Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Joining Short Moulding Into Long

Posts

Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#1

Joining Short Moulding Into Long

John McGaw

I am in the final throes of finishing up my library/gallery room (the carpet installers are downstairs right now stretching) so there is just a fireplace mantle and some moulding to fit. One feature I want is to have continuous picture rail moulding (profile shown) to eliminate the need to punch holes in the walls to hang things. Problem is that to get the stuff sent in at reasonable cost it will need to be in <8-foot lengths and some vendors go even shorter. Does it seem reasonable to pre-join the shorter pieces? I was thinking of the usual scarf joint but with some thin plywood strips maybe 6" long and 3/4" wide let into routed rebates in the back of the mouldings so that I could pre-join and pre-glue the pieces before hanging them near the ceiling. My thought that doing it this way should allow a less obvious join with no need to make them at the studs (24" OC). The profile shown is for the simplest moulding available which is 3/4" thick by 1-3/4" high. Since the room design is very understated this seems to be sufficient to me.

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#2

I'm thinking that you are making work

Gary Smyth

for yourself. A scarf joint should hold and appear just fine w/o having to go to the wood insert trouble. Also that profile is basically standard and I don't know of any lumberyard that doesn't carry 12' or 16" lengths. I'd check around before scheduling the time to do what you intend. Finally the moulding is not that heavy. Pin nails and a dab of construction adhesive will hold and if painted it will be all the more strong. Finding the stud is good, but won't be necessary.

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#3

Re: I'm thinking that you are making work

John McGaw

If the moulding was just for appearance sake then I'm sure that I wouldn't have to worry so much but this moulding has a job to do -- it is meant for hanging artwork, sometimes heavy, and there could be up to 200 pounds of expensive stuff hanging from the long (~23-feet) wall and nearly as much from the short (~16-feet) wall along with a couple of shorter sections on another wall between doors.. The moulding itself will need to be secured to the studs via trim-head screws or the equivalent.

My local suppliers, of which there seem to be very few at the moment, give a blank stare when I mention picture rail. Perhaps that is fair since it started going out of style after the Victorian era. I'd be ever so glad to buy it locally if I could just to save the hassle.

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#4

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

Lars Parrington

why not make the moulding yourself? seems like it wouldn't be any more work than trying to join pieces together. if you don't already have a bit or combination of bits that will work, then i suppose you'd need to buy one. but maybe the cost of the router bit is comparable to the cost of ordering moulding?

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#5

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

Rick Christopherson

The two responses ahead of mine (assuming I don't type too slow) are pretty good. So I will just expand on the options a little more.

Your idea of pre-joining them is ok, but it would be the last choice. There is nothing wrong with it except for the extra work. Even if you didn't pre-join them, you would just make sure that the joint was either over a stud, or right between 2 studs, where the maximum unsupported length is only 8 inches.

As for buying them in longer lengths, see if you can find a local contractor or trimmer and see where they purchase from. Regardless where you live, there surely will be wholesale trim companies. Even if you can't buy direct, you could see if the contractor won't buy for you.

The idea of making it yourself is probably an even better idea because you could better tune the profile to how you are actually using the trim. You could then make the upper roundover more hook-like to better hold hanging objects. Depending on what cutters you have available, this could be made in 2 or 3 passes.

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#6

Wasn't thinking about weight. *LINK*

Gary Smyth

This may be too simple or not well fitted to your wall but for what it's worth this might help with your decision.


http://thejoyofmoldings.com/picture-rail-108

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#7

almost anywhere has a place to make molding

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I know of three locally here in E. TN. And it is cheap to run from any wood if they have the cutters already.

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#8

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If you're in an area served by Kelleher, which kind of dominates the market in my area for molding (it's a Western company, so this may not be helpful to you), ask the suppliers about "P322" molding. That's Kelleher's catalog number for what you're picturing, although the profile you show is better than Kelleher's.

I've made some molding, and it requires ways to keep the molding stock firmly against the cutters, and, ideally, a smart assistant to maintain the flow of the stock across the cutter.

And picture rail isn't out of fashion; just not common. My local lumberyard stocks it, and I've used it as baseboard cap on our house, repeating the idea that the original carpenter used in 1895, though not with the same nifty profile he had available.

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#9

Re: almost anywhere has a place to make molding

John McGaw

In Knoxville, going down the list of molding and millwork places reveals that some of them have simply disappeared leaving no forwarding address -- possibly victims of the housing bubble's collapse or possibly victims of their own overexpansion. And yes, if a shop has the cutters on hand and if they are willing to deal in small orders they can do it easily but this profile is not your everyday stuff. If you can put me in touch with some millwork shop that can help me out I'd be grateful.

I know that, with some serious work I could probably make my own but there are flies in that ointment too. The purchase price of suitable tooling, a tiny shop, and no helper are right at the top of the list here. I couldn't even locate a 5/16" radius half-round bullnose bit that was affordable. $48 for a one-off is pretty extreme to someone cheap like me and I suspect that at least one other profile I don't have on hand would be called for although I haven't analyzed it.

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#10

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

John McGaw

Yep! That's the profile I want but Kellher's nearest dealer to me seems to be Nevada. I'm sure that I will get this worked out somehow but it gets a bit frustrating when something that seems so minor can throw up such roadblocks. I'd made other moldings for the project along with some stair nosings and such but this profile is complex enough that tackling it, along with buying new tooling, for a one-off is not a choice I'd make gladly. If it came to that I might just go with hangers in the wall, holes be damned.

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#11

Re: Wasn't thinking about weight.

John McGaw

Thanks. That is one article that didn't show up in my searches. Actually hanging the rail right now is the least of my worries. I can use a laser level to shoot the line and countersunk and plugged screws or even trim-head screws and some putty will do the job of securing it but I just hate the idea of doing the scarf joints in situ and the attendant waste of material since the joins will need to be at a stud (24" oc). That and the problem I seem to have making really clean invisible joins in something a simple as 3-1/2" baseboard makes me worry about putting up detailed long continuous moulding seven feet in the air in a highly-visible location.

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#12

possibilities

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Call Misenheimer in Morristown and ask. They supply molding machine knives to about every shop in the region. 423 587 4300

East TN flooring and molding Jonesboro 423 753 9268

Appalachian Millworks Abingdon 276 676 2227

There is a place in Kingsport that does a lot of work, but I don't have their name. They are located off Wilcox.

Ask your local lumber wholesaler. They will be selling lumber to this kind of place.

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#13

Not sure about cheap *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It may be cheap for the mill, but the only real hardwood yard around here now charges a $250 setup fee to run molding in any wood but what they commonly use. I found this out when I asked about running some bed molding in cedar or redwood. Bed molding is the pattern used for head moldings at outside window trim and similar locations in our house (see MS343 and MS345 at the link below if you're not familiar with bed molding; I have no idea where the name comes from), and it would have been nice to be able to buy it, for the reasons I mentioned in my comment elsewhere about making your own molding.


http://www.mountstorm.com/catalog_crowns.php

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#14

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

With a little work to make the holding jig, a tapered finger joint bit in the router table will give you very strong and near invisible joints if your moulding is to be painted.

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#15

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

John McGaw

Interesting idea. This moulding will be painted to match the existing moulding, doors, and bookcases. I don't have a finger-joint bit right now. Wonder what I can get a cheap but usable one for?

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#16

Did I miss the style of house trim?

Keith Newton

Is that the only profile that can satisfy your design requirements?

I'm sure you can get lumber in your area with the length you need. I'd rather just make my own, than to put up a lot of short lengths on plaster. I don't see anything that excites me about the standard picture mold profile.

My personal feelings about moldings, is that the changing levels,depths, tilts, fillets and grooves just add the way the light reflects, more than the actual curves. Through the years, I have developed my own set of profiles for every type of molding, most of which can be made on the TS with just one cutter doing multiple passes.

For a simple piece like picture mold, a rabbit on the back, with two steps down on the face, would take less time to make than your friends have spent typing suggestions for you.

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#17

Finger Joint

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Running the joint with the flat side of the profile dow, is easy, although you may want to fashion a trailing edge cozy to minimize tear-out. The holder for the inverted cut (flat-side-up) will be a bit tricky to get (and keep) straight on a router table.

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#19

Sometimes even the unluckiest bird...

John McGaw

...catches a worm. Problem solved by a bit of persistence and a lot of luck. A local building supply house which I think of more as a 2X4s and shingles place had five long pieces of the desired moulding which I gather had come in for a special order a while back and was never picked up. Once I got someone who knew what it was there was no problem beyond trying to haul super long whippy sticks on a short no-visibility trailer. Heck, they even gave it to me at wholesale once I mentioned that I was a member of ETWG. So at <$.51 I got enough stock to do what I want with a bit to spare for the inevitable bad cuts. Off to set up the sawhorses in the garage and start priming some wood...

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#20

Psssst

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

John,

As hung weight is an issue for you, check those long pieces for finger joints. It's been a long time since I saw molding more than 10' long that didn't have joints in it. You have to check from the back surface as they apply a paper-thin veneer on jointed stuff so that they can sell it as "stain grade".

;)

Re: Joining Short Moulding Into Long

#21

Re: Psssst

John McGaw

In a way I lucked out in more than one way on this stock. It is stain-grade clear pine stock with no finger joints. Of course being single long sticks means that moisture and racking has had their way with it so I'll have to wrestle it into a straight line (glory be to the laser level!) when fastening it up. Luck gives and luck takes away. Now that I've decided to put it around the entire perimeter of the room for appearance sake I'm starting to worry that the 5 15ft sticks might not do the job. Guess I can leave it off the soffit above the bookcase if I have to because I really don't want to have to go hunting for another stick to match...