Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

Posts

Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

#1

Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

Barry Irby

My son made some ice cream following the old family recipe. Turned out delicious but grainy. He used 2% milk. (also eggs and sugar and flavoring) Scalded the milk and cooked the custard, let it cool overnight.

Any idea why its grainy with ice crystals? I'm thinking that when I made it I used whole milk and supplemented that with some cream. (Back in my youth I lived on a dairy farm and we made it out of pure cream. It was so rich you couldn't eat much of it.)

Re: Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

#2

Re: Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The answer to your question is to not use what is remembered as "an old family recipe" and then arbitrarily modify it. We make ice cream frequently. The Alton Brown vanilla is an excellent choice for a workhorse vanilla.

I don't prefer making the fruit ice creams overly rich (strawberry, peach ). But Cherries Garcia from the Ben and Jerry book.... that is another story (BTW triple the cherries). Lots of creme.

Re: Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

#3

Re: Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

My guess is that either the sugar didn't dissolve or there's not enough fat. I use whole milk, and dextrose instead of cane sugar and have never had a problem. I don't cook it either (I use organic eggs) - just mix up the batch then put it in the frig for a while and then make it.

Recipe for a 6 qt. freezer:

6 eggs, beaten

3 c sugar

1 to 2 T vanilla (or ½ t for other than vanilla ice cream)

1 can sweetened condensed milk

1/2 gallon of milk

Beat eggs - add sugar and condensed milk

Add rest slowly & mix well

Put in ice cream freezer and follow freezer directions

If making strawberry or other flavors, reduce vanilla to 1/2 tsp. and add approx. 2 cups of fruit.

(I use a bit more fruit, and I puree it in a blender first. You might need to reduce the amount of milk to get it to fit in the ice cream freezer container, which shouldn't be more than ~ 80% full when you start.)

Re: Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

#4

Re: Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

del schisler

i was born on a farm and milked 15 head of cow's 2 time's a day , and we would make ice cream all the time, i don't remember scolding the milk ? all i remember was using the milk and vanilla flav. and what they called junkit tablet's ? mixed that up and put in the old ice cream mixer and i was the oldest so i got the crank, no electric tell 1947 , we would get the ice out of the horse tank, in the winter, and if in the summer , go to town and get it from the ice house, after it was made we got to lick the paddle , sure was good, but than we would pack it for a couple hours before it was served , sure was good , i belive it was a gal size mix, didn't last long, maybe the reasion for the ice crystles and grit may been the boiling the milk ? i would give it another try and not boil or heat the milk , of course you can't get good milk,

Re: Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

#5

terry gearhart

Re: Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

terry gearhart

Hi there, the following is my fathers recipe.

Real creamy and no worries about the sugar

Crystalizing :

Ice Cream

(Gimpy)

Makes 6 quarts

9 eggs

3 cups 10x sugar

3 cans evaporated milk

2 cans eagle brand condensed milk

vanilla

1 large box of instant vanilla or French vanilla pudding

chocolate to flavor or fruit of your choice.

Mix all well, add milk to fill line.

Re: Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

#6

Re: Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

Gerry in North Surrey

Barry, ya gotta use cream, that's why they call it ice cream. The crystals are frozen water.

Gerry, who's never made the stuff but sure sold lots of it.

Re: Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

#7

Yes, cream

John Pappas

Why bother if it isn't made with cream. I don't indulge often, but when I do it's the real thing.

Son of a candy and ice cream maker....who helped, and pretended to be in charge of quality control. Meaning I tasted a lot while helping.

Re: Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

#8

Bob

Re: Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

Bob

We made gallons of banana and black cherry this year. No 2% use cream, its ice cream. LOL

Re: Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

#9

Re: Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Ice freezes at 32°, ice cream at about 22°. Sugar and butterfat act as antifreeze and lower the freezing point. Eliminate either and the percentage of the other MUST go up. Fat free IC is not low calorie because of the added sugar. Make it right and you will be satisfied with smaller amounts, therefore, fewer calories. Low calorie IC is manufactured with all kinds of CRUD to make it smooth and soft. There are no four syllable words in real ice cream.

Re: Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

#10

Re: Anybody make Ice Cream? (OT)

john Veerkamp

You can get smooth desert using 2%. The trick is in the right mixture of salt and ice. I've made it successfully, but I'm not home now and can't give you the proper proportions now. As I recall you freeze it slower to keep the concoction smooth. Google and you can find lots of receipes. As others said it may be good, just not old fashioned ice cream.

Good eating!