My slice through a walnut log has a very round boundary between the heartwood and sapwood. Today I was flattening a slice through a large ash log for the local nature center, and what I'm guessing is the heart-sap boundary is very irregular. I counted 59 pair of early/late wood rings.
Is this in fact the boundary? I'd like to give the naturalist accurate info.
Don, I'm not sure that middle coloration is the heartwood-sapwood transition line, but I've not dealt with ash much.
It looks to me that the tree has been dead, and that the incipient decay has stained the sapwood, blurring the line. I think that star pattern is a mineral stain due to the rink shake, and the radial checks, unless it is a decay starting in the stump.
You might google Dr Shigo, but maybe Tom Dunlap, or Dale Lenz will jump in here with an explanation. That is my take though.
It makes for some interesting patterns when sawed. I picked out this log for kitchen cabinet doors because it had this irregular pattern which resulted in an irregular heartwood pattern on the finished door.
My guess is that it was standing dead too. Look in the part at the 8 o'clock position. See the small pockets? Borer channels for sure.
Ash doesn't compartmentalize decay very well. It leads to some pretty wood patterns too.
The cracks in the center happened when the tree was that age. The vertical split took a few years to seal or grow over. Same goes for the other black lines.
You might google 'ash decay patterns' or something like that and use 'images' to find out more.
Speaking of ash...over the last couple of days I've been working up some ash into pieces that will become face frames for my camper. It is a real joy to be able to make use of the trees that I was paid to remove. A few pieces of wany edged wood will be used too. One will become the backsplash for the galley. The bottom toe kicker of the same cabinet will be waney edged too. I like preserving part of the tree when ever I can.
The only thing I can add by my observation is the last several years of growth are not even around the stem. I'd guess the tree was leaning during that time. This uneven growth results in reaction wood and gives us woodworkers fits. Never have noticed the heartwood being off centered in leaner trees, but very well could be.
Other things which can be read in that cookie, is that one annual ring about 25 years ago is a lot narrower than most of the others, which could indicate a pretty hot dry Summer. You might check the weather records to verify that.
Do you know how close to the ground this piece was? I suspect the lobes are due to root buttresses.
Your profile doesn't contain any information about you or your location, so that could be a roadblock for any other helpful details. do you know if it was killed by the Emerald ash borer? Seems like a nature center would want to share that sort of thing, if this was one of the last of it's species for your area.
Most folks count the late wood/summer wood rings as one year of growth. I sometimes tell people: Actually the tree puts two growth rings a year, Spring and Summer. It normally confuses them....I just grin and carry on. Me think it may not be a good idea to say that, .
Well, Yes, in a softwood like pine, the early / Spring is lighter color, and softer. The late wood is more dense.
In ring-porous hardwood, rather than color, think open pores as Spring.
In even textured woods like maple, close inspection will show a faint darker line, which is the terminal parenchyma, or end of the season for each year.
In your Ash sample, the ring I mentioned about 25 years in, probably was normal for the early portion, but less than half of normal years.
Of course, that could indicate a caterpillar infestation or other things like a hailstorm knocking all the leaves off, heavy vine cover, or other things.
Dr. Shigo got me to start using 'growth increments' rather than rings. Not that it made a lot of difference when I was running my tree company in Minneapolis but tropical trees can have two growth increments per calendar year because of the rainy seasons.
Don't confooze things with two growth rings, early and late, each year This is a case where 1+1=1!
Thanks all for some very interesting and informative discussion.
If the irregular star pattern is likely a mineral stain, I didn't see anything I would classify as dark heartwood when I was taking the picture.
I'd like to learn more about variation in relative proportions of sap and heartwood in different species, and about mineral stains. I've read through Bruce Hoadley's Understanding Wood many times but haven't found another reference book yet. (Just went to the basement and found my copy of Alex Shigo's A New Tree Biology, 1989, and read a few pages. There was discussion about "discoloration" as including heartwood and mineral staining. I'll have to try to wade through this book.
The ash tree, and I, are in Cincinnati, Ohio. I'll try to update my profile in a minute.
I've cut a lot of ash and never have seen white ash look like that. I'm guessing it may be a swamp or green ash. Even so I think the center discoloration is decay emanating from the black cracks. Especially since it doesn't follow the growth rings. That tree has had a tortured life.