Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

What is your preferred cabinet style

Posts

What is your preferred cabinet style

#1

Bart Goldberg

What is your preferred cabinet style

Bart Goldberg

for doing a Kitchen makeover. My current cabinets are a partial overlay door of a face framed cabinet with raised panel doors. I have experience making this type of cabinet, so no issue there. However, I'm wondering if inset doors would be better/worse for a Kitchen, and what do most cabinet makers think of frameless cabinets?

Thanks for sharing

Bart

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

#2

Preferred

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

"Euro" style (framless case work for maximum access to the interior, then full overlay doors on with Blu-motion hinges.

My style of choice? Up-dated Shaker with plank drawer fronts and no stain (letting the wood dictate the color.

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

#3

Only frameless for me

Dick Coers

I also prefer only drawers in the base units. Hate the idea of opening a door so I can pull out a tray. Make deep drawers and only put doors on the sink base.

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

#4

Flush door

John in NM

I like the doors flush with the face frame, installed with high quality butt hinges. Done well with good hinges, the doors will never sag in my lifetime, and as I don't build them for other people, time and cost become a bit more flexible :D

The doors also do not slam, though double door cabinets can with some effort. The inset door has to displace some air in the cabinet, so they have a bit of a cushion. Of course some will find that they won't self close to be more annoying than I find the noise of overlay doors - to each their own :D

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

#5

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Factory cabinets are mass produced on highly automated machinery. The current fashion may be as much driven by what can be made with lots of machinery and little labor as it is by current taste, for example frameless cabinetry doweled together. the parts are cut out with CNC routers, holes drilled with drilling machines, edge banded on another machine, dowels glued and inserted on yet another machine, the parts assembled in a clamping machine. No woodworkers involved and the only skilled function is programming the CNC to make the parts. For home made cabinets make what you can that you like the looks of.

Visit IWF in Atlanta next August to see all this in action. Stop by the LV booth while at it and buy some woodworking stuff.

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

#6

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

William Duffield

Frameless cabinets are for shops, institutions, etc., or for the E.U. They have no place in a high-end home-made U. S. kitchen. I prefer inset doors with raised panels and face frames. There are several features of the European system that I really like, for their efficiency, including their invisible hinges and the plastic cabinet levelers with clip-on toe kicks.

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

#7

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

Dick Coers

What does this mean? "They have no place in a high-end home-made U. S. kitchen"? Does home-made mean made in a basement shop, and it's okay for a professional shop to make them for a U.S. kitchen? Do you really think most consumers care what is behind the doors and drawer fronts? I suggest they have no idea unless the cabinet maker tells them, and tries to sell his construction as being better than those modern techniques used in Europe. Only problem with that is that the 32mm system was invented right after WWII.

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

#8

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

William Duffield

What I meant was that they were made in a cabinet shop, by people, not in a factory by computer controlled machinery. I would have simply said, "custom cabinets" but that is a term which has lost all meaning. What I was referring to was the face frames, doors, drawers and exposed wood panels, the parts that are seen, and should be made from primary hardwoods, or veneers. What you build the actual cases from is not important, as long as the interior surfaces are sanded and with some minimal finish to keep them from getting dirty over the life of the cabinets.

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

#9

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

Jerry Samsen

Frameless of face frame is a matter of taste and the look you are going after. Euro style (frameless) are a little more efficient in terms of space utilization so for smaller kitchens may be the answer.

I'm responding because I am just completing (doing drawer install now) my brand new kitchen. My design is Greene & Greene influenced and I use face frames with depth (stiles are 7/8" and rails are 3/4") and the frame and panel doors also have depth (stiles are 3/4 and rails, with cloud lifts are 5/8"). Doors are inset but I did use Blum euro hinges just because I like the soft close feature which I could not duplicate with butt or no-mortise hinges.

Studied a lot of kitchen designs and there is quite a variety. So there is no right or wrong answer -- just what you prefer.

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

#10

Clint Searl

Kitchen as fashion statement...

Clint Searl

...demands face frame cabs with panel doors in exotic wood and finish to complement the $10K Wolf 8-burner "Hinges-From-Hell" stove that rarely gets exercise.

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

#11

Bart Goldberg

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

Bart Goldberg

Jerry - can you provide me some pics of your kitchen? It sound very much like what I'm interested in making as well

Thanks

Bart

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

#12

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

Jerry Samsen

I will. Installation should be in about a month and then we follow with new hardwood flooring, need to order the soapstone counters and get installed, new appliances installed, final items I expect (hope) to be done bt thanksgiving. I'll probably post on the Woodwhisperer's site as well as here.

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style

#13

Bob

Re: What is your preferred cabinet style 

Bob

Bart I really like shaker style doors and draws on face frames with 1/4" or 3/8" square peg accents in the corners. Here is one I did I without the pegs also found that where possible bring the base cabinets out 3"from the wall and if you have the room an additional 3" at the sink.