Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

No Good Deed . . .

Posts

No Good Deed . . .

#1

No Good Deed . . .

charlie belden

goes unpunished!

15+ years ago, the electrician on my house addition project called, knowing that I was a woodworker, to give me first choice on some really nice wood he wanted to get rid of before moving to British Columbia. In his wood stash were ten, 3/4" x 7-8" wide by four to five feet long boards - of Bear Claw Spruce. He'd acquired them, 20 years earlier from another woodworker - who'd had them for close to 30 years.

Neither he, nor the old guy he got them from, could find a use for them - in a piece of furniture - the Bear Claw figure being just too unusual as an element in a piece of furniture. Had they been able to resaw boards to make bookmatched sets, they might have been able to encorporate bookmatched panels in cabinet doors. I do have a bandsaw - and an LT carbide toothed Resaw King - and I did resaw one of these precious boards and used them for panels in two cabinet doors.

I resawed one of those precious boards, and used the bookmatched pieces for panels in a cabinet door. While really interesting french polished with garnet shellac one one side and platina shellac on the other, they just overpower anything around them.



For furniture - this wood is difficult to use effectively. BUT - for guitar tops - it's highly prized, not only for its look - but also because it is a pretty good TONE Wood ( tap it with your knuckle and it rings). So over the years I've turned a few instrument makers on to a board from which they made one or two guitar tops.

About a year ago I was approached by two guys VERY interested in this wood

- a guy with a Perfect Ear - who is brought in to record a host of music artist - in studios in Nashville, who also collects fine guitars

- a well known in these parts guitarist/singer/songwriter

What they had in mind was to collaborate with the best guitar maker in Northern California - and have a really really nice guitar built using this Bear Claw Spruce for the guitar top. These guys really knew guitars and appreciated fine ones.

It looked like a perfect match - this wood I'd been the most recent caretaker of - and the perfect end use of it - a fine instrument. So I gave them two of the best of the stuff I had. I emphasized to them that this was precious stuff and that they must take care of it well. I explained how it must be stored until final use and stressed that it could be ruined for all times if they didn't take really good care of it.

Two months after I gave them the wood, word got back to me that they were leaning up against a porch wall - facing SOUTH. So they had been sitting "out in the elements - such as we have in Norther California - through August and September - August heat and then a few days of rain in September.

I came unglued! Took me close to a week to finally reach the guy with this wood on his porch - for two months. As calmly as I could, I explained again how it should be stored - and WHY. I was assured that it would be treated properly - and that the instrument maker would begin work on The Guitar within weeks.

Ten months later, I find that NOTHING had been done about making the guitar and so I started working on getting it back - so someone else could actually USE it.

A month later, I got it back - wrapped in construction paper - STAPLED TO THE BOARDS - WITH LOTS OF STAPLES!

Now, unless you bookmatch pieces, the figure in the wood just doesn't look right in a piece - furniture and especially in a guitar top. So even if all the staples were removed without further damage to the wood - and we're not talking little staples for holding sheets of paper together - the boards are ruined. Fifty or sixty years of caretaking it - destroyed by a three or four dozen staples - in minutes.

No good deed goes unpunished . . .

Next time, if there is a next time, I'm gonna want references and a credit report and will check those references - before another one of these boards leaves my care.

RANT MODE - OFF.

A month later

Re: No Good Deed . . .

#2

Ellis Walentine

Sad story, Charlie

Ellis Walentine

Maybe the upshot here is that when you have a rare piece like yours, you need to value it properly and sell it to someone who presumably understands the value. At least, you get out with a profit, and, odds are the price will keep away unsophistocated buyers.

Sorry to hear this.

Ellis

Re: No Good Deed . . .

#3

Re: Sad story, Charlie

charlie belden

These folks are not unsophisticated - at least when it comes to guitars. The missing link was the instrument maker - or more precisely - the money to PAY him to MAKE the guitar. His work STARTS at $2,000 and goes up from there.

Alas, the lack of sophistication of the original two people was with handling MONEY. One HAD the money - but blew it on a bicycle, bling for his older car, and a weekend - in Vegas. (Would you believe I came to Vegas in a $50,000 BMW and I'm going home in a MILLION DOLLAR - wait for it - Grey Hound bus).

Forgot to mention the two 12/4 - 12" wide and 3' long billets of heavily blister, dried over 20 years, maple - that was to become at least two- possibly four, really nice solid body electric guitar. These were stapled too, but only on one side.

Re: No Good Deed . . .

#4

Re: No Good Deed . . .

Hank Knight

That story breaks my heart! What ungrateful idiots!