I need to re-groat and re-caulk our shower. Grinding out the old groat is messy but not bad it's the caulk that is going to be the problem. The old stuff I'm pretty sure is silicone so for the new caulk to seal the old plus any residue has to be removed. There are a couple commercial products that are pricey but might work. I also read that clear pvc cleaner / primer will work.
In your opinion what is the best way to handle cleaning out the old stuff?
3M makes a caulk remover. Why don't you start there.
Cheap alternatives - get some fairly concentrated isopropyl alcohol (rubbing alcohol) - 90% would be ideal. Put some in a spray bottle and spray on the caulk. Let sit. This will work with the acrylic latex caulks reasonably well.
Just some thoughts. I've used the isopropyl - but I've several gallons sitting in my garage.
The only time I've successfully removed the real silicone stuff was when I had to remove a caulked-on shower door rail attached to a metal tub and the only way I did that was to heat the aluminum rail with a torch and pry it off. I'm sure there must be some easier (and safer) way to do it but I'm always the last to know.
My son, working of one of the houses we were getting ready to rent removed caulk around the tub with Acetone. The caulk was white, probably some sort of latex/silicone or bath and tile caulk. I can get you more details of how he did it if you need them.
It is a crosslinked polymer of poly(dimethyl siloxane, maybe modified some). You will not dissolve silicone caulk, period. Crosslinked polymers of any kind are insoluble. In this case I don't know of anything that will even swell it. You can destroy it with a strong caustic solution. Somewhere above 500 degrees it will begin to thermally degrade. You may be able to get it to release with some chemical. But there is a reason it is guaranteed for 50 years. It's sturdy stuff.
Bill, there seems to be several brands of stuff that can be used for removal. Do you think they somehow loosen the connection between the tile and caulk but not actually dissolve the caulk? It's one of those thoughts that don't seem to have an answer. If nothing will stick to silicone how does it stick to something? Is it really once cured the sticking to is an issue? I guess the real question is if it can't be completely removed how can it be redone?
Stuart, are you speaking of the silicone around the door of the shower? If that is the question I would just say to use a single edge razor blade in a holder you can buy and scrape it all of that way....the old fashioned way....used before all these newer caulks and stuff.
"Do you think they somehow loosen the connection between the tile and caulk but not actually dissolve the caulk?"
If they work at all this would be how they work. Something strongly basic may attack and penetrate the interface between silicone and what it is stuck to and loosen it. (speculation) There might be some aggressive solvents that would swell it and may make it into a gel where it could be scraped.
Also, it is not true that it doesn't stick to anything. It will stick to anything it can wet, but given the properties of this stuff what it can wet may be limited. The chemistry that crosslinks it has the possibility of chemically bonding to glass so I expect the bond to glass, and maybe ceramic, could be robust.
I am unsure if new stuff will stick to cured silicone. If it does, why do you needs to remove it, or remove all of it?
a Question to explore. Not all tub and shower caulks are truly silicon. Many are actually "siliconized acrylic" They are more liable to be removed with the various caulk removing products.
That's what I've always done. A single edge razor blade in a holder. I keep a utility knife handy in case there are any heavy spots. I then used steel wool prior to the final cleaning with scouring powder.
I refinished my tub recently, which involves a complete strip of the tub, sanding, acid washing, then painting. For some reason the new silicone didn't stick too well to the tub. I removed the silicone with a razor blade until it was as clean as I could get it, then recaulked.
The silicone did not stick again. The next time I removed as much silicone as possible with a razor blade, then used some of the "silicone remover" sold at Home Depot. It actually worked quite well at removing the silicone residue. I had to apply it several times and use some elbow grease until I could not detect any silicone residue.
After recaulking again, the silicone appears to have bonded to the tub as it has been about 2 years without separation.
Asked my son (who is work adverse) how he did it. Said he twisted paper towels into "ropes" and soaked them in acetone. The toweling was to hold the acetone there a while to let it soak rather than just flash off. Then used a razor knife with one of the long flexible blades, the kind you can snap off when the tip gets dull and "filleted" the caulking. He is convinced the acetone swelled and softened the caulk. Then more cutting, more softening, and scraping and finally scrubbing with a green scrubby. None of it magic, just easier with the acetone.
I guess my plan is to cut away as much as possible then use one of the removal products. Then it's on to grinding out the old groat and re-doing the whole thing. If that doesn't stop my leak I can't think of anything to do but rip out the shower and rebuild and try to figure where the plumbing is leaking. This is not a job I'm looking forward to or how I want to spend my shop time.
If this project is driven by a leak there may be ways of focusing your attention to the area of leakage. Typically where there is a leak there will be mold and/or decay. Look for squishy sections of tile, black grout lines, and the like. If there is a good bond between silicone and what ever this leak isn't in that location, and move on. Check seals in the faucet. Get a hose and spray localized parts of the shower. Etc.
Bill is right. You did not mention a leak. You need to think this through. (As a Home Inspector, this is stock in trade for me) I addition to what Bill said, you need to think about when it leaks, if you can tell. Only during a shower? Then if might be the riser pipe going to the shower head or one of its connections.
Also, this might be an opportunity to buy a new toy(uh, TOOL, that's it, I meant tool). I bought a Multi-tool almost as a joke on closeout at Lowe's. It looked pretty useless, but it was cheap enough to buy on a whim. Boy was I wrong about the "useless" part, We have found endless uses for it. It cuts drywall like butter, makes plunge cuts, cuts the bottoms off door jambs to allow for new flooring, sands into corners, and this week only, special for you, it clears grout out of joints easy peasy. Mine is a Bosch and I like it,but there are others. Be sure to get one that accepts universal cutters.
In the hand tools area, go to the department where they sell tile board and such and find the scoring tool. It a handle with a "T" shaped head. On each side there is a single carbide tooth, sort of like a tooth off a saw blade. Very useful for scraping out grout.
Silicone and gasoline do not mix. I'm not a chemist so I don't know what happens chemically, but I know from personal experience that silicone will swell and lose its grip when exposed to gasoline. I tried to make a replacement gasket for a fuel tank in a boat and it failed in just a few weeks, even though the silicone was fully cured before it was exposed to gasoline.
Unfortunately this doesn't help in a bathroom situation.
…and you might find it helpful for removing the silicone as well. The putty knife blade that Fein supplies with their MultiMaster (the original, and still the best multitool, IMHO) should peel it right off. It also lifts linoleum (or whatever it is called these days) tiles, and just about anything stuck down to a hard substrate with a flexible adhesive. The carbide toothed grout file is indispensible for tile jobs. About the only major feature I don't use on mine is the sanding head, but that's because I'm spoiled by my Festool RO-90 and the abrasives that are available for it.
William is right. The scraper blades will help a lot removing the silicone. (And I suspect he is right about the Fien version as well. Never used one personally, but it looks like a good tool to me. I have the Bosch battery powered version and I had the Bosch 3 Amp corded one until it was stolen. The corded one is significantly more powerful than the 12 volt battery one.) The scraper is like the rest of the tool. We keep finding more and more uses for it.
Once, on a call back on one of my inspections they new owner complained the shower leaked. We ran it for a long time and nothing happened. He practically whined that when his wife took a shower water ran out of the ceiling below. I was about to tell her to take a shower, but used my clip board to splash water on the walls. It was like a flood. There were tiny bits of grout missing here and there and that was enough. (I am talking really tiny, way less than a tenth of a percent of the grout.) He re-grouted and sealed the grout and all was well. The previous owners had been "bath" people and never used the shower. There was no clue that there was a leak. Its now a standard part of my reports to caution people that tiny defects in the grout can lead to leaks.
About 12 years ago we discovered it had leaked for sometime. The end result was I had to rip it out, replace several studs, have termites eliminated. I then rebuilt it from slab up. This involved building a new pan, thick membrane (pvc?), tar paper and Hardi-board. About 5 years ago we had a leak around the door curb. At that time I cut out the floor grout using a Dremel Multi tool, re-grouted and sealed. This took care of the problem until now. I can't see back into the faucet or riser head to determine if it is leaking there. I can see the bottom sill where there is water from the leak but can't tell it's path.
I think the issue might be somewhere around the curb but will hold off on removing tile until I try the re-grout.
Barry, it is interesting because it does leak much more when my wife takes her long shower than when I take my shorter ones. I did try turning the water on and letting it run for a long time but didn't get the larger leak. I think the difference in how we shower probably changes the splash.
By the way, I hate plumbing but with the prices and not knowing how the work will be done I have learned to handle it.
The Fein is the only multitool I have personal operating experience with, but I've worked with a guy who has tried several of the others. A difference that becomes obvious is the temperature of the head, and how fast it heats up. The difference in the drive mechanisms, and therefore the amount of power wasted in friction (which can be extrapolated into the long term wear on the machines) can be\ substantial. The Fein runs cool all day, but all of the other machines warm up to a lesser or much greater extent. I don't have any figures on temperature rise for any particular machine, but a couple of them quickly become uncomfortably hot.
Stuart, Having been a Home Inspector for almost thirty years, my attitude toward many things has changed. One of them is showers. (I am now a big time believer in proper grading and drainage, wide over hangs, gutters and downspouts, dry crawl spaces, and.....) For showers, I believe in redundancy. If I were building one today I would use treated lumber, line it with a permanent water proof liner tucked into the pan, Tile Board, and inner liner, and tile with grout and seal the grout.
Until recently it was considered very low end practice to use Green Board or other water resistant drywall as a tile board. Now I am seeing "Schluter" which is a liner material put over ordinary drywall. (Made by the same people that make Ditra) It appears to be a water proof sheet product about the thickness of polyethylene with fuzzy faces similar to the felt face on hook and loop sandpaper. You install the drywall, trowel on thinset or other adhesive, cover it with the Schluter and trowel on another layer of thinset and apply the tile. Its not quite that simple. There are manufactured corner pieces to cover the difficult inside and out side corners. I have too problems with this. If you get a pin hole leak, the water will destroy the drywall. And as an Inspector, I can't see it. I am betting that the Rednecks installing it don't bother with the fancy details. I bet they skip those relatively expensive little corner pieces. At least, when push comes to shove and they run out, I bet they decide you don't need them in this particular instance.
There are manufactured corner pieces to cover the difficult inside and out side corners. I have too problems with this. If you get a pin hole leak, the water will destroy the drywall. And as an Inspector, I can't see it. I am betting that the Rednecks installing it don't bother with the fancy details. I bet they skip those relatively expensive little corner pieces. At least, when push comes to shove and they run out, I bet they decide you don't need them in this particular instance.
I'm the Redneck that built this shower after I ripped out the original. I researched as much as I could and unfortunately did not find out about corner pieces until a couple years too late. The instructions I had involved folding the membrane and gluing the folds. I think this probably is the root of my issue especially on the curb. There more than likely isn't a 100 % cure without ripping out the floor and building a new shower from the slab up. This is not something I care to tackle but might be the final solution. The saving grace if I have to do it over is I know more about it plus I don't have to try and fit it in while working 10 to 12 hours six days a week.