Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

Posts

Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#1

Uhg.  Set back on my desk project.

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Guess I don't have to tell you what is happening here...

This is the drawer front. It's one where I cut it out of the center of the board and glued it back together to everything would match too. I was routing a groove for the drawer bottom. Bit came loose I guess and came through. Of course the poplar drawer sides were fine, just the front was ruined. :(

Oh, well. Plan B I guess. Whatever that is.


This is the back side of it.


Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#2

Re: Uhg.  Set back on my desk project.

Stephen Kirk

I've been there. Repair if you can, fill the opening with a different wood and call it an accent. Otherwise, remake the part. It really is frustrating when a bit raises like that!

Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#3

avoid routers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have had these unexpected router episodes. I use one as little as I can get by with. I saw these grooves and have to wonder why you didn't. If for no other reason cost. A saw blade will saw miles of such grooves without getting dull.

Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#4

not the router's  fault ??


Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#5

Agreed

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I agree with you. I don't like using the router either. In fact, I have a big Delta Shaper and I've never used it. My dad gave it to me. He used it once.

I've been thinking about getting a router or plow plane. I'd rather use that for doing grooves like this. It would be a less noisy and dirty.

ETA - del, not sure how I could have gotten the bit any tighter in the collet. I don't know why it worked loose. I'm sure I did something wrong though.

Thanks.

Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#6

Usual Suspect

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Dirt in the collet or on the bit shaft as the cause, especially so in 2-stage collets.

BTW, a good stacked dado set makes things very easy and precise as long as the you don't need the dado to be of the "stopped" variety.

Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#7

Re: Uhg.  Set back on my desk project.

andrew nistock

not sure if this is the case,but, I once had a router bit that would not stay tight no matter how much I tightened the collet. Finally put a micrometer on the shank and found that it tapered about .oo3 from the bit to the end of the shank. No way to keep that tight. Andy

Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#8

It happens

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

My Craftsman router does the same thing. What I do is run the router on a piece of scrap first and then re-tighten the collet. It doesn't matter ow much I clean it, it is just not a smooth interior of the collet so it hangs up sometimes. The test run on scrap usually insures that the finish piece come out right the first time.

Lee

Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#9

Making drawer grooves

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For one drawer I would have just sawed it, as many times as needed, with what ever blade happened to be in the saw.

A 6" dado, plus a chisel to tidy up the end, makes stopped grooves and dados. Or at least that is how I do it.

Not often, but on disastrous occasions, I have had bits loosen. The result is never a good day in the shop. But the main reason I avoid a router for these kinds of operations is that these bits get hot and dull quickly. Well, that and control of work and set up on a table saw is easier.

Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#10

Re: Agreed

Joe Burke

I'm going to stick my neck out and toss out some ideas, mostly because I've been there and can relate. I seem to learn things the hard way.

I was once advised (and I think it was after a similar mishap) to toss the wrenches that came with my router and to find some "real" wrenches. Some that would provide more "umph" for lack of a better term. Now this was in the early 80's and routers and wrenches have changed. However it's still something to consider.

Take the collet off, blow it out and clean it real well. That's if you haven't already. Don't be afraid to roll up some sandpaper and clean the inside wall of the collet.

You could certainly use a table saw and dado to cut grooves, but there are times I'd rather use a router for various reasons. I'd say it's one of those personal preferences. I tend to treat the router and router table a little gingerly. I've got a large heavy table, a router lift with one of the big PC routers and I'm still cautious as to what I expect it to do. Maybe too much so, but hey. I'd rather err on the side of caution.

I don't hesitate to make cuts in steps as opposed to hogging all the material out at once. I've also been known to use the table saw to hog out as much of the waste in a groove as is practical and then use the router to make the finish cuts. It all depends on the project and situation at hand. I'd rather spend some extra time up front than have to decide how to deal with whatever disaster might occur because I tried to do too much.

I'm not trying to lecture here at all. I obviously don't know what you did before the router bit slipped on you. Again, I'm just tossing out ideas in hopes that there might be one in the bunch that keeps it from ever happening again.

Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#11

Re: Uhg.  Set back on my desk project.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I use routers on occassions....but I hate them. Those who use them have shared your experience...believe me. Routers can sure make scrap wood in a hurry! Hang in there.

T.

Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#12

Re: It happens

Henry (Raleigh NC)

After the third or so occasion of this type of routing "event" I decided that a 'real' router was in order. I bought a PC 690 series. I have never regretted that purchase, or had any occasion where such an issue could not be clearly traced back to my fault/stupidity. Realize that I am not saying that this could not happen with a PC router, just that it has not happened to me, and that it did happen all too often with my old Craftsman.

Henry

Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#13

dust in the collet ??  1/4" i bet for bit ?

del schisler

sometime's their is dust in the collet and won't let the collet get tight ? or the bit was bottom out, then when you tighten the collet it will not tighten up ? that is probly what happened , what most do is get a little rubber washer and put it in the botton where the bit goes, so it will have some give when you tighten up the bit, my bosch router it goes down a long way so the bit will not botton out on mine 1617ev , i use my router most every day ,

Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#14

Stopped grooves work best with a router

Dick Coers

Stopped grooves are really tough with a saw blade. You have to use a chisel to get the depth cleaned up. I have sawn the groove, and then filled the exposed groove on the side of the drawer with a plug, but I also prefer the router if I don't want the groove to show. I do try to put the groove in the proper sequence so the it will not show on the side of the drawer, but often don't want to sacrifice the position of the bottom.

Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#15

Re: Uhg.  Set back on my desk project.

William Duffield

It's difficult for us to help you analyze your problem if we don't know what kind of router or what kind of router lift you are using. I've never had the problem with P-C routers with the self-releasing collet (e.g., 690 series, 890 series and 7518 series). This is the same advise you got from Harry. Of course, there are many other routers out there with competent collet systems, but also others that we've all had trouble with.

That said, either your bit loosened up in the collet, or your router lift loosened up. I see that you are using an up-cut spiral bit. While not the root cause of the problem, it certainly exacerbated it. While pulling the chips up and out of the groove, it is pulling itself down deeper into the groove, and in this case, all the way through the drawer front. (Of course, "up" and "down" are reversed when using the router upside down in a router table.) While up-cut spirals have advantages and disadvantages, which are too many to go into here, it probably was not the optimum choice for this operation. If your collet was loose, it could pull itself out of the collet. If the collet was tight, but the lift was loose, it could have pulled the router and the movable part of the lift up out of the table.

You should check for a couple potential causes of the problem. There may be a problem with the lift's locking mechanism, or its linkage, or you may have forgotten to set it. Others have mentioned the possibility of rust or debris in the collet, or on the bit shank. What they have not mentioned, so far, is the possibility that you seated the bit too deeply in the collet. When you install it, but before you tighten the collet, push it all the way to the bottom, and then back it up a 16th of an inch or so. Otherwise, you may not get the collet completely aligned and seated in the taper in the end of the shaft, and it can shift and loosen up when you start to get vibration when you start cutting. A little corrosion or debris, or a burr exacerbates this problem.

Someone recommended using sand paper to clean the mating surfaces. I always use 600 grit or finer SiC w/d paper for this purpose. Coarse scratches, large abrasive particles left in mechanisms or a significant change to the geometry only compound the problem you are trying to fix.

Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#16

Speaking of Rubber

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I use a rubber "O" ring on all my bits to keep them at the correct height (insertion) for the collet to grip properly. This is especially handy in a table router situation so I don't have to fuss with the bit while playing with wrenches.

Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#17

A common cause for collet problems,

Keith Newton

When you put the bit in, lift it off the bottom a little before tightening. If the end of the bit bottoms out before the wedging of the collet is complete, the vibration will wiggle it out.

1/2" shanks have 4 times as much metal, but are more than 4 times as stiff as a 1/4" shank, thus smoother cuts and fewer other problems.

Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#18

Re: Uhg.  Set back on my desk project.

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hello all.

I just wanted to respond to some of the comments regarding my little mishap and let you all know I appreciate you taking the time to respond and try to help. Thank you.

Stephen Kirk said:

I've been there. Repair if you can, fill the opening with a different wood and call it an accent. Otherwise, remake the part. It really is frustrating when a bit raises like that!

I am making a new drawer front (and sides). The grain won't be an exact match, but I am going to try and do cock beading around it so it looks like it was supposed to be that way...

Mark Mandell said:

BTW, a good stacked dado set makes things very easy and precise as long as the you don't need the dado to be of the "stopped" variety."

Stupid me. I should have used my (Frued SD208) stacked dado set. Sometimes I make the mistake of rushing and not thinking thrings through.

Lee Schierer said:

The test run on scrap usually insures that the finish piece come out right the first time.

I understand. I had actually routed the grooves in the drawer sides first to make sure all was ok. Guess the router just didn't like the drawer front.

Henry (Raleigh NC) said:

After the third or so occasion of this type of routing "event" I decided that a 'real' router was in order.

I agree. When I buy a tool, I try to buy quality when I can (afford it). My routers are a couple PC7529's and a couple Hitachi M12V's. I have a cheapo router I bought at Sears close to 20 years ago. Haven't used it in close to 20 years... :)

Joe Burke said:

I don't hesitate to make cuts in steps as opposed to hogging all the material out at once.

I should have thought of that.

I'm not trying to lecture here at all.

Not taken as a lecture and I appreciate the time taken for the reply. :)

del schisler said:

or the bit was bottom out,

Not sure that was the problem, I don't know, but when I put a bit into the collet, I bottom it out then raise it back up an 1/8" or so.

Thomas Skaggs said:

Routers can sure make scrap wood in a hurry!

Ain't that the truth! :D

William Duffield said:

It's difficult for us to help you analyze your problem if we don't know what kind of router or what kind of router lift you are using.

I was using one of my Hitachi M12v's that is dedicated to my (crappy) router table that is attached to my cabinet saw. It was a 1/4" bit in one of those adapter for using a 1/4" bit in a 1/2" collet. I have to take the time to have a good look at that adapter/collet to inspect for what you and others have said. The rest of your post made total sense as well.

Keith Newton said:

When you put the bit in, lift it off the bottom a little before tightening.

I did. See above. Like I mention, I need to take a closer look at the collet.

Thanks a ton everybody.

Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#19

Re: Uhg.  Set back on my desk project.

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

Joe,

I have an M12V also and when using the 1/4" adapter, be sure to align the slot in the 1/4" adapter with the 1/2" collet and then tighten.

Re: Uhg. Set back on my desk project.

#20

Re: Uhg.  Set back on my desk project.

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Wow. Never thought to do that and/or it was required. May have been the problem all along.

Thanks for that.