Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

OT; basement insulation question

Posts

OT; basement insulation question

#1

OT; basement insulation question

Mark Hennebury

Any body have any advice on whether or not i should insulate the basement ceiling?

I have a 110 year old two storey brick farmhouse, triple brick construction with a stone foundation and a dirt floor in the basement. Basement ceiling height is about 7'. we have a newer gas furnace in the basement.

The house has been renovated and all the old lathe and plaster removed and replaced with stud walls vapour barrier and Roxol bat insulation.

The basement just has the stone walls and dirt floor, I have been told not to insulate the ceiling in the basement to allow the heat from the furnace to come up, but it seems to me that the house would be warmer if i insulated the basement ceiling; anyone know what is best?

Re: OT; basement insulation question

#2

Re: OT; basement insulation question

Dave Bair

I'm not sure, but you can contact "Ask This Old House" online with any renovation questions.

Re: OT; basement insulation question

#3

Re: OT; basement insulation question

Kevin French

I insulated the unheated half of mine last year (paper up) and it made a big difference. The down side is you need to watch the moisture build up in the spring. It took me a while to figure out the best thing to do was to use just an exhaust fan.

Re: OT; basement insulation question

#4

Re: OT; basement insulation question

John McGaw

A 'newer' gas furnace should be putting out little, if any, heat. Not so with an old coal-burner but new furnaces are insanely efficient. The rule of thumb is that you insulate around all the heated/cooled areas of the home so unless you are intentionally conditioning the air in the basement I'd fill the ceiling with some sort of insulation. I spent a bunch of money a year ago putting closed-cell foam in the ceilings of the shop and garage before I closed them in with 5/8" plasterboard. The bedrooms and bathrooms above the newly-insulated areas seem to have warmer floors now although in the summer I haven't noticed too much of a change.

Re: OT; basement insulation question

#5

Re: OT; basement insulation question

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

I can't offer an opinion on insulating the basement ceiling (first floor floor) but you should definitelyvinsulate the joist cavities along the wall edges.

Lee

Re: OT; basement insulation question

#6

Re: OT; basement insulation question

Dick Coers

Are the ducts insulated? That would be the first easy money. I would insulate the ceiling. I would also put down a vapor barrier on the floor, and pea gravel on top of that to limit moisture coming up through the floor. You will have to monitor moisture in the spring for sure.

Re: OT; basement insulation question

#7

Pay Back

RobbCarr

It is unlikely that insulating the basement ceiling will be cost effective - even if you do the work yourself. Unless your floor feels cold (icy cold!) there's probably enough air leaks in the duct work to help maintain a pretty even temperature year round in the basement and that's not affecting the floor above it.

Re: OT; basement insulation question

#8

Jesper, Denmark

Re:Insulate

Jesper, Denmark

Insulate for sure.

Start with a vapor barrier directly under the floor. Roxul batts to fill the cavity between the joists. Cut the batts slightly oversized, then they stay in place and are easier to install. ad your favorite ceiling material - or not. If you do not install a ceiling under the batts, then you can keep the batts in place with strapping or stapled wires.

The Roxul batts are easier to work with than fibreglass, as they are harder and not as itchy as the glass - better fireproofing too.

As the basement is technically an un-heated space, you do need to have some ventilation there.

Re: OT; basement insulation question

#9

Thanks to all for your suggestions