Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

desk on home stretch-cockbeading

Posts

desk on home stretch-cockbeading

#1

desk on home stretch-cockbeading

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

After getting the drawers built and fitted I then faced the last risky operation, sawing away the rabbits for the cock bead. Its a bit stressful sawing on a finished fitted drawer.


The picture shows on completed drawer and the rabbit sawed on the other.

It went well and I thought the difficulties were over. The goal was to cock bead with some African Blackwood, which, is of course black. I have done some things with it. It turns nicely, for example. Well, it doesn't pare.


The corner joints involve paring this stopped miter. It pares about like brass. What takes minutes in a typical cabinet wood took an hour to fit 4 miters. I also discovered that glue doesn't bond to this wood. The test piece has zero wood failure. So the cockbead had to be nailed on. It behaved similar to glass when I tried to nail it. I had to counter sink the wood after drilling pilot holes to avoid the brad head from splitting it when it was counter sunk. What a pain!

Anyway, one drawer down and 2 to go. Then I shoot it with Target E9000, at their recommendation and hope it doesn't turn green, a small risk with this finish on ash. The next installment you see should be a finished desk.

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

#2

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

John Pappas

"Its a bit stressful sawing on a finished fitted drawer."

Bill, From excperience I know exactly what that feeling is like. My approach was to use a router....ended up with some bad chipping. The fronts were bookmatched, and I had to do a fair amount of planing to remove the chipout and lost some of the bookmatched appearance. Of course, I am the only one who knows that. The drawers did turn out to be quite attractive. As are yours.

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

#3

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I saw the rabbits. I think it less risky than router.

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

#4

"...behaved similar to glass when

Gary Smyth

I tried to nail it". Nice turn of phrase. You can pretty much anticipate me pilfering that image sometime in the future.

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

#5

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

William Duffield

Although this is supposed to be about hand tools, in this case, I think I would trim the miters with a belt or disc sander.

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

#6

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Fantastic work.

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

#7

I don't see how this would be possible

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....and how would one do that on a stopped miter? The miter on the top and bottom cock bead ends where the more narrow side drawer side cock bead intersects and continues flush with drawer from there. See PIC 2. The transition must be sharp and orthogonal.

Note: when cock beading drawer sides the cock bead is narrow so as to not weaken the dovetails. On the drawer front top and bottom it is full width to cover the veneer on the front and back of the drawer so as to provide protection of the veneer edge.

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

#8

Re: I don't see how this would be possible

John Pappas

"when cock beading drawer sides the cock bead is narrow so as to not weaken the dovetails"

I've only done this once, but I was advised by someone on this board to make my drawer front an inch thick so that the bead could be the same size and not interfere with the dovetails. Thus the cockbead I did was the same size on all sides. I would, of course, be interested in hearing from others on what has been, and is, common practice. Is there a "right way"?

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

#9

Re: I don't see how this would be possible

William Duffield

You're right. What was I thinking?

A minor detail: When I've done them, I've made the bottom cock bead the same width as the side cock beads, because "it won't be seen" and it saves a few steps and a bit of material, and it protects that bead from the drawer blade below the drawer. The bottom bead, and its rabbet can be cut at the same time and setup and to the same dimensions (except length, of course) as the side beads. There is no avoiding the trimming necessary to the top bead, but at least the other three can be fitted using the sander.

While John's method works too, it results in an extra heavy and more expensive drawer, and may result in period correct hardware not fitting, because the bolts are too short. The expense starts to add up if you are using primary wood for the drawer front instead of veneering it.

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

#10

the purpose of cock beading

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The original purpose of the cock bead is to protect the fragile reveled edge of the veneer on each side of the drawer. The cock beading shown in picture 2 is Period correct, and I think it looks best. I have done it on many drawers. With anything other than the black "glass" (AKA Blackwood)I foolishly chose to work with it is easy to execute this beading with a chisel and 45 degree guide block. There is no reason to avoid this joinery.

Should I do another desk, which I am contemplating, it will be crotch walnut with holly accent.

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

#11

Re: I don't see how this would be possible

Sgian Dubh

"I would, of course, be interested in hearing from others on what has been, and is, common practice. Is there a "right way?

The method Bill has demonstrated is not quite the way I see cockbeading normally executed here in the UK, particularly when looking at antique furniture, most of which you will appreciate are British made. The main difference between what Bill has shown and common British practice I have observed is the width of the cockbead along the bottom edge of the drawer, which matches William Duffield's description, i.e., the bottom edge cockbead is the same width as the drawer side cockbead, whereas Bill's covers all of the drawer front thickness. I'm not saying Bill's chosen methodology is incorrect even though it varies somewhat from the norm, e.g., as witnessed in physical examples and described in most texts on the subject.

Most commonly the drawer side cockbead is of a width that matches the drawer front lap, plus a bit to be slightly proud of both the drawer front and the front face of the carcassing. In other words, this cockbead extends from the end of the drawer side dovetails to the front face of the drawer front plus something like 3/16" or 1/8". The front edge of the cockbead can be square, but it's most commonly round, i.e., a torus profile. Slainte.

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

#12

Re: the purpose of cock beading

William Duffield

Yes, your technique is definitely period correct. So is mine.

The cock bead also makes it less critical to get precisely even spacing between the drawer and the cabinet components, all the way around.

You usually don't notice that the bottoms of the drawer sides or the runners are wearing excessively and need some maintenance, until the back of the bottom of the drawer front collides with the drawer blade, and by that time the hide glue has usually begun to get brittle. You have a better chance of knocking off the cock bead if the decorative wood it is made from does the collideing instead of the structural wood selected for the drawer front. This doesn't have anything to do with damage to the show surface of the cock bead.

Another very minor point is that if you make the bottom cockbead full width, it can compromise the strength of the groove for the drawer bottom, depending on the method you choose to attach the drawer bottom to the drawer front.

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

#13

Drawer bottom strength

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think people often make furniture drawer bottoms ridiculously robust. There is a place where I get to see lots of English furniture that has lasted one to two centuries and the bottoms are frequently about 1/4" softwood of some kind, to say nothing of the frail looking sides. Yet for socks and undies these drawers do fine. I have taken to making my drawer bottoms from something light weight and about 3/8" thickness or less. Basswood and pine do nicely. Hence, I am not concerned about the strength of the groove in the cock beaded drawer front. The drawer bottom will fail first if used for a lead shot collection.

For the case at hand nobody is going to put anything in a desk drawer that will challenge its strength.

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

#14

Re: I don't see how this would be possible

Jack Plane

From my experience of British antique furniture, I would tend to agree with Sgian Dubh: The side beads need only be as wide as the lap to cover the end grain and prevent the uptake of moisture.

For what ever reason, the bottom bead is traditionally the same width as the side beads.

Veneered drawer fronts were not traditionally veneered on their reverse faces, so the full width top bead was certainly not for protecting the inner drawer edge. As the final fitting of drawers is achieved by lightly planing the runners and top drawer edge, it makes matters easier if the grain of the top edge is all running the same direction... something that may not necessarily be so if the top bead was the same width as the side and bottom beads.

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

#15

narrow vs wide tradition

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I was taught what I do in a Period cabinet shop that seems, perhaps to a fault, to faithfully reproduce styles from mid America. I will consider the narrow bead on my next project.

I can see that the correspondingly narrow bead on the drawer bottom would be a bit faster to do. I think the full width for the top looks better than a narrow bead on top.

Re: desk on home stretch-cockbeading

#16

Re: narrow vs wide tradition

Jack Plane

I haven't encountered a narrow bead on the top edge. I agree, it would just look 'wrong'.