Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Fun with Science - Rust Removal

Posts

Fun with Science - Rust Removal

#1

Fun with Science - Rust Removal

Stephen Kirk

Step 1, research on the internet about rust removal and find out our own Bill Tindall is the expert (as if there was any question!) http://www.rickswoodshopcreations.com/miscellaneous/rust_removal.htm I recalled hearing about this to restore hand tools and figured it would work fine for my needs.

Step 2, make a tank with some soda water - I used washing soda. Cut some rebar for the anodes on the sides. Connected the anodes with copper wire. Then I hung the rusty parts from a steel rod over the top. Hook up a battery charger - hot to the anode and ground to the parts.


If you get bubbles, its working!


After a few hours, we took the parts out, scrubbed them with some steel wool and put a bit of WD40 just to keep them from re-rusting right away. This is a bearing disc that sits between the pusher and the screw on the cider press. It spins nicely now. An oil wipe down should keep it nice for the long term.


Re: Fun with Science - Rust Removal

#2

Re: Fun with Science - Rust Removal

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Another approach is an acid dip, of a mild acid. Citric acid and vinegar (acetic acid) are the most popular. I've been using vinegar for a few projects, and it's pretty simple: soak for 24 hours, wire brush the loose rust off, immediately wash the tool parts in lots of water to neutralize the vinegar, copiously apply WD-40 or the like to neutralize the water. The metal often comes out kind of gray, but it's very effective.

Re: Fun with Science - Rust Removal

#3

Limitations of the acid dip

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

One of the often overlooked aspects of electrolysis derusting is the action of the scrubbing bubbles. If the current source is robust vast amounts of tiny hydrogen bubbles will be generated at the iron surface. These will get under anything stuck to the iron- grease, crud, paint, etc- and blast it away for better or worse.

Re: Fun with Science - Rust Removal

#4

This article lives on

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Spencer and I wrote it years ago for WoodCentral or Badger Pond, I don't remember which. A German woodworker asked if he could post it at some museum web site. From there it seems to have propagated far and wide.

Every few months we get an email concerning the article. Usually it is some shrill environmentalist railing that we have recommended despoiling the environment through generation of chromate when the preferred stainless steel anodes are used. Somewhere back in time someone made the claim that stainless steel will generate chromate when used as an anode in this cleaning. As is usually the case these folks have lots of concerns and little technical knowledge. I have asked each time for a reference to where this claim came from but so far no data has been produced to substantiate it.

A biochemistry graduate student (no doubt from CA)was particularly aggressive and was going to have us arrested if we did not retract the stainless steel recommendation at once. He was entertaining to engage. A degree in biochemistry does not leave one prepared to argue the details of this chemistry. He was unable to provide any citations to support his claims. I hope he did better in his thesis defense.

A friend has a 55 gallon electrolysis bath which has a stainless steel screen for an anode. I had this solution analyzed and found it contained around 1 part per million of chromium in some form or another. The amount was too piddly to be concerned with the details of what form the chromium was in. Another critic wedded to the chromate belief argued that the solution had been analyzed incorrectly and that was the reason no chromate was found in significant amounts. He did not fair well either in the exchange.

As a point of fact a 304 stainless steel anode will suffer only slight attack when used as an anode. What ever tiny amount of chromium might be removed will most likely wind up as harmless chromium hydroxide in the bottom of the bath. It will join the environment along with the hundreds of pounds of stainless steel being dissolved each year through corrosion of the local chemical plants.

There are many kinds of stainless steel. It may be that one of the less corrosion resistant varieties could generate small amounts of chromate at the anode. However, lots of stuff that would turn chromate into a benign form of chromium will be present in the bath. So, in the absence of data to the contrary I don't believe chromate generation should be a concern when using a stainless steel anode. No doubt those that make a career about fretting will continue to do so and we will continue to get emails.

Should one be concerned about the toxicity stuff being generated in the bath then focus on other factors. Paint pigments in days past contained cadmium and lead. If rebar is used it is made from recycled metal and it does dissolve releasing what ever might be there which will surely include chromium, etc.

I have been emailed about using the process to derust tractors. Just yesterday I was asked about details of attaching the anode by an exceptionally polite responder who was provided a detailed answer.

Re: Fun with Science - Rust Removal

#5

Analogous to the chromium cranks...

John in NM

I got a kick out of that Bill, especially the one who claims the analysis must be wrong, as it didn't find the proof so desired! :D

They remind me of the various cranks who push gold properties based on "new assay methods" that supposedly reveal gold where none was found before. My dad used to call them "Gold Bugs", and recently there was a local bunch claiming to have a new method to detect "unassayable" platinum. You seem to have discovered Chrome Bugs! :D

Re: Fun with Science - Rust Removal

#6

Re: This article lives on

Stephen Kirk

I was a bit worried about disposal of the mucky water, but your research suggests there isn't much danger in there, or at least not much that wouldn't show up another way. Plus, I may do this every few years, not 3 times a week.

I've also dealt with those who can find a problem with anything without much to back it up.

The process is quick, works well and is easy to clean up. I'm more worried about water ear electricity, so keep it out of the wary, and it's only trickle charging anyway.

Great stuff Bill! My parts should last another hundred years.

Re: Fun with Science - Rust Removal

#7

On that small scale, I was wondering,

Keith Newton

I have an old rusty trailer that I need to clean up. I wonder if the next time one of my friends with a swimming pool goes on vacation, would notice if I tried to scale this up a bunch. Would a big DC welder do the trick? he he

Re: Fun with Science - Rust Removal

#8

Re: Analogous to the chromium cranks...

R Payne

Based on what Bill said, the analysis was incomplete as he didn't have the sludge tested as well. Failing to test the sludge relies on the assumption that there is nothing in the solution which will precipitate out the chromium. And since it is impossible to know all the chemicals present on all of the parts that have undergone electrolysis this is a flawed assumption and invalidates the claim that chromium isn't released. Test the sludge and I'll be satisfied that the grade of stainless being used is safe.

Re: Fun with Science - Rust Removal

#9

the correct analysis was do to answer the question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I didn't analyze the sludge for good reason. The claim was that using a stainless steel anode would generate sufficient chromate in the solution to pose an environmental hazard, or apocalypse depending on the critic making the claim.

Chromate would be soluble in the basic solution while the more probable form of chromium dissolved from the anode would not. Hence, analysis of the solution for total chromium (the easiest analysis to do) would provide an upper limit on the amount of chromate present. No worrisome amount of chromium was detected in the bath analyzed.

Given the results of this experiment the onus is on the critics to provide data that there is chromate generated, rather than to continue to make the so far unsubstantiated claim.

As far as measuring how much chromium, likely present as chromic and precipitated as benign chromium hydroxide, this amount would be easily calculate by weighing weight loss from the anode and multiplying by the amount of chromium present in the steel. Personally I have seen very little loss from the anode in my work.

But for those looking for an environmental concern to avoid, use platinum. It won't dissolve at all, unlike rebar which will release all the minor ingredients present, including chromium.

Re: Fun with Science - Rust Removal

#10

Bravo Bill!

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

My patience has suffered from the remarks of some of the environmental quacks. I am reminded of the time in history when they were discussing the radiation levels that should be allowed to "leak" from a Nuclear facility. The "expert" environmental advocates were recommending to the government panel a certain (very low) level that was essentially unobtainable - period. Finally one of the true experts on the other side spoke up. His response was somewhat along these lines. If you truly believe the level you suggest is harmful then we had better evacuate these premises immediately and all the other buildings in Washington as most are marble lined. Marble emits a much higher level of radiation into these buildings than you are proposing as a maximum limit. The allowed level was then set at a reasonable figure.

I still hear how any Nuclear explosion will render a huge area around the epicenter uninhabitable for "Thousands of years" - Yet there are people living at ground Zero in Nagasaki and Hiroshima (and have been since the bombs were dropped). Their cancer /mutation rate is in line and/or lower than many other "safe places".

Re: Fun with Science - Rust Removal

#11

Dale Lenz

Enjoyed the read, thanks to all.  ?

Dale Lenz

Article said not to put your hand in the soda solution while powered up. If you did, will you get a an electrial buzz. Solution is acidic or what?

Re: Fun with Science - Rust Removal

#12

Re: Enjoyed the read, thanks to all.  ?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The solution is basic(caustic) but not greatly so. Prolonged exposure would cause irritation. Not as bad as uncured concrete or TSP (trisodium phosphate).

If a battery charger is used the voltage is 12 volts. If touching the battery didn't result in a shock I don't see that touching the solution would. That said, a used electrolysis bath is not an inviting place to diddle ones fingers.