The local nature center has asked me to make smooth one side of an oak "disk" cut from the end of a log recently felled but probably dead for a year or more. I'm sure the disk was cut with a chain saw, and supposedly is pretty large diameter. Would a portable power planer do some effective initial smoothing of the end grain before I switch to a belt sander? The director called back this afternoon and said the disk wouldn't fit in his car so I may be getting a lot more than I expected.
Build an oversize rail and base system for you router. Let that ride on a parallel frame around the disk. Make sure to tell them the disk will do some major cracking. You may want to take a single radial cut to the center, and it will open up wide, but you are likely to only get one major crack instead of a dozen. Fine Woodworking had it in issue 222.
Even dead a year, I'd also be a bit worried about cracking. It would be fine after that time out here where it's bone dry, but not sure about the rest of the world
Planer won't do well on end grain. Router planing will work, but you must shim the piece to take out any wobble, and you'll need a good planing bit (1-1/4" or better). You can also go to a belt sander starting with heavy grits (24-36) and work up from there. The issue with abrasives is that the wood will be wet and the fibers will tend to feather and clog the belt; have your gum rubber belt cleaner handy.
Since your baloney-slice will be wet, it will crack rim to pith. I have, however, had reasonable success preventing this by drilling out the pith with a 1" bit. The idea being that the hole provides some room for the wood to shrink as it dries. It then gets filled with a plug when dry.
We're all assuming this piece is a thick slab. If, on the other hand, it's a nice thin slice to serve as a display of the tree's annular rings the piece will warp even as you're working. I doubt I've ever been in a "nature center" where they don't have a baloney slice of some mighty 200 year old oak with historical events tagged to the various rings.
what i would do is use a disk sander with , say starting out with 36 grit and working up , i have done lot's of cypress blanks and this what i done, now if it is just to show the growth ring's this will work, but if it has to be perfect flat, than a slade and router wound be in order, sound's like a job. sound's like this will crack open up it will change as time goes by , maybe just sand a little to show the rings and than let it set in a covered up place and dry some, this is going to be a long drawed out project, a standing tree isn't going to be dry , oak will take a lone time , now if all they is to see the growth rings , after you let it dry some , you can sand with a disk sander and than pour expoxy on the blank and it will not show the sand lines, ever with 36 grit good luck
The power-planer would be my choice of tools to start this, however you should get it as quickly as possible before the drying starts. The wetter the wood, the easier it will cut.
However beyond that, you should inform them that a cookie cut across with some tilt will stand a much better chance of drying without self-destructing as much as one cut straight across the grain will, due to tangent to radial ratios. The slanted cut allows some of this tension to run out the faces, rather than being locked in all the way around.
As Someone else stated, drilling out the middle can help, but I would go bigger than 1" if left up to me.
Get your hands on it as quickly as you can, and it won't hurt to hose it down, if it is just starting to show tiny checks. I'd want to hose it anyway to get rid of any imbedded dirt that could have gotten on it between where it lived and your shop.
Dead for a year in log form still means there is a lot of moisture in there.
1) Drying without at least one crack to the plinth will be tough. Others have some good thoughts to minimize this.
2) Watch your other tools & machines in the shop. Wet oak boards, shavings & chip will stain & rust raw cast iron in minutes. Cover your machines, and if you do get some stains, WD40 & steel wool will be needed immediately.