Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

Posts

Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

#1

Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There appear to be three persistent myths that circulate the forums. I will take this opportunity to challenge them.

After encountering the African Blackwood every edged tool I used needs some serious edge restoration. I prefer to only grind near the edge so as to preserve the reference straight line of the honed edge and continue sharpening by honing. However, when the edge is more damaged than by simple dulling the fastest means to a restored edge is to grind away the damage with the bench grinder.

During this evening's sharpening marathon I ground two thin Stanley plane blades. They are amazingly soft compared to modern plane blades and grind at breathtaking speed. They are thin and if I was to have any hint of a heating problem it would be with these blades. Furthermore, I don't claim any exceptional hand skills. I have taught several people to do what I do and they all were successful in short order. If you can use a hand plane you can use a grinder to sharpen its blade.

Myth 1- "You need a slow speed grinder to avoid burning the blade. " I grind at 3600 rpm. The thin Stanley blades didn't even get warm.

Myth 2- "You need a coarse wheel to avoid burning the blade" ( I have had quoted as essential a 46 grit wheel, where ever that bogus advice came from) Baloney! I used a 120 grit wheel tonight.

Myth 3 "The Norton 3X wheels are ideal for grinding our tools" They are a poor choice and make no sense to buy unless you are a cheap turner sharpening lathe tools. This wheel is too hard for plane blades and chisels. The durable feature of the seeded gel abrasive is of no advantage for sharpening plane blades.

What you do need is simple- a good tool rest, a light touch of tool to wheel, and a soft bond, crowned wheel with a friable grit. Persons neglecting any of these factors may experience heating.

I use an H hardness wheel, pink grit, and a Wolverine rest. Something in the range of 80 to 120 grit is fine. The wheel is crowned so that only a small part of it touched the tool at any one time. I use a back and forth motion with very light pressure on the wheel. It typically takes me about 30-60 seconds to grind what needs to be ground.

The problem is metal going away too fast and loosing control. At slow speed you actually heat faster( I can explain the theory if there is interest, or, read the article in articles section).

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

#2

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

Doug Trembath

Actually, Bill, I don't think it makes a bit of difference which wheel a person uses, as long as they use a soft hand and some manner of ensuring they grind away only the steel that needs removed. As a turner, I routinely have mounted an SG 8" wheel, simply because of the ability to grade it to multiple grits to satisfy my turning requirements, yet have found nothing I can't achieve the required profile with it, if I just keep in mind the advice given to me by a professional sawyer nearly a decade ago. I watched him sharpen his chainsaw between trees being fallen, and he had the lightest touch I had ever seen, yet accomplished a task I had considered a chore for years, in a matter of moments with spectacular results. Humbling, but truly effective. I have applied the same concept to almost every abrasive task I undertake since, and it has served me very well. I agree with you, if you drive any cutting edge into any abrasive in a a manner too swift for it to achieve the desired result, you will overheat and burn steel.

Your point is very apropos, and again you have identified a good issue for those of us out here to consider...

The less pressure you apply to an abrasive, the more efficiently, and controllably, it will cut.

Thanks for bringing this subject to the fore...

Doug Trembath

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

#3

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

Rick Snyder

Bill, Thanks for the great info. on bench grinding.

Rick

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

#4

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

Ralph Lipeles

Bill,

I have an alternative to sharpening with a grinder. I use a horizontally mounted 4" belt sander. Right next to the bench is a glass of water. I dip the chisel in the water, sand until the water starts to bubble and then repeat as necessary.

I find quite a few chisels at flea markets. They often need much more then a light edge dressing so the belt sanding works out great for me.

Ralph Lipeles

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

#5

lathe tools vs plane blades and wheel selection

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is a wheel factor I did not discuss because it has no importance to sharpening a plane blade on a crowned wheel. However, for lathe tools the shape of the wheel can be important and in these cases it will be important for the wheel to maintain its shape during grinding. For example, one may want the wheel to be flat across and have a sharp edge. A tool steel turning gouge will dig a groove in the soft H bond wheels I use for plane blades and its life will be short grinding M2 tool steel.

The key to fast or cool grinding is sharp grits. The wheel can maintain sharp grits by shedding worn grits through use a soft bonding matrix for the abrasive particles. Alternatively, the particles themselves can micro-fracture to yield new sharp cutting edges. "SG" or seeded gel abrasive particles micro-fracture in use to maintain sharp cutting edges without having to shed the dull particle. Hence, an SG wheel can be made with a harder bond to preserve its shape and life in a cool running wheel. These properties-shape holding, long service life, cool running- are important in industrial tool grinding and these users are willing to pay more for a wheel with these properties. Someone making chisels and plane blades might also find the shape holding ability and long life economically advantageous, or even a turner that sharpened a lot.

The Norton 3G consumer wheel, as I understand it, consists of 30% SG abrasive. If one can take advantage of the SG properties it could make more sense to buy an industrial quality SG wheel from MSC, Travers, Enco etc. If long life and/or shape holding are unimportant a soft bond wheel is a better choice for it will be cheaper and run cooler.

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

#6

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

Kevin French

Amen Bill, I have the same setup.

For those of you who still need proof watch this.

http://www.finewoodworking.com/how-to/video/bench-grinder-basics.aspx

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

#7

Zirconia is your friend

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The blue zirconia belts are likely worth the price for this task. When we were building tools we did a lot of belt grinding and the blue belts performed much better than aluminum oxide on tool steels.

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

#8

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

don stephan

Perhaps the most important factor is understanding - what the edge needs, what the grinding media needs, and what can damage the edge. I can't grind a thin plane blade without overheating and I keep the wheel dressed and know not to overheat. Some might be able to grind the same successfully on the most inappropriate media.

Your comments are helpful and informative.

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

#9

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

John Lucas

Well although I agree with you on most points there are some things that simply make it easier for newer people.

Even with all the years I have sharpening I find it hard to grind a carbon steel tool to a point at 3450 without bluing it. You have to be extremely careful and dip it in water after every pass. That thin point just heats up too quick. That's on a 100 grit white wheel and it takes really light pressure.

The aluminum oxide wheels make it much easier because as you stated somewhere the tips of the abrasive break off and stay sharp and consequently they run cooler.

My strip sander is great in that it runs much cooler and makes it easier to reshape edges without over heating them. Blue Zirconia belts are fantastic for sharpening steel and will outlast the other belts many times. However you can't find them in all grits. I just went through every catalog I could find looking for the finer grits in Blue Zirconia and could not find them.

I just got a CBN wheel for my grinder for sharpening lathe tools and it's the best thing I ever did. They run really cool. My 180 grit wheel sharpens as fast as my 100 grit white wheel and the tool is cooler when I'm done. It of course leaves a 180 grit finish. I haven't used it yet for shaping plane blades but probably will soon because I usually find a used plane at the flea markets in the fall.

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

#10

So what's the difference....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You, and about everybody else I might add, must worry about heating when grinding a plane blade yet I just ground two that didn't get warm and everyone I have taught has similar success. So wherein lies the difference?

Let me repeat the requirements- soft bond (preferably H) crowned wheel, light touch and a good rest. Use light back and forth motion. I use a pink grit but that is probably not critical. The two differences that might be overlooked are the crowned wheel and wheel bond. Most don't even know what wheel bond means and it is common to think one must use the full surface of a 1" wheel for sharpening.

I have an 80 grit white wheel that is impossible to sharpen with without heating. Never knew why until I learned about bond hardness. It is a K bond. Nice and hard for holding wheel shape but useless for plane blades and chisels.

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

#11

Re: Since you ask...

Tom

I hear you say you are getting these results but it is also well known that the edges hold heat, they are sorta dead ends, and as the edge thins they become essentially infinitely thin. So overheating shouldn't be a surprise. Butchery tools is not necessary regardless of the set-up, rate of feed is in the hands of the user.

- Looked at differently, if you aren't getting overheating, your are babying your edge. You are just doing it differently than someone else. Your approach is with the bond, and a small contact point. Essentially you are grinding with an ever freshening wheel that is zero inches wide. Others are grinding with more wheel width and/or lower RPM. Just different ways of controlling the heat.

- The downside to your approach is mainly in the crap in the air from the soft wheel, and the fact that a soft wheel is a bit of a moving target in terms of geometry etc... And then the geometry of a crowned wheel is great for some stuff, and less so for others. Personally I like to get some work done when I am grinding. But I have a current project that requires wheel crown, that is why they make the shapers.

- Dry grinders aren't designed to burn out HSS cutters in their basic config, that is not the hand tool deal, so some variation in intitial set-up is a good idea. A better idea is a better grinder, but I still use mine a lot, and don't have any trouble with it, and never did.

- Another reason for low speed is larger grinders, mine is an 8", and serious ones are normally 10" with fat wheels, judging from the baldors that are on the auction sites locally. You really don't want to pump those up to 4xs the energy and then get in their way.

- Since you often mention your alphabet soup tools, that are not easily affected by heat, the mileage of someone grinding antique or O1 tools might vary.

- 46 is coarser than I need, it probably mainly has to do with the bevel width. It is like a saw, larger teeth for a wider cut, to carry off the crud. I use 80 most of the time. I have never seen 46 advocated for 1/8" tools, or seen them as standard issue on the grinders I have. Finer is better up to the point where it isn't. I can buff right off 80. Again, touch is part of it, release the load, and dust back and forth and one will get a smoother cut. Or just use a real grinder that has belts.

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

#12

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

Tom

"Your point is very apropos, and again you have identified a good issue for those of us out here to consider...

The less pressure you apply to an abrasive, the more efficiently, and controllably, it will cut."

Probably a good enough way to think about it. But with the proper set up you can feed steel into a grinder like tree branches into a chipper. I don't think the real answer is to substitute another mythically perfect set up for the straw man one in the OP. Just get to know the tool , and let it rip.

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

#13

Re: Since you ask...

Tom

I meant to suggest the basic config was for HSS, I said the opposite.

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

#14

Re: Couple of tips - for real

Tom

- When doing some major grinding on delicate edges, I dip them in a cup of water, and then grind until the water walks off the edge. That is around 200F and perfectly safe. I re-dip and carry on. The water is a coolant, but even more important it is telling me heat info.

- Sometimes this pace of grinding is too much for the tool, or my hand, then I will see if I have a few tools to work on, which allows more time to cool between hits on the wheel.

- If I have this kind of task under way, I find some kind of adjacent thing in the shop to act as a heat sink. A flat piece of cast is good, a block of copper would be fabulous. I lay the tool on this surface between hits, and I lay the edge side (normally the back) directly on the surface. When selecting a heat sink, make sure it is the kind of surface that will have full contact with the tool. My grinder moves around the shop on a stand so I have it near whatever tool I am using the most at the time, or can move it out of doors if I am doing anything more than a touch.

- when removing chips, grind back at a blunt angle, like 90 degree, but beware of setting up a catch. Then finish the grind at the bevel angle. This means the edge will only be thin at the very end, and reduces overheating.

- be aware of the tool composition and geometry. Some steels, the HSS steels generally, and those that approach them, are often fairly insensitive to heat, as far as loosing temper is concerned. While one doesn't want to created a branding iron from sharpening heat, the reality is the tools grind faster when hot, and some tool steel could care less.

- As far as geometry is concerned, take a plane blade or chisel for example. It really wouldn't mater if you pulled the temper out of the blade other than on the surface forming the back. That is the edge stock. Of course that is also the area most likely to be overheated. But going back to my water tip, if I keep a film of water resting on that edge/surface, it is cool. Just having an awareness of the geometry to govern your grinding practices is worth while.

Re: Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder

#15

Kool-mist attachment improves any grinder

Keith Newton

On more than one occasion, I have suggested, and puzzled over why the usual tool suppliers don't offer the Kool-mist sprayers with grinders. When some heavy grinding is needed, right out to the edge, having the mist spraying right where the wheel contact the tool edge. Not only is the mist cooler than ambient air coming out of a fine jet under pressure, but keeping a constant supply of water on that fine edge, which boils off utilizes another little law of physics to take the heat away.

The fluid, is mixed with water, to prevent rust on other tools. The additive mixes 4 oz / gallon water, so it is cheap over the long view. My jug has an added label proclaiming it a safety solution for the 1990's, and there is still about a quart left, which will probably take care of the rest of my working years.

I have two of them, one of which lives on the grinder with the diamond wheel, and the other on my main grinder, but either can be moved wherever I need it, like the frill-press, for deep or heavy higher speed drilling. Sometimes when I'm helping a couple of friends dealing with their 3Form plastic jobs, I will mount it on the back of the unisaw, with the tip wetting the blade through the hole behind the blade, just before it comes out above the table. It allows more variation of feed-rate without melting and welding on the side of the tooth.

I even have used it hand-held on a circular saw, cutting through 1.5" plex successfully, where we re-built some architectural details that someone else failed to glue up without bubbles.

And one of my favorite uses, is when I grind jointer and planer knives on my little table saws.