Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Wood ID Help.

Posts

Wood ID Help.

#1

Wood ID Help.

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hi all.

These pictures are of a chest that my Grandfather gave to my mother when she graduated high school in the 40's.

I think it's Walnut.

Do you agree? Butternut maybe?

Thanks.





Re: Wood ID Help.

#2

Re: Wood ID Help.

John Veerkamp

Definitely walnut. It is one of the few woods that actually lightens with UV exposure.

Re: Wood ID Help.

#3

Re: Wood ID Help.

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks!

I knew that plus I hoped others would agree on Walnut.

Re: Wood ID Help.

#4

Bob

Re: Wood ID Help.

Bob

Looks a bit like chestnut to me.

Re: Wood ID Help.

#5

Dale Lenz

agree with John.


Re: Wood ID Help.

#6

Re: Wood ID Help.

Keith Newton

Walnut would be my guess as well.

Did your granddad make it for your Mom, or hire someone? Either way, that was a nice gift for back then. You must come from good people.

I'll bet it would make a great tool-chest if Mom has passed it on. It'd probably be too small to hold all your money though.

Re: Wood ID Help.

#7

Re: Wood ID Help.

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"Did your granddad make it for your Mom, or hire someone?"

No. As I recall, he bought it for her from an antique store that would have been in a small town in central Ohio.

"Either way, that was a nice gift for back then."

Yeah, I know it has always been pretty special to my mom.

"You must come from good people."

:) Thanks. I like to think so!

"I'll bet it would make a great tool-chest if Mom has passed it on."

I've told her many times to put my name on it! Not sure she has though...

"It'd probably be too small to hold all your money though."

Guess I don't have to worry about that one... :(

Re: Wood ID Help.

#8

Walnut ID

Dave Arbuckle, Plano, TX

Is it unfinished on the inside (or anywhere)? Walnut has a distinctive smell, rubbing your finger on a unfinished spot should bring proof of walnut or not. :)

Re: Wood ID Help.

#9

An alternative guess

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When I first looked at it I thought cherry. The color is largely indistinctive. Old cherry with old finish becomes essentially the same color as old walnut with old finish. The areas of grain reversal that show up as dark places throughout the front are more characteristic of cherry than walnut, however the grain in the lower left looks more like walnut. What will distinguish between them is whether there are obvious pores. Each growth ring in walnut will have a porous band, and cherry will not. Search for pores and let us know.

It is a very fine piece of work.

Re: Wood ID Help.

#10

Re: An alternative guess

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"When I first looked at it I thought cherry."

As I recall, my mother has always told me it's Cherry. We are both fans of Cherry. All of our antiques and hers, are much darker though. All of the stuff I've made using Cherry has always gotten a lot darker over the years as well.

All the things I've made have always received just a varnish; no stains.

I've always known, of course, that Cherry tends to darken with age and Walnut to get lighter. I suppose there are many many variables involved, but this kinda surprises me:

"The color is largely indistinctive. Old cherry with old finish becomes essentially the same color as old walnut with old finish."

But maybe you are literally describing 'color' opposed to whether it is light or dark?

"The areas of grain reversal that show up as dark places throughout the front are more characteristic of cherry than walnut, however the grain in the lower left looks more like walnut."

I was thinking Walnut because I see (what I think are) big open pores that look similar to the Walnut I am currently using on the desk I am making. Plus, it is so light compared to other old Cherry pieces (that don't appear to be stained).

"What will distinguish between them is whether there are obvious pores. Each growth ring in walnut will have a porous band, and cherry will not. Search for pores and let us know."

This I find interesting. My next visit there I will take a loupe and try to get a good look at some end grain. I took a look at some scrap Cherry and some scrap Walnut. The Walnut definitely had a 'porous band'. I see the difference now.

I'll let you guys know that are interested what I see next time.

Thanks for all the help.