wood. It is the experimentation with color, texture, and interesting features of wood that keeps the hobby interesting and new in my world.

And one must not overlook the provenance of a particular tree or log when making the mill/ firewood decision. Less than perfect lumber with character can be made in to wonderful projects that the landowner can appreciate well beyond the intrinsic value of the boards simply because they know it was grown on their land.

So, if you can spare the resources on milling a log that doesn't make financial sense, and you are able to appreciate whatever quirks the nature may be hiding in the log, then it may be well worth your time after all.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Hickory log going to the mill *LINK*

#14

Re: Don't write off all hickory...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Nobody said hickory was not an attractive lumber. The issue is what is one likely to get from a log 14" at its large end.

The relevant measure of a log is its size at its small end. That is the end that determines the width of the widest board one can expect as well as the distance this board will be from the useless wood located at the tree's center. These two factors, along with internal defects telegraphed to the bark pattern is what determines the value/yield of a log.

Re: Hickory log going to the mill *LINK*

#15

Individual variability among species.

Keith Newton

Bill, you can get individual variability among species, but what I was referring to was the shrinkage values of domestic hardwoods from the encyclopedia of woods. Some of the worse lumber that I've gotten off my mill, was a Cherry from a yard a few blocks from here, and who would claim cherry to be problematic?

My memory was off a little, when I stated Shagbark, when it was actually Shellbark, which has the highest numbers. It shows Shrinkage from green to ovendry at Radial 7.6, Tangental 12.6, and volumetric 19.2. Compared to Black Tupelo of Radial 5.1, Tangential 8.7, and Volumetric 14.4.

The difference between T&R is 5, in Shellbark, while 3.6 in B Tupelo.

West of the divide, pacific Madrone is R 5.6, T 12.4, and 18.1 Volumetric, with a difference of 6.8. There are some well known turning artist who have made a lot of money using the crazy warping properties of that wood, by turning thin green vessels then letting Nature do her thing as they dry.

Re: Hickory log going to the mill *LINK*

#16

Buckthorn for lumber

Tom Dunlap

I've made use of many pieces of low grade lumber. Defects don't bother me.

Some of you might know Buckthorn Rhamnus cathartica. Its a nasty invasive found in the northern US more than the south. for years I cut it down and saw the nice color of the heartwood. One day I took one down that was quite large. It went to a friend's mill where he slabbed it about 3/4" think. I was thinking of picture frames and boxes. The useable pieces were about 1.5-1.75" wide and maybe 18" long. I used it for the first counter top in my ToyBox. The plan changed and I used wide oak planks instead. Still, its a nice looking wood and easy to work too.

If the time comes to mill I have reasonable expectations of what to end up with. As an arborist/woodworker I 've done this before and ended up with decent lumber...and very little 'nice firewood'. The slabs would be stored far away from any good wood to isolate the creepy munchers that destroy wood. I may be moving and could use the stuff for sides on my trailer if nothing else. Then, cut it up for firewood/smoking when I settle in.

Tom