Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

That desk I am making for my daughter

Posts

That desk I am making for my daughter

#1

That desk I am making for my daughter

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

So, last week I showed you how I screwed up the drawer using my router routing grooves for the drawer bottom. It made me mad for several reasons. One being I had cut the drawer front from the middle of the drawer apron so it would be an exact match grain wise and on.

I got over it. I milled out a new piece from the same board for a new drawer front. Grain won't match, but I'm going to try and 'hide' that by putting cock beading around it. I've never done that, so I may end up making a third drawer front...

Anyway, it's turning out ok so far. I even was able to start cutting the DT's.

ETA: I also made new drawer sides. This time out of some ash. Not sure why I used ash instead of poplar, but should be okay I guess. The drawer runners will be screwed on so they can be replaced someday if needed.

While I was working on it, my daughter called to let us know her boyfriend proposed to her. :)

The drawer so far:


Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#2

cock bead hints

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.



The aux fence makes sawing the bead trivial. Go slow and use a sharp rip blade to prevent chipping. Do make triple sure the drawer is oriented right. I went absent minded and sawed 90 degrees to what was needed once.

You may tend to think the bead should be thicker than what will in fact look best. For a small drawer something less than 1/8" is preferred by most. The beads on my drawers are 0.110. "

To aid installation I clamp a board to the drawer front that has a rabbit cut from the edge at a depth that I want the cock bead to stand proud of the front. I push the bead strip against the rabbit surface to establish the distance it will stick out from the drawer front and nail it on.

Shellac, sand and then wax the drawer sides and they will slide like skates on ice.

PS Note: flaunting of dovetails is restricted to Hand Tool Forum :)

Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#3

Questions

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks for taking the time to offer your tips Bill.

"The aux fence makes sawing the bead trivial."

Are you showing your setup to cut the rabbet that the cock bead will sit in?

Question: is your rip fence exactly parallel to the blade? Or is it skewed out a bit at the back of the blade.

"For a small drawer something less than 1/8" is preferred by most."

I think my only option will be to rip some thin stock and use a scratch block to create the bead profile on. I did this once for a round Shaker candle stand top, and it worked well. It will be something less than 1/8". I'll have to look back in some old FWW magazines to remember how to safely rip thin stock. Actually, for the small amount I will need, a couple quick passes with sandpaper will create the bead I suspect.

"To aid installation I clamp a board to the drawer front that has a rabbit cut from the edge at a depth that I want the cock bead to stand proud of the front."

I think I understand what you are saying.

"PS Note: flaunting of dovetails is restricted to Hand Tool Forum"

Sorry. Not sure what I was thinking. :)

Thanks for your help.

Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#4

answers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Are you showing your setup to cut the rabbet that the cock bead will sit in?.....yes

Question: is your rip fence exactly parallel to the blade? Or is it skewed out a bit at the back of the blade........I don't know. Never check it.

I think my only option will be to rip some thin stock and use a scratch block to create the bead profile on.......A 7 1/2" blade, 40T is ideal for ripping thin stock. There are all manner of aids, but I just sent the fence at 1/8", grab a thin push stick and shove it through. After smoothing it wound up 0.110" in my case and that looked ok so that is what I used.

"To aid installation I clamp a board to the drawer front that has a rabbit cut from the edge at a depth that I want the cock bead to stand proud of the front." ......


Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#5

Bob

Re: answers *LINK*

Bob

This is a good video I found on Fine Woodworking showing a few ways of doing it.


http://www.finewoodworking.com/woodworking-plans/video/two-ways-to-make-cock-beading.aspx

Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#6

Re: answers

William Duffield

Very interesting video, Bob. We recently had a discussion here on the relative advantages and disadvantages of completely or partially covering the bottom of the drawer front with the cock bead. The video shows that Steve Latta, who both Bill and I accept as an authority, prefers to completely cover the bottom. I guess I'm going to have to start doing it the same way they do it.

Also, as an aside, note that Steve is using his bench-on-bench for yet another detailed operation (other than decorating table legs with inlay stringing, patarae, etc.).

Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#7

while we are name dropping.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Mack Headley shop covers full on bottom too, which is where I learned.

I was checking out a well made cherry chest of drawers at Hillsville market last week and it has full on top, partial on bottom and even less on sides. So now we have three ways of doing it.

Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#8

Bob

Slipped right by me

Bob

Thanks Bill

Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#9

Re: cock bead hints

Sgian Dubh

"PS Note: flaunting of dovetails is restricted to Hand Tool Forum."

They are a bit odd looking though aren't they? Usually the tails are significantly wider than the pins, especially on drawer fronts where a decorative element is usually part of the equation, but in this case the tails and pins are about the same size, and the half pins at each edge look a bit heavy. In that drawer I think the joint would have looked better balanced with just two tails. The form seen here is closer to carcase dovetailing where tail and pin size are closer to equal and done for reasons of strength. Slainte.

Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#10

a comment on Steve's way of making the bead

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1. Nobody is going to get a magnifying glass and examine a cock bead profile to see that it is perfect around the drawer. This is one place where the mark of "hand made" can be revealed to good effect. This addition to a drawer can be quick and easy if the maker doesn't get hung up on unnecessary "machine made" perfection. I suppose if the piece was headed for a high end gallery to be sold to someone steeped in machine made precision the goal might be different.

2. I cut the strips and then add the half round profile. I set the scratcher (I think scraper might be a better word) for the stock to bottom out on its holder when I have the half round scraped. It can be easier to mount the profile scraper in a vise and pull the bead stock through it.

3. If some tidying is required, a fine file works , well, fine.

4. It was suggested earlier that the profile could be planed. Indeed, I found this approach to be a quick means to get a profile that will reveal the makers hand upon close scrutiny.

Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#11

This post...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

clears a lot up in my mind.

Thanks!

Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#12

Re: answers

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks Bob for posting this link.

I searched FWW, and didn't see this one.

Thanks.

Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#13

Re: cock bead hints

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"They are a bit odd looking though aren't they?"

I see what you are saying. Thanks for the comment.

Maybe I'll try something a little different next time.

Thanks.

Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#14

The purpose of dovetails

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"especially on drawer fronts where a decorative element is usually part of the equation"

While this statement has become true, especially in studio furniture, it certainly was not the case historically, judging from the dovetails I see on American antique furniture. Which leaves the modern furniture maker with a choice. Your dovetails can become a mark of craftsmanship, as well as a fashion statement, or to coin a phrase "flauntable".

Or, you can make your dovetails "period, or regional, correct" and ignore modern fashion and convention. This later criteria will cover any dovetail one winds up with if the maker gets to define the "period" and region. Every detail of a dovetail shape and execution seems to be regional and time dependent in North American furniture. To that end I have a small drawer in an 1850's piece that looks almost exactly like Joe's dovetails, except in my piece the half blinds are way over cut, common in the day, to hasten waste removal. The drawer remains sound, which after all, is the only judgement that likely has even been made by an owner of these dovetails in the past 150 years.

My advice would be to not get stressed out making dovetails. What ever you wind up with you can claim in good conscience that was how they were made in some previous century and region in a piece of furniture now worth $XXXXX because of its design, and not because of the details of the dovetails holding a drawer together.

Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#15

Bob

Not a problem enjoy


Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#16

Re: The purpose of dovetails

Sgian Dubh

Bill, I realise that there are all sorts of dovetail forms and that each can be 'right' as judged against whatever criteria are applied in a particular case. I simply think the dovetails in Joe's piece look a little 'odd' because I think the proportions of the individual elements could have been set out a little more elegantly, e.g., use just two tails instead of three, and perhaps make the half pins a little more delicate. A little strength would have been lost, but the end result would still have been perfectly functional and long lasting if made as well the pictured example.

When it comes to funny looking dovetails, I think those from the sixteenth and seventeenth century oak and walnut period can look odd, e.g., a 5" deep drawer side with a single dovetail at the front into drawer front, and a couple of cut nails; and even weirder looking to contemporary eyes are Egyptian dovetails where the pin was usually much wider than the tail. Slainte.

Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#17

Re: The purpose of dovetails

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I haven't had any time to work on my desk. Life has been getting in the way.

But I happened across this blog post by Chris Schwarz the other day and thought of this post about dovetails. Just thought it was interesting.

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/techniques/joinery/dovetails-472-flavors

Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#18

that's what I said

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Or, you can make your dovetails "period, or regional, correct" and ignore modern fashion and convention. This later criteria will cover any dovetail one winds up with if the maker gets to define the "period" and region."

My opinions don't carry the weight of prolific article writers but for what it is worth dovetails should be judged like any other joint. Will it hold the furniture together over its useful life? I believe if there was less angst over whether they were flauntable they might be used more often, and that would be good.

This opinion applies to joinery that is not obvious without poking into the piece. On a blanket chest they should look "attractive", which in itself provides wide latitude. On studio furniture they may indeed be an important design element. On something trivial to make they might be the only way to demonstrate the makers proficiency, if this demonstration was important to the maker.

What we can learn from the 476 dovetails is that historically the objective of the joint was to hold something together, and to make the joint as efficiently as possible. It was not a fashion statement nor a mark of the makers skill. What could be seen with the drawers closed served that purpose!

I am reminded of my conversation with Alan Batty who worked in an English furniture factory with a quota of drawers to make each day. The pins were made tiny in the easily carved mahogany fronts not because this was high dovetail fashion, but because this tiny waste could be removed from the hard white oak sides with two saw kerfs and one chisel slice. The relatively soft pins drove like nails into the oak sides. Now days this efficiency is regarded as high fashion.

Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#19

Agreed and...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I just hope to be able to work on this this weekend. The sooner I get it done, the sooner I can drive down to Blacksburg and visit my daughter! She doesn't care what the dt's look like! :D

Have a great weekend.

Thanks.

Re: That desk I am making for my daughter

#20

"more" on the topic

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Once I got over the notion that dovetails must be flauntable I found them much faster to make and less stressful to make. Once I found that I could make them fast I employed them in more places and enjoyed doing it. As I made more of them I became able to make them even faster. Which in turn led to using them even more.

For example, on the desk I dovetailed together a gridded insert for pencils, paper clips and the like. I didn't think much of it. But when a woodworker was scrutinizing the desk they exclaimed when they encountered the dovetailed grid. They were clearly impressed, but should not have been. It likely distracted them from the slightly over sawed tails on the drawers. Slightly over sawed tails are much faster to saw and clean out.