Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Heavy duty bookcases... ??

Posts

Heavy duty bookcases... ??

#1

JL

Heavy duty bookcases...  ??

JL

I'll probably be commissioned to build some new bookcases for the new rector. He has a few hundred more books that he needs to shelve.

Conservatively speaking, he has a good 20' of books that need shelving. This are not paperback, but theological hardbacks.

So - my initial thought was to just use red oak hardwood. The price of three sheets of veneer core B-2 3/4" plywood is on the order of $220. If I use plywood for shelving, I'd have to do a face frame to beef up the leading edge. I'd have to have a solid plywood back (3/4") to anchor the back. If I do the shelves out of hardwood, I can just do sliding dovetails.

My question - I've about 14' of wall. I was planning on doing two units (easier to carry and move about) - each unit being 30" x 6' 11". I was figuring on using 5/4 for the outer uprights and 8/4 for the middle uprights. If I do sliding dovetails - I really don't have to worry about screws or the like. Should I stay with 8/4 for the middle - or can I use 5/4?

Re: Heavy duty bookcases... ??

#2

First Question

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

One thing to consider is weight of the shelves plus books. As many libraries have learned, books can be heavy! Have you checked that the additional load can be applied to the desired location?

Just something to think about.

Tom

Re: Heavy duty bookcases... ??

#3

Overkill

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

On a 30" span you can use 13/16" just fine. I am sitting next to one built from walnut 25 years ago and loaded with weighty (content and paper) text books. Open back on it. I can't imagine that theology is "heavier" than science.

Doubt it...? Do a test. Suspend board between two bricks and load it up.

Measure books. People tend to overestimate the depth of actual books. I have made lots of book shelves and never ones more than 10" deep.

Stopped dadoes work just fine and are much easier to do.

Re: Heavy duty bookcases... ??

#4

Re: Heavy duty bookcases...  ??

Merle

JL,

I agree with Bill that your construction as described is way more than necessary. I just went to the Sagulator

http://www.woodbin.com/calcs/sagulator.htm

For fixed shelves with a load of 50 pounds per linear foot with a span of 30 inches and a depth of 10 inches and thickness of 0.75 inches using northern red oak, it computer a sag of 0.019 inches per foot and indicates that 0.02 inches per foot is acceptable. I can't imagine that the books would weigh more that 50 pounds per foot.

HTH

Re: Heavy duty bookcases... ??

#5

Re: Heavy duty bookcases...  ??

Sgian Dubh

A typical load allowance for books is 25 lbs. per linear foot shelf length. This works well for a standard mix of paperbacks, hardbacks, larger size reference books, mid-size dictionaries, etc. On the other hand, if the books you're dealing with happen to be all large format, e.g., an old fashioned collection of Encyclopaedia Britannica, then you will need to allow for this. An the obvious way to work out what's needed in a situation like that is to weigh a fair selection of the books and extrapolate the requirements from that.

A two foot span using 3/4" or 7/8" thick solid wood shelving (of just about any wood) is generally more than adequate for a standard mix of books, and won't have an obvious visible sag even after several years of loading. The same load of books on MDF or chipboard will result in a noticeable sag of about 1/8" or more in a few months. Even without a load, both MDF and chipboard with a two foot span will more often than not develop a noticeable sag after a year or two.

I strongly recommend you avoid sliding dovetails for every shelf. It's overkill, and assembly can be a pig (to the point of failure- and I've seen that happen a few times) if the joint is tightly executed, which in reality it should be. But when the joint is long as is the case in your bookshelves, you have to make the joint a bit sloppy just to get the darned thing together, which rather defeats the purpose of doing sliding dovetails in the first place. Now, if you were talking of tapered sliding dovetails, or interrupted sliding dovetails, assembly would be a doddle, but the execution of both these variations is a great deal more demanding than the simple common-or-garden sliding dovetail. Slainte.

Re: Heavy duty bookcases... ??

#6

Re: Heavy duty bookcases...  ??

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'd consider making at least some of the shelves adjustable. Your new rector may move on to another parish at some point, and his/her successor may have a completely different mix of books. I'd also make an extra shelf per unit, to be stored somewhere (maybe on top), in case a future rector has a huge DVD collection that takes up little vertical space.

Re: Heavy duty bookcases... ??

#7

Re: Heavy duty bookcases...  ??

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

I agree with the others that your design is over engineered. I build a book case in our family room that had 3/4" thick pine shelves 12" deep and 38" long that supported a set of Encyclopedia Britannica for nearly 20 years with no visible sag.

Lee

Re: Heavy duty bookcases... ??

#8

Re: Heavy duty bookcases...  ??

Brian from Monument

Close to 15 years ago I made 2 of the bookcases that Norm Abrams made in NYW.

Each shelf is 3/4 oak faced plywood with a 1.5 inch high by 3/4 front edge stiffener.

The back has a thinner piece of solid oak stiffener.

The span is 28.5 inches. Each shelf is supported by shelf standards set in a groove in the side.

The sides are 3/4 inch oak plywood with a 1.75 inch faceframe.

Each shelf has been loaded with paperback books, notebooks or fax machines for 15 years no failures.

My opinion use 3/4 inch ply stiffened with 3/4 inch oak will do fine.

Re: Heavy duty bookcases... ??

#9

Re: Heavy duty bookcases...  ??

Gary Smyth

Just checked for the weight of books for moving purposes. Depending on the web site the weight for each box is estimated from 38 to 50 pounds. 1.5 cubic foot moving box (16 x 12.5 x 12.5 inches): commonly known as the "book box". (I see that the sagulator has been recommended for your inquiry.) I use a lot of architecture, design, furniture, catalogs, "art" books. These books often have a clay based paper for photo rendition and weigh more than uncoated paper. That may not apply to your task. The shelves I use are 3/4" ply with front and back cherry stiffeners so they can be reversed if necessary. All but one are adjustable by providing holes for shelf pins from 21" up to 7" from the top. Each case is 14.5" deep (inside) and the bottom shelf is the only one fixed at 16" high. That height was built permanently to hold both oversize books and vinyl records of which there are many.

My shelves are designed for maximum adaptability for my accumulated stuff not standard books. As has been stated I also recommend that no matter how many shelves you build that you build at least one additional shelf per bookcase for future changes. Better now than to try to match at some later date. In my case the bookshelf sides are 3/4" baltic birch, painted, with a hardwood face stiffener. If you have floor to ceiling shelves I find that a toe kick at the bottom will be convenient. Finally these are heavy, I found a outside or bearing wall to put my cases. I wish you good building.

Re: Heavy duty bookcases... ??

#10

on floor to ceiling shelving.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

On the off chance that I am not the only person to suffer this embarrassment I offer a warning on floor to ceiling bookcases. Likely they must be tipped into position. Geometry should have clued me that the diagonal, that dimension critical to tipping into position, is longer than the floor to ceiling height. Failure to remember this fact will lead to a tense situation.

Re: Heavy duty bookcases... ??

#11

Fitting bookcases into a room

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Which is why a lot of bookcases have crown molding atop them - to hide the gap needed to install them.

Jerome* says the shelf units will be 6'11" - unless the room has very low ceilings, installation should not be a problem. I recommend fastening them to the wall framing. Even though you don't have frequent or big earthquakes to worry about back there**, you do have rambunctious children and other events that can cause bookshelves to fall over.

*I am remembering your name correctly, yes? If not, I apologize.

**well...unless you worry that the New Madrid quake is going to repeat.

Re: Heavy duty bookcases... ??

#12

JL

That's 30" high by 6' 11" long

JL

I wasn't clear. These are to go under the window moldings.

That's why the center support out of 8/4. I'll have two 40" spans.

Re: Heavy duty bookcases... ??

#13

Re: That's 30" high by 6' 11" long

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

4/4 might still be ok and 5/4 certainly will be in solid wood. Easy to test.

Price this right. There is a lot of acreage in book shelves to be finished.

If you don't use a back a shoulder on the shelf going into the support dado will stiffen the assembly considerably.

Re: Heavy duty bookcases... ??

#14

Dale Lenz

Re: That's 30" high by 6' 11" long

Dale Lenz

JL: I built a solid oak wood book case over 25 years ago, sliding dovetails with 1/4" plywood backing panel, no facing. My shelf span is 42", have a slight sag, college books. After I built the case I read, 32" was the max I should of gone. Good luck.

Re: Heavy duty bookcases... ??

#15

Data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Experiment: poplar board 5 3/4" wide by 1" thickness suspended between supports 40" apart. Load is centered in span. Load provided by my lead shot and lead brick collection.

Load, pounds deflection, mm

35 0.5

55 1.5

80 3.0

105 4.0

130 5.0

This experiment leaves me to believe that 5/4 oak planed to 1" will do just nicely. Plus I think the 1" will look good in the long span. If I remember correctly the stiffness goes up with the cube of the depth, so adding a bit of thickness to the lumber has a huge effect on deflection.

My shop shelving is 1 x 12 pine shelving stock 4' long, adjustable. It has held the tools for 40 years acceptably.

Re: Heavy duty bookcases... ??

#16

Re: Data

RobCarr

Being an American I have no idea what a mm is, but the thing missing from your experiment is the element of time. I think over a period of years the sag will increase.

Re: Heavy duty bookcases... ??

#17

Re: Data

Sgian Dubh

Rob, 1mm is 0.039 inches, or somewhere between 1/32" and 3/64", i.e., pretty thin. Standard decorative veneers are usually supplied 0.6 mm thick (or at least they are here in the UK) to give you an idea of scale

Your other point is correct. Relatively small loads within the elastic limit of a wooden shelf may turn into permanent plastic deformation if the stress remains in place for long enough, i.e., the shelf takes on a permanent bend. This form of time dependent deformation in response to a load is creep and the permanent bend indicates some structural failure within the wood. It is a result of the duration of load (or creep rupture). A loaded bookshelf is under constant load and because of this fact it is only able to carry up to 60% of the maximum load indicated by a laboratory test on a corresponding shelf part-- the same 60% reduction in load occurs in the construction industry and elsewhere when a beam, etc is expected to be under permanent load. This is because in a standard laboratory bending strength test the test takes only a few minutes to complete. Rheology is the study of time dependent stress. Slainte.