Thinking about pulling the trigger on LV new shooting plane, thanks to Derek's great review. My question if I got to LV site from WC or if there's a comment section when ordering and say something to the effect: Came from WC....will WC get some kinda kickback?
I am not denying that shooting ends is a useful capability. I do it more or less on every project. It is ideal for nibbling a bit off an end to shorten it for fitting, or a miter for precise fitting. I did a lot of nibbling fitting the cock bead end pieces. And I will probably do it again in a few months when I am involved in fitting chest of drawer parts. It is that doing it again in a few months part that makes this expense difficult to justify, for me at least. I would need to be doing nibbling frequently to justify buying a plane that that is all it was good for, given that any heavy plane with a sharp blade is adequate for the task.
The other thing a shooting plane (and board) is good for is squaring ends that aren't. But building a sled for my table saw ended that need. And with shims I can adjust "squarness" on the sled similarly to how I did it on the shooting board.
The LV low angle jack is an alternative to be considered. It is dandy for use on a shooting board- it is heavy, it is "low angle", and it has places to hold that are less hostile than say a Stanley #6. Additionally, it can multitask as a jack plane for surfaces, edges or ends.
I use a shooting board and plane for jointing a board's edge prior to glue up. All of my planes are made to use upright. A shooting plane is designed to use on it's side. As my picture shows in the link below (might need to be a FaceBook member to see pic) I've shot many feet of lumber. Holding the plane while shooting does not seem natural to me. As Dan Donaldson told me once, get a shooting plane as that's what it was designed for.
Will my results be any different with a shooting plane vs. a "regular" plane, probably not, but getting there will hopefully be easier and more satisfying. I'm one of them people that enjoys the journey, up to a point, while building.
Surely a plane is designed to plane what ever you point the blade at irrespective of whether it's oriented vertically or horizontally? If a shooting plane is used on its side, the blade would be pointing at the base of the shooting board!
I make a fair amount of furniture and I estimate I would shoot stuff maybe once a fortnight at the most and even then, only for an hour or so. An ordinary plane is more than adequate for those occasions. If I employed someone to shoot drawer stuff all day, every day, then I would consider purchasing a shooting plane.
It's often the case that the less accomplished the worker, the more elaborate the tools he believes he must have. This is also true of many amateurs who believe dedicated tools will afford them more time for their hobby. The reverse is true as they merely have more clutter and additional blades to sharpen.
No one likes a new tool more than I, I suspect, Dale. I have spent a LOT of money on the latest and greatest. On the Hand Tools forum I replied with an alternative, but was shouted down. No matter, I don't need a 40" shooting board for what I make. You, on the other hand, might. That is for you to decide, and only you. I am intrigued by the LV shooting plane, just as you are, because perhaps a new tool will make it better in the end.
However, I have found the reverse to be true. I have found that I progress as a woodworker far more when I am faced with a problem and don't have a ready option of ordering the latest tool which will magically give me the desired end result. Call me crazy, but I can shoot any number of feet with a number 8 jointer laid flat on my virtually perfectly flat bench. If I need to shim the stock, I do, but to spend , what $300 or so to have a shooting plane that is shorter than my #8, where is the economy in that?
Man, I love new tools, but have accumulated so many that I don't even remember sometimes what I actually have, and use FAR less in my day to day work.
It's up to you to figure this all out, my friend, but remember, the furniture you truly admire, was created through craftsmanship, not the latest tool on the market.
Good luck on your decision. Let us know how it works out.
Dale is a big boy. He's been posting on this Board a long time. Surely he's capable of deciding whether he needs or wants a shooting plane without being chided about it.
that my question has not even been attempted to be answered yet. As with a lot of post, someone takes the question in a different direction. And there seems to be a lot of assuming on.
Our advertisers pay only for the privilege of putting their message in front of your eyeballs. They may or may not track referrals from WoodCentral, and there is no commission on click-throughs or sales.
Thanks for your thoughtful question. Good luck with the new purchase. I've always lusted for a shooting plane myself.
Asking why someone has decided this or that could be negative if the intent of the question was to judge the decision. Or asking could be positive if discussing the factors that went into the decision provide useful information to others, or even the first poster. In fact it could be the most valuable aspect of a Forum to announce that one is proposing doing something or buying something and see what others have to say about the proposed, decision, technique, etc.
There is no better invitation for this discussion than to begin...."I am about to/thinking about/etc", or any similar phrase that indicates the poster has yet to make up their mind. A response to this opening line should be received as not being judgmental given that a decision has yet to be made.
For example, "I am thinking about buying a widget. "
Why?
To cut the joint in making thing-a-ma-jigs?
Ideally some experienced thing-a-ma-jig makers would then offer tips on making them with or without the widget.
And, those not familiar with thing-a-ma-jigs making would learn the benefits of the widget for making thing-a-ma-jigs as well as alternatives that might be better suited for this need.
The hundreds of "silent majority" readers of the thread are there to learn from the exchanges.
Hi Dale - You are right, I read Jack Plane's reply and had responded with a "Ditto" sort of manner without really taking your question to mind. I straddle his attitude and the new-tool desire sometimes and should have been more respctful of what your actual question was about.
Sorry bout that, my man.
PS, i shoot with my LV LA Jack and have blisters on my palm sometimes. I am too lazy to make a hot dog for it...maybe next time i ahve some casework to square up...watch out!