Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

unfreezing stuck steel.....

Posts

unfreezing stuck steel.....

#1

unfreezing stuck steel.....

Edward in Vancouver

This Saturday I lucked out and bought a circa '40's era Delta Milwaukee drill press (dp 240) for the princely sum of $75.00.

Other than some minor surface rust and a layer of filth, the machine is in great shape. The motor is 1/3 hp made in the '40's, runs well and weighs almost as much as my 3/4 hp bandsaw motor.

After cleaning all of the crud off (column took me well over an hour!) I realized the handle on the quill lever is frozen in place. Normally the handle is held in place by a wingnut that is tapped into the end of the quill lever.

So far I've been drenching the lever and handle junction with "liquid wrench" over two days, light taps with a 6 oz tack hammer and a few licks with a propane torch. It ain't moving...

I'll continue with this for a few more days, then I'll try an old bike mechanic's trick* for removing stuck seat posts from bike frames: Heat up the frame with a torch, and shoot a cartridge of co2 on the seatpost which pretty much freezes it. These are 'emergency" co2 cartridges cyclists use to inflate tires when a pump isn't handy.

Is this adviseable? Or are there any other tricks out there I could use?

Regards,

Edward

The other bike mechanic's trick I learned--when I was 12-- was to install and remove handlebar grips with hairspray......

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

#2

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

Keith Newton

Ask at a boat supply store. Back when I lived on a yacht, I had spray can of something that the former captain had left in the supply room which was really good, but I don't recall what it called. But maintaining boats that live in saltwater requires tough solutions.

Can you cut it from the back with an abrasive blade?

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

#3

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

Barry Irby

I am thinking you are trying to to work on the lever or handle that rotated the shaft that raises and lowers the quill/chuck and bit? Th quill works fine, but the handle is stuck in the shaft? So you could use the drill press, but you can't change the position of the lever?

Someone here suggested using either brake fluid or transmission fluid. I think it was transmission fluid, but I forgot and used brake fluid. Soaked and incredibly rusted bolt for a few days and then could turn it by hand.

In the case of my DP I would probably have to lay it on its side to arrange a container to soak the end of the shaft. I can visualize a pan with an inch of fluid. Or you might wrap it with a rag and soak the rag with the fluid or Liquid Wrench. Other than that, keep doing what you are doing. I have always been reluctant to use too much heat for fear of ruining the temper. Patience is your friend. And persistence.

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

#4

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

Tom Dunlap

Aerokroil or Kroil is the best rust solvent I've found. PB Blaster is #2.

Lets us know how the heat/cold work!

Tom

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

#5

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

Use some 320 grit or finer paper to remove the rust from the rod as close to the shaft as possible. Then soak it for a couple of days with light oil or brake fluid. Then give it a good whack with a 12 oz hammer. It should move onto the cleaned area. If some one tightened the wing nut too tight they might have scored the rod so it is stuck due to a burr on the shaft. If possible remove the rod and shaft from the drill press and set in in a vise so that the shaft is supported by the jaws and the rod can move when you whack it with the hammer.

Lee

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

#6

this works

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I had a stuck set screw. A person with a a career in maintenance told me the same thing that you suggested. Soak in penetrating lubricant for a day or two and then whack it. I did and it came loose as easy as if it had never been stuck. The whack must open a channel that enables the penetrant to enter.

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

#7

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

R Payne

If you can manage it, electrolysis.

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

#8

tell us more

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In theory, I don't see that it would be useful. The current in the restricted stuck part would be essentially zero. But, if you have experience with it working it would be good to know.

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

#9

Re: tell us more

Edward in Vancouver

Tried the hot/cold thing tonight with a propane torch and a c02 cartridge, having first "sanded" rust and crud off the handle with 320 grit paper and wd40. With light taps of the hammer it slid out quite nicely.

The more I work on that machine, the more I appreciate it's quality and durability, and I am totally in love with the cast iron "Bonnet" and decal that covers the quill pulley cone. I haven't found an owner's manual for it yet, but have found the "Delta Homecraft drill press" version on one of the websites. I believe the Homecraft and the 200 series drill presses shared a lot of common parts and similiar construction.

I also found the Delta "Getting more out of your drill press" booklet on line which I believe is from the same era (1940's). Using a drill press with a max of 5,000 rpm as a router was something I never considered, (it was even illustrated with the head mounted upside down on the column, underneath the table with the bit poking up through the table...) but then again, the manual uses a dedicated spindle to hold the router bits, not the 1/2" chuck. Scary business.........

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

#10

Re: tell us more

Chuck in Mtl.

I have used the technique of heating and cooling the part to loosen it. I used a propane torch to het it and then WD40 applied liberally to cool the part. I repeated this 4 to 5 times and finally the part loosened.

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

#11

Kneale Brownson

Kroil is my favorite penetrant

Kneale Brownson

But I've also had similar successes using a 50-50 mix of acetone and ATF (automatic transmission fluid).

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

#12

Re: tell us more

R Payne

I've use it to free small parts. My first experience was on a found pocket knife that the blades were rusted shut on.

I used a simple saltwater solution, hooking the knife to the negative side of a nine volt battery and using a bit of copper wire hooked to the positive side.

It can be hard to get a large enough vessel for large items, but I've had success with small items.

ron

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

#13

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

Brian from Monument

There was a test of unfreezing stuck nuts on threaded rods on one of the machinist pages.

That ranked a bunch of substances to be used.

As Kneale points out the number 1 and number 2 ranked items in the charts

1. a 50-50 mix of acetone and ATF (automatic transmission fluid).

2. Kroil

As a gunsmith, I use kroil for a lot of things.

But we can fall back on the old heat game.

Heating up metal is risky as it damages the finish and alters the tempering.

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

#14

not the best arrangement

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The solution should be sodium carbonate (washing soda available in laundry section). A chloride solution will promote further rusting in the future unless it is thoroughly cleaned from steel. A copper anode will dissolve, which in itself is not a problem, but the dissolved copper will find its was to the steel and plate upon it, which will promote further corrosion. Use a stainless steel anode- spoon, fork, screen, etc.

A friend does this in a 55 gallon barrel with a battery charger and a stainless steel mesh for the anode.

While I have derusted stuff I never considered that it would be effective for stuck stuff. Will try it.

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

#15

Re: not the best arrangement

R Payne

I have not doubts there are better ways to do it, that was just what I had on hand to try on a project I had nothing to lose on.

I have read that stainless steel shouldn't be used as the anode. The anode will eventually corrode away regardless of what it is and the reason given for not using stainless is that it can create hexavalent chromium which is rather nasty. I don't know if this is correct or just how much of a danger it is, just something I read.

The last time I used electrolysis I used a bit of rebar for the anode.

ron

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

#16

Electrolysis myths about stainless steel

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Try as I might to stomp out this myth I remain not only unsuccessful , but occasionally some earnest person with more environmental concern than knowledge emails me to warn, and often threaten, me to stop advocating stainless steel as an anode. I particularly enjoy dealing with those that threaten to bring the regulatory forces of local, state and federal governments down upon my head, and maybe mother nature to boot. Where's the data to support your case, I ask?

Stainless steel will not dissolve in your lifetime. If it doesn't dissolve it can't make Chromate .

But since the myth persists, and maybe some tiny amount may dissolve, I sampled my friends 55 gallon electrolysis bath which he had used for months with a stainless steel screen (probably 304) and analyzed it for total chromium in any soluble form, chromium III being the likely species present if there was any. I no longer remember the exact value, but the chromium present was about 1 milligram per liter, a value so low as to be of no concern to me.

That said, I do not recommend drinking an electrolysis bath in any case. It may have been exposed to lead or cadmium pigmented paint.

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

#17

Re: Electrolysis myths about stainless steel

R Payne

You tested the bath. How about the sludge at the bottom of the tank?

If you don't think you're doing any harm, I'm not in a position to stop you. I'm not going to risk it. I'll stick with mild steel anodes.

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

#18

Re: Electrolysis myths about stainless steel

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Chromate ("chrom 6") is soluble in sodium carbonate solution. No point in analyzing the sludge, all of which came from what ever was being cleaned.

Rebar has a small chromium content. Given that it will dissolve during electrolysis one is left with a dilemma. Use rebar and be assured that some chromium is dissolving in the bath, likely as benign trivalent chromium, or use stainless steel and know that but a tiny amount of the anode is dissolving with the resulting advantage that the bath and anode stay useful forever.

Re: unfreezing stuck steel.....

#19

Re: Electrolysis myths about stainless steel

R Payne

Chromate may be soluble in sodium carbonate solution but is it still soluble with all of the ions that go into solution from whatever got stripped in that bath?

You don't know. You can't know everything that was applied to everything that got stripped. And since you didn't test the sludge, you methodology was flawed therefore your conclusions are invalid.