I have need to do a light-duty vacuum bagging job -- a couple of curved cabinet doors from bendy board and veneer for right now. The thought of trying to get everything right using M/F forms and a zillion clamps does not appeal to me so it appears that I need to use bagging. I can buy a light-duty vacuum pump for $100 that will probably serve me for a long time but what else do I need? A bag for sure, hose, some sort of fittings to attach to two but there are probably a slew of other bits and bobs that I haven't thought of. Can somebody who has done this on the cheap please provide some guidance and perhaps some sources?
John, probably somebody will jump in here with a short list, but everything you need to know can be found on http://www.joewoodworker.com/. I have toyed with this process for a long time and haven't been brave enough to actually try veneering other than small pieces that I could do with blue tape. lol
He's right, JoeWoodWorker.com will give you more info than you could possibly need.
I did it on the cheap. I had a small Gast pump (.7cfm I think) and I scrounged the rest of the stuff. Bought a vacuum gauge from some local supply house, some 1/4 inch tubing and a few pipe fittings form the local Borg/Lowe's. Went to the "fabric" Dept. at Walmart and bought some sort of clear plastic (Vinyl?) sheeting and I think I got the glue there as well. I think that was E-800 or E-8000. I got a valve stem and a clip on Nozzle (Like you would use to put air in a tire.) And a sheet of MDF to use as a platen.
It really is low tech. The plastic sheeting is about four feet wide (Whatever) and I bought a piece about eight feet long. Folded it over to make a four by four bag. Sealed the two edges with the glue. (put a little extra at the fold.) I think I out a stick on both sides and clamped it for a while. Left the fourth side open to insert the product. Cut the MDF down to fit in the bag and used two layers so it would remain flat. You can wax the surface to prevent the product sticking to the platen. (I used a piece of Formica I had laying around.) Used a round over bit on all the edges to keep a sharp edge or corner from cutting the bag. You could also put a piece of poly on the platen to prevent sticking.
Mount the tire stem in a hole in the bag. (I bought a type that was threaded and sue two rubber washers and two steel washers and some of the glue to seal the hole. You have to remover the little needle valve stem from inside the valve to let the air escape. (That's why you have to have the clip on filler) Can't remember, but I probably removed the guts out of the filler except or whatever gasket that seal this to that. (Pardon my lingo, but I have forgotten the names of the various little parts.)
Then you put the platen in the bag, hook the pump to it through the tubing and fittings. Have a tee in the line for the gauge. I seal the bag by rolling the excess plastic around a pipe and clamping a 2x2 with a Vee cut in it on either side of the pipe. (gently)
Turn on the pump and watch the magic. My little pump slowly sucks the air out. At first it appears nothing is happening and the gauge appears stuck. Then the bag contracts and collapses and finally the gauge inches upward. We are actually talking a couple of minutes here. My pump is rated for continuous operation (important). I just leave it running. (maybe several hours) You can rig up a reserve tank and a pressure switch so that the pump can cycle on and off, but I have not bothered.
I have used yellow glue for my stuff. There are better glues. Look into those. Yellow was fine for me, but the others might be better.
I find that the edges are a problem. If you cut the sub straight exactly the right size and then glue on a piece of veneer, the veneer needs to over hang the edges a bit or its a bear to get them dead on. If the over hang too much the bag will flex them and break them. Also they end to bend down but arch up a bit just inside the edge of the panel, creating a poorly bonded perimeter. Much better if the panel can be at least a half inch too big all the way around and then trimmed. Don't hesitate to tape everything together securely. These sandwiches will slither in directions you never thought of.
If you get a pin hole in the bag, a piece of tape will seal it if you can find it.
Something like 28 inches of mercury is a perfect vacuum. That translates to something like 14.7 psi. Lots of variables here. Quality of the pump? Some (Most)simply won't deliver that kind of vacuum. Quality of the bag? Quality of the seal at the opening? Etc. If you can get 20" you should be fine.
Read up on flattening the veneer if yours is wrinkled.
The glue needs to "set" rather than dry. Remember that your bag is not unlike the bottle you dumped it out of, so leaving it in the bag for a long time may not help much. If you are doing low stress panels you can get the initial tack form yellow glue and then let them fully cure outside the bag. This is why some of the other glues may be better.
Funny that you brought this up now. I just loaned my home made set up to a friend of my son to veneer some curved doors.
For low use and low budget stuff it does not ave to be fancy or expensive. Aside from the pump I doubt I have $75 in mine.
I got in to vacuum bagging five years or so ago. I am frugal, but not cheap. I ended up discovering JoeWoodworker.com and his great information about the techniques of veneering. He has plans and kits to build venturi style vacuum presses, which are as low cost as they come, assuming you already have an air compressor.
Though I haven't built as many projects as I would like, I did manage to build some very successful laminated water skis, several bent wood lamination parts for projects, and some small veneered panels.
I think I spent around $250 for everything I needed to get started, a great deal of which was spent on the large 4'x8' vacuum bag, so it can be done cheaper with a smaller bag. The venturi pump I built was from his kit and it was called the "V2". The system has no problem pulling 28" of mercury and holding it over night. My 7 gallon contractors air compressor only cycles on about once every hour or so with the large bag in use, so there is very little leakage.
The venturi pump automatically cycles to maintain the vacuum level you set.
Here's a picture of the venturi pump along with a water ski built using the system.
Here's a close up of the tight baltic birch-like seams I can get with the system. The glue used here was Dap Weldwood Acrylic resin Urea Formaldehayde glue. I needed waterproof, thus the glue choice.
I highly recommend the setup, and I can say it has a lot of capability for a small amount of cost.
Here's one more of some bentwood table legs I made with a friend:
No affilliation with Joe Woodworker, other than being a VERY happy customer and benefactor to his knowledge base.
Another vote for joewoodworker, lots of info and lots of ideas for doing on the cheap. I also like that he keeps his site with items for sale separate from the info site.
this site is the font of sage advice. Get a urethane bag. Well worth the extra price. I have used both and the suppleness of the urethane makes it more convenient to handle, seal, etc. Also get some of the plastic screen while you are at it. Anything the pulls vacuum will do. If the bag seals the most piddly of pumps will be ok. I would look for used on Ebay. Get anything that is Gaast.
Thanks to everyone. It looks like it will cost a bit more than expected for the whole bundle but if I break down and buy a good pump rather than the cheap one I will probably find other uses like vacuum chucking and clamping down the road.
I have seen some "baggers" fret unnecessarily over their pumps. In a classic example of misguided pumping the person bought a used , large lab pump and then rigged a complicated device with a vacuum reservoir, pressure switching, etc. to turn it on and off to maintain some preset vacuum and "save" the pump from running continuously.
Lab pumps are designed to run continuously, like for hours or days. Turning them on and off wears them out prematurely. Even the small diaphragm lab pumps are content to run continuously and that is how they are typically used. Given the service these pumps see in a lab it is doubtful that any place other than a shop that bags daily would ever wear a pump out. The quality lab pumps can be readily rebuilt; the small ones by replacing the diaphragm. Personally, if I needed one I would buy a used pump off ebay for $50 and be happy for a lifetime.
We run pumps for days on end at work, no problem. Unlike compressing air, the heat generation of vacuum pumping is mostly due to friction between pump parts and is minimal and very steady in use.
Heavy oil bath pumps can suffer from fume contamination of the lubricating oil (from epoxies and glues), but as diaphragm pumps are much more common for gluing operations, this is a very minor point.
Good to know. I haven't done the search yet for pumps -- did it some years ago and then changed my mind and invested in other things. At the time I was looking for higher-volume pumps (> 7.5cfm for sure) because the main intent was vacuum chucking and that can be a problem with a puny pump because workpieces are unpredictably porous and leaky. Now it is looking as though a 2.5cfm will be sufficient for occasional vacuum bagging since I don't care if it takes 1 minute or 5 to draw it down just so long as it does the job.
John, If you have an old compressor around, or for that matter, a new will work, except some oilless ones. All you need to do, is open the tank, and then plumbing on the intake side to get a hose in the bag.
As for doing curved parts, I think it is a waste of time to have to build a bullet proof form which is inside the bag. I always bend the bag of veneers around the form, which is outside of the bag. This only requires it to be strong enough to resist the bending pressure of the combined parts. Since I use epoxy for my bends, it acts like a lubricant between plys, making that easy.
Run the largest hose you can between the pump and bag. The low pressure of the atmosphere at your elevation is not capable of pushing any more air through a small hose or fitting, whether you have a half horse pump than a ten horse. Each doubling of hose size equals four times the volume. And there is no need to look for any trick fittings to get the hose into the bag. When I make up a bag, I put a few wraps of rope caulk or butyl tape around the hose, then squeeze the bag against it where it comes into a corner. A shirt sleeve taped around the end of the hose in the bag gives the air a path between hose end, and the project, without the bag sealing around the end of the hose.