Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Table Saw Motor

Posts

Table Saw Motor

#1

Table Saw Motor

Kelly M. Robison

I currently have a 2 HP table saw {General}, I just got a brand new 3 HP motor that has all the same specs as the one currently on the saw. It looks like it would be a direct replacement. Should I replace the 2 HP motor for the 3 HP one??? The current one draws about 10 AMPS [220 Volt] and the specs for the 3 HP states it will only draw 12 AMPS; it would give me more power for those hard woods that I am always ripping. What do you all think? Yes or No???

Kelly in Port Orchard

Re: Table Saw Motor

#2

JL

Re: Table Saw Motor

JL

Look to your trunnions. General equipment is built quite solidly. So there shouldn't be a problem - provided the mount is similar. I wouldn't do it on a contractors saw - but with a 2 hp hybrid or cabinet saw (which is what I am presuming you have) - it might be worth it.

However - the usual inexpensive fix is to get a sharp, thin kerf blade. A good Freud, Forrest or whatever. A 2 hp hybrid or cabinet saw is generally powerful enough (pun not intended). I have a 5 hp cabinet saw - because it was only $50 more than the 3 hp at the time I bought it. I can muscle through any hardwood. But with a sharp blade you don't have to. Will you really notice a difference between a 2 hp and a 3 hp? Probably - but a sharp, quality blade would probably make a similar difference.

That being said - go for it. You have the motor on hand. It would take an hour to swap out. If you don't like it - swap it back.

Re: Table Saw Motor

#3

Re: Table Saw Motor

del schisler

see for your self, take a piece and rip it with the motor that is on the saw, now change motor's and than rip the same piece, now you will know if it is better ? if not your choice , use new motor with warrenty and than when warrenty is out change back ? i guess your choice

Re: Table Saw Motor

#4

Re: Table Saw Motor

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Sure - change it. The increased Horse power certainly won't hurt anything and can be a help when running a less than perfectly sharp blade through thick stock. Most decent cabinet saws are offered with (when new) with various HP motor options. For instance my Delta Unisaw could be purchased either with a 3 or 5 HP motor. Most commercial shops will opt for the larger motor for a couple reasons, first they can run a blade longer (dull blades take more hp to cut) so they save on blade sharpening costs and downtime. Second, when cutting stock almost continuously the motor is less likely to overheat, and will both last longer and reduce downtime due to motor overload kick-out. If I could have purchased the 5 HP version for my saw for close to the same money I would have, but I wouldn't replace my 3 hp for a 5 hp, as I don't run dull blades and really don't work the saw anywhere near its normal rating. If I were cutting continuously with thick very hard woods I probably would. As far as increase danger or force of kickback (the ONLY detriment I can think of for increased HP) I doubt there is any measurable difference in a 2 or a 3 hp saw using the same blade. Sure you can obtain about the same difference in sawing capacity by using sharp thin kerf blades - but they do "warp" due to heat buildup faster than a standard blade and "wander" in the cut more. The only time I would use a "thin kerf" blade is if I were cutting very expensive material. (I use WW2 - 1/8" blades)

Re: Table Saw Motor

#5

Re: Table Saw Motor

Bill Howatt

The only way to find out is to try it.

Personally, I find the 12A to be a bit light for a motor that is called 3HP.

Bill

Re: Table Saw Motor

#6

Re: Table Saw Motor

Robby Wright - San Marcos, CA

If the motor has the same frame size and weighs approximately the same, there isn't a mechanical reason for not making the swap if you think the trunnions are beefy enough to take the strain. What you do need to pay attention to is the electricals.

Switches that are made to use with a motor are rated in horsepower. There are two reasons they do this. The first is that a motor has a large starting current that can last for awhile while the motor and its load come up to speed. This isn't a huge issue on a table saw unless the blade is jammed and the motor stalled, but it still needs to have attention paid to it.

The second reason is that when you turn the switch off and the contacts open. the inductive load that a motor presents can cause a large arc. When the magnetic field in an inductive load (think big coil of wire like a motor) collapses because you turned the power off, it creates a large bolt of energy called back EMF. It takes imaginary numbers in math to describe it, but if you ever get bit by it, it is not imaginary! Anyway, the arc and the back EMF can really damage a standard duty switch. Motor rated switches are designed to take this load repeatedly without failing, thus the motor rating.

A final thing to think about. The 2HP motor that came with your saw probably has an internal thermal cutoff device. 3HP motors usually don't have this device and require an external thermal based device to detect when it is being overloaded. Small overloads won't trip magnetic breakers like the circuit breaker in your power panel. If your motor doesn't have an internal thermal protection device, which usually looks like a pushbutton on the end of the motor, you will need to use a motor starter. You can get this from Grizzley or other sources. Here is the link to the Grizzley motor starter:

http://www.grizzly.com/products/Magnetic-Switch-Single-Phase-220V-Only-3HP-21-25A/T24101

Re: Table Saw Motor

#7

A lot goes into that decision

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I run a 1.5 HP on my Unisaw and have never longed for anything more powerful. I have never had it bog down on any sort of cross cut and there have been thousands of bdft of lumber go across it. I expect it would bog down ripping 8/4 oak with a 40 tooth blade. It doesn't pause using an 8 tooth blade. If I frequently needed finish rip cuts on 8/4 oak with a "fine" toothed rip blade I would be looking for a larger motor. I don't, so spending $50 on a coarse rip blade was better economics.

Then there is the fate of the two motors to consider. What is the use for the one not used on the saw? Which would be the best motor for this alternative motor application?

Re: Table Saw Motor

#8

Re: Table Saw Motor

don stephan

When I purchased my PM 64A contractor saw I chose the 1.5 HP option over the 2HP. This was my first real table saw and I was concerned about potential kick back. Years ago a friend said his 5HP Unisaw threw him and a 90 pound sheet of 3/4" melamine across the room before he knew what happened, and the only thing that saved him was a metal support post that stopped the sheet short. Don't know if true. Occasionally I have to slow the feed rate with my 1.5HP, but I'm not a production shop. Someday I hope to get a Sawstop or similar true cabinet saw and I'll probably get a 3HP for resale considerations.

Re: Table Saw Motor

#9

Bob

Re: Table Saw Motor

Bob

There is not enough difference between a 3 and 3 HP motor to be looking at crank amps but you did bring up a good point if you were jumping from a 2 HP to a 5HP.