Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Polyurathane

Posts

Polyurathane

#1

Polyurathane

Tomm

I usually uses a polycrylic that I buy at a local store. I have had good results both spraying and brushing. I have read on different message boards that people seem to prefer Crystalac or GF finishes when it comes to waterbased material. I was wondering the reason why one product would be preferred over another. Is it drying time between coats, leveling proporties, ease of application, durability when dry

or something else? I was also wondering why some people recommend Crystalac when someone asks a question about waterbased polyurathane. I thought Crystalac was a waterbased lacquer. Thanks for your input.

Re: Polyurathane

#2

Ellis Walentine

Good questions. Anybody have the answers?

Ellis Walentine

I'm wondering that nobody has weighed in. I don't know enough about Crystalac to give you a decent answer.

Anybody?

Re: Polyurathane

#3

The question just seems to general to me

Dick Coers

It's like why do you buy a Honda, when I like a Ford. All of them are water based finishes, and some folks are going to like polycrylic, others are going to like Target, others are going to like Sherwin Williams, well, you get the point. So people are spraying in Texas and like the way a particular finish flows out there. Others are in Florida, and some finish will not blush there. Different finishes, different characteristics.

Re: Polyurathane

#4

Re: Polyurathane

David Yoho

I've used Crystalac and found it to spray nice and leaves a hard finish. The thing I liked most was the absence of fumes and easy clean up. The newer product they sell today looks to be even better.

That said, I know General Finishes has been working hard to bring to market waterbased finishes that work well and they seem to have been a hit with many finishers.

Certainly there are other brands of waterbased finishes that people like and use. I think it boils down to what you like and the job it does for you. If you have been using a polycrylic that works for you, that may be the right one for you.

As for Crystalac, as far as I know it's a waterbased lacquer and not a polyurethane.

Re: Polyurathane

#5

lacquer?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Does anyone know what "lacquer" means when we are talking about a water based finish? "Polyurethane" has slightly more meaning. It indicates there is urethane chemistry involved in the film former. But that is about as revealing as claiming a bread has flour. What kind of flour and what kind of bread remain undisclosed.

To be clear all water based finishes are formulated with some amount of solvent to coalesce the latex particles. So they all have "fumes" but different fumes than nitrocellulose lacquer, for example.

Re: Polyurathane

#6

Re: lacquer?

CHuck Hans

And is really Water Borne not water Base isn't it?

Re: Polyurathane

#7

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Yes.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

"Water-based" would technically imply that water will dissolve the dried finish (no chemically reactive cure), like children's water colors. However, rarely do many folks outside the coatings production industries make that distinction.

Jason

Re: Polyurathane

#8

Waterborne Lacquer???

Howard Acheson

Go to the site below for a good write up about waterborne clear finishes. The article explains that neither waterborne "lacquer" or waterborne "shellac" have nothing in common with solvent lacquer or solvent shellac except the name.

http://www.hardwoodlumberandmore.com/Articles/ArticleViewPage/tabid/75/ArticleId/9/Water-Borne-Finishes.aspx

Re: Polyurathane

#9

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Excellent myth-buster....

Jesper, Denmark

Thank you

Re: Polyurathane

#10

Re: Polyurathane

james jacomb

I have been using "oil modified water based polyurathane" from minwax. I apply with HVLP, sometimes brush. I really like the results since it inparts an ambering to the finish. After reading the link about water borne finishes I am not sure what animal I have but I know I like the results, the ease of clean up and the set time is fast, plus I don't have fume problems that I would if I used a solvent based finish.

Re: Polyurathane

#11

So, is there a difference

DizD

between waterborne clear finish and waterborne paint? Does the addition of pigment alter the basic chemistry? I'm starting on a project where I plan to spray waterborne paint (which is the terminology the label on the can uses), which the label on the can also says is an accepted aplication method.

Re: Polyurathane

#12

the answer is complicated

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The link provided does not begin to provide insight into the complexity of waterborne finishes/paints. I often spell "water based" simply because I forget how to spell borne/born/whatever)

All these finishes are based on "emulsion polymerization chemistry". Reactive stuff is dispersed with "soap" and catalyst in water to make an emulsion of tiny reactive stuff liquid droplets. When catalyst is added the reactive liquid stuff droplets polymerize to make a dispersion of polymer particles in water, called a "latex". This latex is the film former.

There is a bewildering diversity of chemicals and an infinite mixture of these chemicals, and an infinite variety of how and when these chemicals are added to the reaction that can be formulated to make the latex which becomes the film former of the material in the can.

Add pigment and it is a paint (latex paint for example). Or add some other stuff and it is Titebond I or II or III or waterborne lacquer or urethane or polycarbonate or whatever. If the chemicals are acryllic the paint has good weathering but it is expensive. Use vinyl acetate or styrene and the paint can be made cheaper(interior latex). Add something reactive and the finish will cross link after application and become more durable. Stuff can be added that makes the film harder, tougher, clearer, UV resistant or not, solvent resistant, etc. The list goes on, to optimize the film to meet some need.

the bottom line is that only the company making the finish, as well as their competition that has a group dedicated to deformulating products, knows what is in the can to make the finish what it will be when dry. Hence, always test "the can" as best you can.