Here is the complete story
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
We bought and sold hardwood lumber for 30+ years so I have some perspective on this topic.
Historically, hardwood lumber was traded at the wholesale level with the tally based on the lumber being measured , and sometimes graded, before kiln drying. Experienced buyers and sellers knew the convention and there was no problem with this convention so long as it was understood by all that it was the accepted convention.
However, retail buyers get their shorts in a knot over this convention if and when they encounter it. Volume buyers and sellers knew the system and there was no misunderstanding or controversy. Every pack of KD lumber we ever bought for resale had 7% added to the tally.
Some years ago someone, or group, sued the National Hardwood Lumber Association (they set the measuring and grading rules for hardwood lumber in the US) over this practice. Confusion ensued, for now some wholesalers added the 7% and some didn't. To add to the confusion the details of how the 7% got added, or not, varied.
To navigate this situation a knowledgeable buyer needed to ask about the basis of the tally and reputable sellers divulged the basis for the tally to the buyer, either wholesale or retail.
On a personal note, to avoid the confusion we bought on a "shrunk" basis because that was the practice of our suppliers, added this
shrink" to our cost and sold on dry measurement. Our customers never had to worry about this convention. A critical point- We didn't have any competition pricing on a predried measurement so we were at no disadvantage for taking the route we did.
The bottom line of it is if you are buying from a business that caters to volume customers it is wise to ask on what basis the lumber was tallied and graded and accept the answer without knoted shorts. Obviously the economically significant customers for this business are satisfied with what ever practice they use. Don't expect them to change what they do to accommodate a 50 bd ft customer.
Again , on a personal basis, our typical customer was a cabinet shop or other woodworking business that bought hundred or more bdft quantities on each order. We would sell to individuals so long as they were willing to accept our business practices geared to our volume customers. If not they could shop at Woodcraft where the 2X higher price was enough to accommodate their expectations.