Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Tinting Poly follow on to banister question

Posts

Tinting Poly follow on to banister question

#1

Tinting Poly follow on to banister question

Dustmaker Mike

Well the wall prepping and painting is done. So now it is on to the banisters. I have taken them off and started to clean them with a scotch bright sponge and warm soapy water. It seems the finish is old enough that it is coming off pretty easy this way. It is still leaving a light golden oak color because they used a better stain then finish on it. So here is what I am planing on doing.

Get two gallons of Glossy Poly

Tint one to the color my wife wants

Put two coats of clear gloss on then one coat of tinted sanding in between each coat.

Now my question what do I use to tint the Poly? I want it more brown to walnut in color.

Does this sound like I am on the right path. I will doing the same treatment on the new treads and a bench seat I am going to be replacing and building.

As Always Thanks

Re: Tinting Poly follow on to banister question

#2

Re: Tinting Poly follow on to banister question

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You're more likely to get a better job if you sand and restain the wood to the color you want, then coat with clear. Tinted finishes are prone to lap marks, especially when hand-applied. I have done them successfully using tinted shellac and a small HVLP gun, but they are still a pain to get an even tone.

The other issue is that to get a deep tone you wind up with many coats and the job comes out looking like plastic and the pigment tends to hide the character of the wood. Stains have pigment, of course, but also use dyes so the two colorants allow more variation in tone.

Lastly, the job will go much faster with the stain/clear route. Do be mindful that the stain (always oil-based) needs to be fully dry before top coating with the finish. If you're using a water based poly, consider sealing the oil stain with a coat of dewaxed shellac like Zinnser's SealCoat. You'll have better adhesion with a water based poly with the shellac sealer in between; do NOT, however, use "Bull's Eye" or other waxy shellacs as they will create adhesion problems with the top coat.

Re: Tinting Poly follow on to banister question

#3

Re: Tinting Poly follow on to banister question

Howard Acheson

Mark has given you excellent advice. Tinting and brushing on a clear is a road to problems. In effect, tinting a clear produces a finish similar to the universally hated Minwax Polyshades. Any variation in film thickness produces an uneven coloring. It's particularly problematic on curved surfaces.

If you want to use a tinted clear, be sure to test it out on some scrap or on an inconspicuous spot.

Re: Tinting Poly follow on to banister question

#4

Ellis Walentine

Staining oak

Ellis Walentine

I'm curious about why you advocate oil stain only?

Ellis

Re: Tinting Poly follow on to banister question

#5

Re: Staining oak

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Easier to get an even tone. Straight dye stain (alcohol NGR) tends to blotch for me. Oil based can be rubbed more easily but will leave highlights showing on the winter grain. I know that ring porous woods like Oak tend to weep excess stain, but I still prefer the oil and don't mind doing a few wipe-downs