Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Daughters desk. Done. Almost...

Posts

Daughters desk. Done. Almost...

#1

Daughters desk.  Done.  Almost...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Well, the desk I have been making ALL summer is done. Almost...

I was in the basement this morning before leaving for work putting another coat of finish on the drawer front - hope it comes out ok. I drive to Blacksburg, VA. tomorrow to deliver it to her.

I so hate finishing...

I got behind schedule making this because I was taking care of my elderly father for 3 weeks who has Alzheimers while my mother was in the hospital recovering from a heart attack and face plant onto the sidewalk... uhg.

The drawer front was nice until last night when I went to drill holes for the (ugly) knobs I turned the night before. I thought it would be a good idea to put some blue tape on the front where I was going to drill the holes. For some reason, when I pulled the tape off, I also pulled off some finish! Grrrr. I don't know why that happened. The last coast was put on about 4 days ago and I sanded between coats. I was using minwax gloss poly.

Of course while scuff sanding this last coat of poly I went thru all previous coats into the stain. Great. What a moron.

There are a number of things I don't like about this desk. Its ugly knobs (no time to redo right now), the back of the drawer I screwed up and is now a total hack job - hope nobody sees it :) , and I'm not too crazy about the finish.

The finish is too glossy for my taste. I don't have time to rub it out. Not sure I even can. Can you rub out/knock the gloss down a little on walnut and poly? Not sure you can because of the open grain? I'll try someday on some scrap I guess.

I do like the color of the walnut. I used the technique Bill Tindall posted about some time ago and used the General Finishes stain. Looks nice.

Overall though, I am happy with its look. It's a great height to sit at and its overall size is nice. I think it will work out well for my daughter who is going for her PhD. in Soil Science at VT. She is going to use it with her laptop and studies.

Here are some snap-shots (pre knobs). Thanks for any comments and for looking.

Joe

#1


#2


#3


#4


#5 - At least one of my Goldens likes it...


Re: Daughters desk. Done. Almost...

#2

suggestions.

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you intend to continue building furniture learn to spray finish by any one of the various means available now days. It eliminates most finishing annoyances. For one thing you can be done in just part of a day using lacquer, shellac or conversion varnish(as durable as polyurethane).

The solution to the gloss is to apply a coat of clear followed by a coat of dulled finish. By mixing clear and dull you can get the sheen you want. You can still rub out to smooth the finish and the pores won't be mirrors.

If my experience is any guide your next piece of furniture will be more complex and more refined than the one before. After a few more pieces your stuff will look better than what is in many galleries. That said the desk at hand will be way better made than anything the other grad students have and way beyond the junk from Ikea. .

Re: Daughters desk. Done. Almost...

#3

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

On "blue" tape...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Not all tapes are created equal. But there are some general principles to remember when buying tape for a project.

The higher the adhesion, the less time one can leave it on a surface before it becomes difficult to remove. Also, this means that any finishes must have had longer to cure before applied tape does damage. One indication of high adhesion is a rating of something like 3 days--meaning it would be difficult to remove after 3 days in the hot sun. 3M's bright green tape falls in this category.

Standard "blue painter's tape" falls roughly in the middle of the range of adhesion commonly available. However, this does mean it has enough adhesion to do damage to fresh finishes--even those that have cured up to a month or so. Also, the less glossy the finish, the more likely damage will occur, even months or years later. As a painter, I don't use this tape much at all--the rough edge texture wicks paint, making it virtually worthless for a clean tape line.

For freshly-dried finishes, you need a tape rated for "delicate surfaces". The yellow Frog Tape and the blue, smooth 3M tape with the orange labeling both fall into this category. Generally, this tape can be applied to a dried finish after 12-24 hours, and still be cleanly removed. This tape is also excellent for sharp paint lines because it is thin and has a sharp edge. The trade-off is that it is low adhesion, and may not stick well, especially to rough, damp or dirty surfaces.

Jason

Re: Daughters desk. Done. Almost...

#4

HVLP

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks Bill.

I'd like to learn more about spraying. I'll have to do some research and/or drive over and talk with Jeff Jewitt (his shop is just a couple miles from my house).

I think though I would find out it's a little pricey for me right now and I don't have a place to spray. Not sure I could do it in my basement and I couldn't use my garage, and of course outside wouldn't work from October thru May...

I'm going to do a little research though.

Thanks.

Re: Daughters desk. Done. Almost...

#5

Thanks for the info Jason.


Re: Daughters desk. Done. Almost...

#6

spraying tips

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Equipment can be cheap. Son in law got a DeVilbiss high end conventional spray gun for $50 on Ebay. A used air compressor can be similarly cheap.

HVLP would never have been widely available were it not for environmental regulations. In most situations it has no advantage over conventional spraying and it is more demanding of good technique.

Finish formulated to spray can be easy to spray and hence easy to learn to spray. A little know fact is that the viscosity of lacquer increases extremely rapidly as the solvent evaporates (something in the neighborhood of viscosity increases with the cube of concentration). Lacquer is formulated with some highly volatile solvent that flashes off quickly to provide this viscosity spike. The result is a material resistant to runs, yet levels well.

I spray out doors, all year. The secret is to preheat the object and finish indoors. Dash out side and spray. As soon as the solvent has flashed off move the object back inside to cure the finish. I get my best finishes when it is cool to cold because they level well. Alternatively buy an old VW van to cure finish in the winter. They make a great greenhouse on a sunny day. In fact they perform much better at curing finish than driving.

The 3M PPS cups are pricey, but cheap as I am, I find them worthwhile.

I successfully spray everything but latex paint including lacquer, conversion varnish(my favorite), shellac(difficult to spray), oil based paint(thinned a bit), solvent based varnish(thinned a bit), etc. Once you see the glass smooth result of spraying paint brushes will sit unused.

Re: Daughters desk. Done. Almost...

#7

Adam of Oakland

Re: Daughters desk.  Done.  Almost...

Adam of Oakland

Hi Joe - I would like to add that that is an adorable pic of your dog! also the desk has graceful lines and I'm sure it will be well loved. The patina from use will knock the sheen of fresh finish off too in a pleasant way. Good work!

Re: Daughters desk. Done. Almost...

#8

Water based?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"I successfully spray everything but latex paint including lacquer, conversion varnish(my favorite), shellac(difficult to spray), oil based paint(thinned a bit), solvent based varnish(thinned a bit), etc. Once you see the glass smooth result of spraying paint brushes will sit unused."

What about water based finishes (I know water based doesn't necessarily mean safer)?

I've been reading some older FWW articles about spraying, and it looks as though a compressor based sprayer (HPLV) can't spray water based products.

If I were to go down the path of spraying, and had to spray in my basement, I think I would have to look at water based finishes. I don't know if taking something outside to spray in the middle of winter would work. Can you do that if it's 20-30 degrees out?

What about a mask and spray booth?

I don't know, lots to learn. I'll keep doing a little research.

Wondering out loud...

Re: Daughters desk. Done. Almost...

#9

Re: Water based?

AlanWS

I am far from an expert at spraying, but wanted to say that I have been happy using water-based hydrocote resisthane from Highland with a cheap HVLP system. If it had been warmer today I would have used it, but in my shop in Wisconsin it's a summer-only process and I settled for brushing.

Re: Daughters desk. Done. Almost...

#10

Re: Water based?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I can not imagine why a claim could be made that water finishes can't be sprayed with conventional equipment. The only thing I notice is that they are greatly more prone to run, hence more experience to spray them is required. But that would be the case even if they were brushed! In any case I have sprayed both Target and General finishes uneventfully with my DeVilbiss gun and air compressor.