Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Doors warping - spruce lumber for sets?

Posts

Doors warping - spruce lumber for sets?

#1

JL

Doors warping - spruce lumber for sets?

JL

I build sets for the local theatre group. Little or no budget - therefore I have to use spruce or equivalent lumber from the building supply company.

The 2 x 4s and such are stored outside under metal roofs but are otherwise exposed to the elements. I always take care to get straight lumber without a lot of blemishes or knots.

I've built some "French" doors out of ripped 2 x 4s (ripped to 3" or so). By the time they've sat for a couple of days, they have a tendency to warp a bit. Not quite to the potato chip stage :b , but not pretty. Typically one side is out by 1 1/2" or so.

Thoughts for solutions? I've time invested in them, but I'd rather they look right - and have the ability to store them for future uses.

Should I go to Home Depot or Lowes and use their 2 x 4 stud lumber? It has the advantage of being in an air conditioned building and is probably drier (or not).

Should I search for near quarter sawn lumber at H.D. or the building supply place?

Any other solutions?

Again - we have a small budget.

Re: Doors warping - spruce lumber for sets?

#2

Re: Doors warping - spruce lumber for sets?

Stuart Johnson

I don't know if there is any truth in this but will pass it on.

To get the best straight grain 2x4's buy 2x6's and rip them. I think the theory is you can select where in the board will give you the best outcome.

I don't know which "tip of the month" I heard about it. I'm sure there is a lot of waste but it could be used for other projects.

Re: Doors warping - spruce lumber for sets?

#3

I was going to say.....

Barry Irby

Pretty much the same thing, except, buy 2 x 10's or 12's and rip them. They Almost surely are from larger trees. Most (all) for the 2x4's and Lowe's and Home Depot come right out of the center of the tree. or they are cutting trees just barely large enough to get a 4x4 and ripping it into two 2x4's. Either way, it juvenile wood and the least stable part of the tree. May have 30 times the expansion and contraction characteristics of the rest of the wood.

I used to build some rustic furniture out of framing lumber. I bought the biggest pieces they had and stored them indoors for a while (6 mo. or a year). It would be good if you could buy some stock and stash it, but you may not have the luxury.

Have you checked with Habitat? They might have some salvaged lumber they would sell cheap and it might be dry.

Re: Doors warping - spruce lumber for sets?

#4

Re: I was going to say.....

Tony - Memphis

Seems like I read recently about something along those lines and cutting the 2x6,8,10 or whatever in such a way that your small pieces were rift or quarter sawn and would tend to be more stable?

Tony

Re: Doors warping - spruce lumber for sets?

#5

MDF

Dick Coers

If you have little or no budget, rip and laminate MDF. Assuming paint grade of course. 2x4s are definitely not the way to go, but you know that already.

Re: Doors warping - spruce lumber for sets?

#6

Re: Doors warping - spruce lumber for sets?

don stephan

Years ago I decided to economize by making my woodworking bench top from southern yellow pine. The smallest yellow pine framing lumber in cincinnati at that time was 2x8, and I expected ripping them would give me two 1.5" x 3" pieces. About 1/4 moved so much during ripping they weren't useable. I expect that trees grown for framing lumber today are extremely fast growing. I also don't think framing lumber is dried to 8% - there is still a lot of moisture in kiln dried framing lumber.

You might be able to find 4x8 sheets of baltic birch plywood, which would be very stable and not as heavy as MDF. You might also be able to find light weight MDF.

Re: Doors warping - spruce lumber for sets?

#7

Re: MDF

David Yoho

Last I looked, MDF doesn't hold up well around moisture. I've seen cabinet doors and drawer fronts in kitchens and bathrooms made with it that was swollen from being in a moist environment. Since it would be stored outside for periods of time and subject to moisture, I don't think it's a better alternative. I hear there is MDF available now that is better in this situation but know nothing about it and it has to cost more, probably not in his budget.

Re: Doors warping - spruce lumber for sets?

#8

Re: Doors warping - spruce lumber for sets?

C. John Hebert

Using framing lumber for finished products is almost certainly doomed for failure. Most framing lumber has about 18-24% moisture content and you'd have to store it inside a heated shop with a dehumidifier going for at least a month...maybe even 2 months. In drying it out...it has to be close to the ceiling on lumber racks and not on the floor. It also has to be stuck with stickers so that air can pass all around them as they dry and even with that...framing lumber is chancy to use.

Re: Doors warping - spruce lumber for sets?

#9

Wasn't he talking about theater sets?

Dick Coers

What's water resistance have to do with theater sets? It's not a production of "Singing in the Rain" is it?

Re: Doors warping - spruce lumber for sets?

#10

MDF and painted grain...

John in NM

Amazing effects can be had with paint. I remember a set at a 1 act competition when I was in HS, everything was painted on flats, picture frames, door molding, etc. Under the lights you couldn't tell.

So I too would make the doors out of MDF, and then paint wood grain on when called for.

Or maybe laminate 1x pine to make them if actual wood were required.

Re: Doors warping - spruce lumber for sets?

#11

JL

Dust?

JL

I'd wouldn't want to do it at the theatre - which doesn't have a system.

Re: Doors warping - spruce lumber for sets?

#12

My Mistake

David Yoho

I went back and saw where he was saying the 2x4's at the local lumber place were stored outside. What I thought he said was they stored the not-in-use set parts outside under a roof without side protection until needed another time.

The MDF could work like you said.