Myths- sharpening with a bench grinder
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
There appear to be three persistent myths that circulate the forums. I will take this opportunity to challenge them.
After encountering the African Blackwood every edged tool I used needs some serious edge restoration. I prefer to only grind near the edge so as to preserve the reference straight line of the honed edge and continue sharpening by honing. However, when the edge is more damaged than by simple dulling the fastest means to a restored edge is to grind away the damage with the bench grinder.
During this evening's sharpening marathon I ground two thin Stanley plane blades. They are amazingly soft compared to modern plane blades and grind at breathtaking speed. They are thin and if I was to have any hint of a heating problem it would be with these blades. Furthermore, I don't claim any exceptional hand skills. I have taught several people to do what I do and they all were successful in short order. If you can use a hand plane you can use a grinder to sharpen its blade.
Myth 1- "You need a slow speed grinder to avoid burning the blade. " I grind at 3600 rpm. The thin Stanley blades didn't even get warm.
Myth 2- "You need a coarse wheel to avoid burning the blade" ( I have had quoted as essential a 46 grit wheel, where ever that bogus advice came from) Baloney! I used a 120 grit wheel tonight.
Myth 3 "The Norton 3X wheels are ideal for grinding our tools" They are a poor choice and make no sense to buy unless you are a cheap turner sharpening lathe tools. This wheel is too hard for plane blades and chisels. The durable feature of the seeded gel abrasive is of no advantage for sharpening plane blades.
What you do need is simple- a good tool rest, a light touch of tool to wheel, and a soft bond, crowned wheel with a friable grit. Persons neglecting any of these factors may experience heating.
I use an H hardness wheel, pink grit, and a Wolverine rest. Something in the range of 80 to 120 grit is fine. The wheel is crowned so that only a small part of it touched the tool at any one time. I use a back and forth motion with very light pressure on the wheel. It typically takes me about 30-60 seconds to grind what needs to be ground.
The problem is metal going away too fast and loosing control. At slow speed you actually heat faster( I can explain the theory if there is interest, or, read the article in articles section).



