Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

need a waterborne finish recommendation

Posts

need a waterborne finish recommendation

#1

need a waterborne finish recommendation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am about ready to finish the ash desk and I am looking for a durable water white finish that will not yellow over time. Many of the waterborne finishes meet this requirement.

I have had some experience with waterborne finish over the years and it has not been favorable. My main complaint is that what I have used has not given me the clear bright luster of a solvent based finish such as lacquer or varnish. However, I realize that much work has been devoted to improving these finishes so maybe there is something out there that will look like lacquer and not be yellow or turn yellow.

Additionally the finish needs to be durable in a desk top application.

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

#2

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

John Veerkamp

I use Minwax Polycrylic Satin. I am now completing a walnut bed that looks great. I use it on lighter woodturnings that I want to stay lighter.

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

#3

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

Merle

Take a look at this Target Coatings. I use their product line exclusively. The company president is a really good guy who makes himself available by phone, email and on their forum.

http://targetcoatings.com/products/interior-top-coats/em9000-super-clear-interior-polyurethane.html

http://targetcoatings.com/products/interior-top-coats/em7000hbl-high-build-lacquer.html

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

#4

Clint Searl

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

Clint Searl

Bona Mega floor finish or Varathane floor finish.

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

#5

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

GolfSteve in Calgary

I've used Target's lacquer several times, but usually on a darker wood where I want a richer tone compared to topcoating a white wood. Target on top of cherry looks great.

Target finish samples:

Gloss (the figured maple board was very brown/yellow to start with, so not a great example of how the finish affects colour). I also rubbed out parts of the plywood board to different glosses. I've never been happy with how the Target rubs out - to me it just looks scratched up. However, the Target polishes to high gloss very well.


Semi-gloss on Baltic plywood:


Gloss Target on cherry


The gloss Target is a bit "plasticy" if applied too thick. If applied too thick (or perhaps too fast) I have also gotten a bluish tint that took years to go away. However if applied fairly thin I am very happy with the finish.

The finish has stood up relatively well on our coffee table, suffering the abuse of a 3 and 6 year old for several years.

On my latest project I applied a thinner finish, and used a final coat of satin Target, and I was very happy with the final finish. No plastic appearance at all.

Target on cherry - first coat of shellac, then dyed gloss Target topcoats, with one final coat of satin gloss.


Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

#6

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Looks great

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Hi Steve,

The finishes look great!

BTW, was thinking about you during the terrible flood, I hope you were not effected.

Take care,

Jim

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

#7

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

Don Stephan

I've found Jeff Jewitt at homesteadfinishingproducts.com to be completely trustworthy and extremely knowledgeable about how to obtain desired looks with differing methods of application and experience levels.

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

#8

Jesper, Denmark

Re:Why does it have to be waterborne???

Jesper, Denmark

My experiences with clear water reducible finishes has not been good. Waterbased paints seem to be developed to a point, where they perform well, but not clear finishes.

They all do contain solvents anyway, and some materials, which are not so nice and do not have long enough history to be proven "safe". So, my take is that I will rather deal with the solvent devil that I know, than the co-solvent devil I don't know.

In the auto industry, waterborne primers and color coats are standard, and there have been used either powder coating or waterborne clearcoats. However the trend there is to go back to solvent based clearcoats from a pure performance consideration.

If it has to be waterborne, then I would look towards industrial floor finishes, such as used in gyms or basketball floors.

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

#9

the answer was provided

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you can recommend a solvent based finish that is water white and one that will stay that way I would be delighted to use it. A yellowing finish on ash will make it look like it has been stained with a yellow dye and that is not a pleasing look.

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

#10

Re: the answer was provided

paul in AZ

Ash will very slowly yellow no matter what finish is on it.

I have two pieces in my house that I built something like 30 years ago. A cabinet that I oiled and waxed with no other finish is now a rich honey color leaning to amber and a table that I varnished but likely didn't oil is somewhat paler with a more yellowish look. That had to be a solvent varnish.

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

#11

Jesper, Denmark

Re: the answer was provided

Jesper, Denmark

I can't give you a specific product, but suggest you look for an automotive clearcoat repair finish. Intended for light base colors, it would have a very minimum of color impact.

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

#12

Kneale Brownson

Re: the answer was provided

Kneale Brownson

I don't think an automotive finish responds well to the expansion/contraction of wood.

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

#13

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

I use General's HP poly. I use the floods formula and if you leave it a applied it will have a distinct plastic look. to correct this I knock down the gloss with 0000 steel wool and then apply a coat of paste wax.

I use a brush but the finish can be sprayed. Once dry it sands like nitrocellulose. And like all finishes it takes a full month to cure. during the first couple of Weeks you will not be happy with the hardness our abrasion resistance, be patient. Once curred it is exceptionally hard and stretch resistant.

Repairs to the finish don't burn in like lacquer but the blend and disappear just as well.

In a FWW review of h2o finishes a few years ago generals HP poly rated as the most water clear of the batch. It has a slight amber a opposed to a blue tint but you well be hard pressed to see any color.

Robin

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

#14

General's HP poly

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

I use General's HP poly. I use the floods formula and if you leave it a applied it will have a distinct plastic look. to correct this I knock down the gloss with 0000 steel wool and then apply a coat of paste wax.

I use a brush but the finish can be sprayed. Once dry it sands like nitrocellulose. And like all finishes it takes a full month to cure. during the first couple of Weeks you will not be happy with the hardness our abrasion resistance, be patient. Once curred it is exceptionally hard and stretch resistant.

Repairs to the finish don't burn in like lacquer but the blend and disappear just as well.

In a FWW review of h2o finishes a few years ago generals HP poly rated as the most water clear of the batch. It has a slight amber a opposed to a blue tint but you well be hard pressed to see any color.

Robin

Re: need a waterborne finish recommendation

#15

Re: Clear solvent based finish

Doug Wolf

Hi Bill,

I finished this maple turning in May 2011 with a mixture of 50% Deft sanding sealer and 50% lacquer thinner on the lathe. After a couple weeks I triple buffed with Tripoli, white diamond and carnauba wax and it is still as white as the day I finished it.