I am an artist working with black and white ebony, also known as pale moon ebony. I'd like to know if this wood is toxic, and suitable to eat off of (turned bowl) or as a utensil.
If it is toxic, would anyone know of a specific non-toxic glaze or finish that could be used to make the wood useable for this purpose.
Re: black and white ebony and it's toxicity *LINK*
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
Ebony is much like walnut in that it is an irritant and a sensitizer. I use walnut bowls for salad without incident. I cannot, however, tell you with any confidence whether eating out of an ebony bowl presents a hazard.
I can opine, however, that short of saturating wood with epoxy to make a composite material, there is no coating that could be relied upon to render a dangerous wood safe for food use. Any film-forming finish you might use will fail, crack, and peel or chip off. This is why any turning I make for use (treenware) is finished with food grade mineral oil and wax. It's simple and easily renewed.
That reference is not necessarily even identifying the wood you are interested in, and no mention that I found was for the wood, itself. You will have to find an online translation service for the description that is in Latin. You might try Babel Fish first. There are many references to the medicinal properties of the fruit, but none of that is applicable to the wood. I would strongly suggest that you do the googling yourself, and carefully read the scholarly articles that come up. That being said, you are going to have to seal it anyway to plug the worm holes, else your vessels will leak. All the black wood is the result of reaction of the tree to the worm damage or perhaps to a pathogen that invaded the wood following the worms. I do not know whether it is the same pathogen mentioned in the article that Mark references.
If I were going to seal it or impregnate it (different processes), my first choice would be West System epoxy, 105 resin and 207 hardener. Also, you, as a woodworker, run a much greater risk of being sensitized to any ebony, or any other wood, than your customers, who will only be exposed to solid wood, and not the dust.
The scientific name for black and white ebony is Diospyros malabarica. It is similar to black and white striped mun ( or "moon") ebony which is a different species, Diospyros mun. The Diospyros genus is fairly large and includes, among others, the North American persimmon.
Re: black and white ebony and it's toxicity *LINK*
Hank Knight
The link below will take you to a database that discusses the toxicity of various woods. Just enter the scientific name in the search window and it will pull up lots of info on both black and white ebony and mun ebony, including toxicity data.
My apologies forr the confusion, but it appears that D. peregrina and D. malabarica are synonymous. I don't have access to the type specimens, so I cannot verify that, even to my own satisfaction, much less to the satisfaction of the taxonomic authorities on the genus.
All I could find at your link was a generic mention of the possibility of all Diospyros being sensitizers, but nothing specific on Indian Persimmon. But even Acer saccaratum is a possible sensitizer. IMHO, nobody really knows much about the ebonies.
I agree that , beyond being identified as sensitizers and/or an irritants, there's not much information about other possible toxic properties of ebonies. One would have to think, however, because ebonies have been a treasured woods in many cultures for centuries, any direct toxic properties they might have would be known and reported. One poster above, maybe you, noted that contact with a chunk of wood known to be a sensitizer or an irritant is less likely to cause a bad reaction than contact with the dust from that wood. I think that is probably the practical answer to the OP's question.
I thank you both for your looking at this.. It has been a real struggle to find out the definitive answer to this.. including higher ed and wood tables that only go so far as to say the already stated as a dust.. I wonder if your suggestion of sealing this particular species, either with mineral oil/wax or epoxy/resin would allow for uses with food ?
Might anyone suggest a few exotic hardwoods or domestic hardwoods that i may use for this purpose (functional/eating/bowl/utensil) as an alternative?
As I said earlier, it is my view that if ebony posed a direct toxic threat, I.E., was poisonous or a carcinogen, we would know about it, given ebony's wide use over the years. As for as the finish you choose, that would depend on the nature of your project. Encapsulating the wood in a film finish is seldom satisfactory unless the object will not be subject to handling, moisture or other abuse that would almost invariably cause the finish to crack and peel. Once that process starts, the only fix is to strip the finish off and refinish it. Marine woodwork with a spar varnish finish is a classic example of this - it requires regular attention, including refinishing. Most treen ware (bowls, utensils, etc. meant for cooking and eating), if they have any finish at all, are finished with an "in-the-wood" finish - something that penetrates the wood fibers and offers a little polish and protection, like food-safe mineral oil. There are also commercially available "salad bowl" finishes that are based on some kind of food safe penetrating oil. Even these finishes require reapplication periodically if they are subject to moisture or washing, especially with soaps or detergents. Their advantage is that they don't peel. Some woods can be polished to a high shine without a finish. These are mostly dense tropical hardwoods, and ebony is one of them. Ebony is known for it's ability to take a high shine. FWIW, I was a in China for several weeks this Spring. Most high-end restaurants there provided ebony chopsticks and spoons, and ebony eating utensils were available for purchase everywhere. They appeared to be polished only, with no finish. These were usually Macassar or some other dark ebony. I don't recall seeing any black and white ebony pieces. I frequently ate with them during my visit and suffered no ill effects that I could detect. Given the Chinese government's attitude toward environmental issues, this may or may not be helpful. I just thought I'd pass it on.
Sorry I can't give you more specific information. I'm sure someone has a definitive answer to your question, but it's not me.