Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Behlens Rock Hard or something else?

Posts

Behlens Rock Hard or something else?

#1

Behlens Rock Hard or something else?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hi.

I am about ready to start finishing the desk I am making for my daughter.

It's all stained (General Finishes Oil Based Walnut) and ready for finish.

In the past, for table tops, I have used Behlens Rock Hard Table Top finish. Sometimes I just use Minwax high gloss poly, wipe on coats and do a final rub out and wax until I like its look. I've done the same with Behlens too.

But I seem to remember having problems with Behlens and I also seem to recall being told here that Behlens is not a good product to use when you plan to rub it out. I think I was told (here) that because of the type of resin used, it doesn't lend itself well to being rubbed out. There is a very good chance I am not remembering this right(!).

For the table top, I will brush on.

For the table base, I will thin and wipe on.

If I use Behlens I will probably thin it a little before brushing it on the top.

I like the look of the Behlens product on a piece of scrap, but the Minwax is fine too.

Does what I am remembering about Behelns sound right? Something in the back of my mind is telling me not to use it.

Thanks.

Re: Behlens Rock Hard or something else?

#2

Re: Behlens Rock Hard or something else?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The finished product is a poor place to do chemistry experiments, or rely on someone's memory. Test the proposed schedule on a test piece.

That said, to rub out a finish it needs to be hard, period. "Rock Hard" sounds hard. If the finish resists denting with finger nail, it is hard enough to rub and use for a desk.

If you local source of urethane varnish has test pieces in the store try denting with finger nail. Use the one that tests the hardest. Something for floors would seem to be ideal.

Re: Behlens Rock Hard or something else?

#3

Re: Behlens Rock Hard or something else?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I used Behlens' Rock Hard stuff on my dining room table. It is very hard, so be sure you do a good job of brushing it out evenly. Scrape the nibs between coats and to help take out brush marks. Then wet sand and buff after it has cured for at least a week, maybe even more. There are pretty good instructions on waiting periods on the can.

My next door neighbor (with zero woodworking or finishing experience) made a blanket chest for his wife and finished it with a really hard urethane varnish, not a poly. The stuff was so hard he couldn't wet sand it without leaving a hazy finish, and he didn't have the experience to know what to do or when to quit. I brought over some pumice to use with his buffer, and he got just the glossy finish he had hoped for.

Re: Behlens Rock Hard or something else?

#4

Re: Behlens Rock Hard or something else?

Dave Arbuckle, Plano, TX

Been my experience that Rock Hard rubs out like a dream. I've used MicroMesh on it.

One of the things I've finished with it is what I call a "junk box", because I use it for carrying junk. Made of cherry, I carried it to my dovetailing classes and my wood coloring classes. Never once did it fail to get complements.