Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Tung Oil Questions

Posts

Tung Oil Questions

#1

Tung Oil Questions

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

So I have a project that I want to use an oil finish on. Tung oil might be the choice. But I am wondering if anyone has a preferred product? I'd like to get a soft shine with the finish.

Or does anyone have a "magic formula" with a drying oil they would care to share?

Thanks,

T.

Re: Tung Oil Questions

#2

JL

Re: Tung Oil Questions

JL

I usually buy Rockler's Tung oil - which I am sure they don't manufacture - only distribute. It dries well, is hard and is somewhat inexpensive.

Re: Tung Oil Questions

#3

Clint Searl

Re: Tung Oil Questions

Clint Searl

You can simulate an oil finish by wiping on any thinned oil based resin finish (poly for instance) in the sheen of choice.

Re: Tung Oil Questions

#4

Re: Tung Oil Questions

Stephen W. Schoene

Pure tung oil is a poor choice as a finish. It is slow to dry, needing several days between applications and often requiring 4-5 applications to build an even satin sheen. If you go too quickly it can turn a whitish color that requires stripping to remove. And, in the end it isn't very protective--only slightly more water resistant than the negligible protection from boiled linseed oil.

I much prefer an oil varnish mixture for an oil finish look, rather than any of the pure oils. It looks very similar, is applied the same way (apply liberally, let penetrate for several minutes, and then wipe off thoroughly.) One good formula is equal parts of varnish, linseed oil, and mineral spirits. The end result will require fewer applications and be considerably more protective.

Re: Tung Oil Questions

#5

Re: Tung Oil

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Keeping in mind the comments to Alan Young's counter-slab . . .

Waterlox is one of the few finishes actually made with tung oil. Big advantage of Waterlox over a linseed oil finish is that, although both will "amber" the surface, the tung doesn't darken over time. Where Waterlox comes up short is in the Wear Department; it is not a very hard or abrasion-resistant film. I do, however, use it when finishing darker woods (walnut and cherry). I have used the original Sealer, the High Gloss (more resins), and the Marine Sealer which is great for outdoor wood furniture. On interior items I will often use one application of Sealer, then a coat of Gloss, then a tie coat of dewaxed shellac, and lastly a cross-linked top coating of a waterborne such as General Enduro Clear or HP Poly.

I always use gloss clears rather than semi or satin because the flatting agents muddy up the refraction and visual depth of the top coat. I prefer to rub out the final coating to the amount of gloss or satin I want on the piece.

hth

Re: Tung Oil Questions

#6

I use a wiping varnish,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

in this case, Minwax Antique Oil finish. It does exactly what you want. I generally put on three coats, apply with 400 or 600 WD paper, wipe down between coats and buff the final coat after it's dry with a soft cloth. The process couldn't be easier.

Re: Tung Oil Questions

#7

Re: I use a wiping varnish,

les winter

http://www.leevalley.com/us/html/56z4500ie.pdf

great stuff

Re: Tung Oil Questions

#8

craigd

Re: Tung Oil Questions

craigd

I really like real Tung oil, smells wonderful, nut like (duh). Wish I wasn't too cheap to use lots more of it (vs BLO). I like the 1:1:1 oil/varnish/thinner (MS/Turp) mix. I'll often use straight oil, let it sorta dry, use the mix and maybe topcoat with varnish (not in a hurry here). One project, (Claro walnut and purpleheart), I wet sanded the mix and the result was wonderful, it has that "glow", and still does ten years on (not a wear item).

I haven't tried it but japan dryer might improve drying time.

Re: Tung Oil Questions

#9

Re: I use a wiping varnish,

Stephen W. Schoene

The Minwax Antique Oil Finish is an oil/varnish mix, it is not a wiping varnish. You can tell from the directions which call for buffing each coat with a clean cloth after allowing 5-10 minutes for penetration. It will do a fine job when directions are followed. But, if you treat it like varnish, applying a film and then failing to wipe off excess, the finish will be softer than desirable.

Re: Tung Oil Questions

#10

Re: Tung Oil Questions

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have (and will continue to use) the Rockler "Pure Tung oil" on some of the walnut stocks on my firearms. I'm sure it is personal preference, but I have used BLO and Tung oil on gun stocks for a long time - around 60 years. I have never seen any other finish containing varnish of any kind that is as "repairable" without detection. Rifles get scratched - a little 4-0 steel wool and a new coat of oil completely repairs any scratch. Besides I really like the satin sheen and appearance of the pure oils.

I wouldn't use it on a real wear area like a table top due to the time required to re-coat when it would get scratched - it isn't as hard as some of the compounded finishes - but in my opinion it does have some uses that can't be done as well with other coatings.

Re: Tung Oil Questions

#11

maybe the confusion

Bruce, a MN Galoot

comes from an article on wiping varnishes by Bob Flexner, in which he lists Minwax Antique Oil finish.

Re: Tung Oil Questions

#12

Re: Tung Oil

Howard Acheson

<<<< it is not a very hard or abrasion-resistant film.

You might want to check with Waterlox about that. Waterlox is made with a phenolic resin which is much harder that the alkyd resins used in most varnishes and poly varnishes. Take trip to their site and you will find that Waterlox Original is actually started life as floor finishes. In fact, Waterlox Original Gloss was originally named "Gym Floor Finish" until Waterlox found that they could make more money by calling their products a furniture finish.

The bottom line is that Waterlox Original Gloss, Satin and Sealer Finish are very hard and durable varnish finishes.

Re: Tung Oil Questions

#13

Re: Tung Oil

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Hi Howard,

I have no way to test the waterlox film to fit it into a hardness scale, but my experience with it shows me time and again that it is a softer finish than oil-based poly urethane.

Re: Tung Oil Questions

#14

Re: Tung Oil Questions

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

Here is a classic recipe. Not sure who came up with it but I got it from a guy that picked it upwhen he apprenticed to Art Carpenter in the early 70's.

Equal parts turpentine, oil, Varithane, and a bit of bees wax.

I prefer tung oil to linseed oil and use polymerized since I have it on hand to use as straight oil, but in this formula raw will work just fine. Start by mixing turp and oil, and for a 1lb coffee can sized batch of the total mixture add a chunk of bees wax about the size of your thumb. Melt the wax in the turp and oil mixture by heating a double boiler. Cool and store. Mix in the Varithane just before using, this will have a shelf life of about a week or so.

Once the bees wax is melted and the mixture is cooled the wax will not re-solidify.

Robin

Re: Tung Oil Questions

#15

Re: maybe the confusion

Stephen W. Schoene

Better double check the Flexner article. He has it listed correctly among oil/varnish mixes in the revised edition of Understanding Wood Finishing, and in his Popular Woodworking article in 2011.

Re: Tung Oil Questions

#16

Ellis Walentine

Lintungtane

Ellis Walentine

We used to mix up a linseed oil and tung oil and urethane concoction that worked great for a soft shine. Thin the first coat up to 50% with paint thinner or naphtha, wipe it on and let it penetrate for about 15 minutes, then wipe it off. Repeat a couple times with a little less thinner each time, and wipe it off after 5-10 minutes. Three coats is probably enough for vertical surfaces, more for wear surfaces, although it doesn't build, so there's little abrasion resistance. If the surfaces will get handled a lot, you will probably have to do maintenance coats down the line.

Ellis

Re: Tung Oil Questions

#17

Re: Tung Oil

Howard Acheson

Mark, you might want to go to the Waterlox website. They have lots of info about there products there. Also, they are very receptive to phone inquiries and would be happy to speak with you.

Re: Tung Oil Questions

#18

for a durable "oil" look

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Kemvar C conversion varnish. It was designed to look like an oiled finish. Looks like an oil finish but it has chemical and abrasion resistance. I made/finished some "danish" walnut furniture in the early 70's and it wore well through 2 kids and a dog.