Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

water based stain problem

Posts

water based stain problem

#1

water based stain problem

Jerry Gibbs

I tried using General Finishes water based stain on red oak. I have used it before and know the problem of trying to stain too large an area. It is difficult to wipe out an even coat. Aware of this issue I tried to limit myself to manageable areas. I have two 25" square panels. The first I could not evenly wipe out. The second I tried to stop at a glue line, but that didn't work. I think I have evenly sanded the panels to 220. Any suggestions on how to start over and how to apply this stuff are appreciated. If I can sand or otherwise remove the stain I am not against buying an oil based product, but I should be able to use this stuff.

The rest of the project is an end table with slats on the sides. Do I have to tape off each slat and do them one at a time to use this stuff? Jerry

Re: water based stain problem

#2

Re: water based stain problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I can't help solving the waterborne problem but I can say that I never have any problem staining any sized area of any complexity with an oil based stain. No doubt, slow drying is the oil stain advantage that aids uniform application. . And non-grain raising is another advantage. I like Minwax "golden oak" on oak for a lighter color.

Re: water based stain problem

#3

Re: water based stain problem

Merle

It might be that the stain is drying too fast. You can try staining early in the AM while it is still cool and the relative humidity is a little higher. Another option would be to add a retarder to the stain. I use Target Products SA5 for spraying, but you would need to check to see what is compatible with your stain.

You might try diluting the stain and applying a few weaker coats to sneak up on the desired color. That way you would have a little better control over the color, but I have never done this myself. HTH

Re: water based stain problem

#4

Re: water based stain problem

don stephan

I have used their water based stains a few times, once on a large boat top dining tablel. The stain is a gel formulation, and trying to put it on thinly may cause problems, as it does dry quickly. On some scrap, try spreading it as a wet coat, wiping back and forth over the entire surface while it is still thick enough to remain wet, then begin quickly wiping off from one side to the other the excess with a clean paper towel or two. Keep working the entire surface until it is all dry.

Re: water based stain problem

#5

Re: water based stain problem

Dick Coers

I don't care for water based stains as they all look muddy to me. I have had success applying them. I use a foam pad painter that holds a ton of stain. I can flood the entire surface with one filling of the pad painter and then wipe and clean up the surface. You will use more stain than usual, but no overlap or dry lines.

Re: water based stain problem

#6

Re: water based stain problem *LINK*

David Yoho

When in doubt, always check the manufacturer for tips. When I first read your post I was thinking "dye stain" but then looked closer where you indicated "wood stain". A dye can often be applied with spray equipment giving better results. GF actually indicates their wood stain can be applied by hand or spraying. Have a look at the page linked below for their tips on hand and spray applications to see if it helps resolve your issue.


GF Water Base Finishing Tips

Re: water based stain problem

#7

Re: water based stain problem

gary peterson

read where you can lightly mist surface prior to applying stain, that way the wood absorbs the stain uniformily. I dye alot, must work fast...if there is an application line between swipes I flood the line and press down a bit and work the area to get a uniform look.

Re: water based stain problem

#8

Ellis Walentine

Which stain?

Ellis Walentine

Jerry, General Finishes makes both pigment and dye stains in waterbased formulations. You didn't say which one you were using, but I wouldn't expect lap marks from either if you've flooded the surface and wiped off the excess. The exception would be if you were using dye stain and wanted a color lighter than that naturally produced by the stain. Otherwise, a thorough wetting of the surface should dry to a uniform color.

By the way, I'm a firm believer in using a dye stain to extablish a base color and follow up with a pigment stain to add depth and glazing. The two coat approach produces a much richer and more authentic looking color than either stain alone, especially on ring-porous woods like oak.

Ellis

Re: water based stain problem

#9

Re: Which stain?

Stephen W. Schoene

The GF dye stains are not dyes, but are really toners, since they include a waterborne binder. That makes them work much differently than water-based dyes. Once the binder sets the overlap is quite possible. A true dye, such as powdered water soluble dyes give much more working time, and the ability to correct problems. TransFast and W.D. Lockwood are both good choices.

Re: water based stain problem

#10

Re: Which stain?

Jerry Gibbs

pigment, not dye.

Re: water based stain problem

#11

Ellis Walentine

Good to know, Steve

Ellis Walentine

I've used several of the GF waterbased dye stains without lapping incidents. Is this because I hit it all at once and wiped it off quickly?

Ellis

Re: water based stain problem

#13

Re: this doesn't have dye in it?

Stephen W. Schoene

The GF dye stain does contain dye, but it is mixed with an acrylic binder, rather than a pure solvent. If you work fast enough it will give color without obscuring figure. Once it dries it's permanent short of stripping. With a water based dye, you can redissolve it in water to make it lighter or to eliminate problems. With water based dye you flood it on--a sponge is good, working from the bottom to the top. If you drip dye onto dye that is still wet, a swipe with the sponge eliminates the problem. You control the intensity of color of dye by how concentrated you mix the solution.