Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Joint issue on the desk- dovetail something arced

Posts

Joint issue on the desk- dovetail something arced

#1

Joint issue on the desk- dovetail something arced

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Curtis Buchannan, the Windsor chair person, has a provocative definition of "professional". In his mind you become professional when you become confident of the result. This skill based definition has merit, compared to the economic based definition often used. By Curtis's definition I will never get there because I add a new construction element to each new thing I build now days and in the case at hand it is a bent lamination stretcher shown in the pictures.



The question is how to orient the dovetail that will tie it to the stretcher? Should it be aligned with the stretcher, or itself? In the first picture I have made a test cut so that the end of the dovetail is parallel to the stretcher. In the second case the end is perpendicular to the tangent of the curved stretcher. While the dovetail will be straightforward to saw, the socket will not. I think the socket in case 1 will be easier to saw and chisel. Maybe there is some possibility I have not considered. Anybody got experience with a joint like this one?

Re: Joint issue on the desk- dovetail something arced

#2

joint layout suggestion

Mark Hennebury



Re: Joint issue on the desk- dovetail something arced

#3

thanks, and a reply

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Your layout has the end of the dovetail parallel to the piece it goes into, not perpendicular to the tangent to the arc. I think that will be the easiest to layout and saw for this cut can be scribed off intersecting piece.

However, I never understood the bias to full dovetails. They are harder to cut and fit and I don't see that they offer any increase in withdrawing resistance. With a half tail if one saws slightly large the joint is easily fit by shaving the straight side with a plane. I use half tails for drawer dividers too.

Re: Joint issue on the desk- dovetail something arced

#4

Clint Searl

Re: Joint issue on the desk- dovetail something ar

Clint Searl

The structural answer is: "Who cares?" All else is aesthetic affectation.

Re: Joint issue on the desk- dovetail something arced

#5

Re: Joint issue on the desk- dovetail something ar

William Duffield

But, there are structural issues. Mark's solution to the problem distributes the tensile load from the tail evenly to both sides of the socket, maximizing the force needed to split out the socket.

There are also executability issues. Not all configurations are equally easy to lay out and cut. That's why cheap chairs use a dowel here, instead of a dovetail.

Aesthetically, the best solution is to make the dovetail disappear (unless, maybe, you are from the College of the Redwoods. The dovetail joint is not visible if it is executed in the bottoms of the stretcher, and not cut all the way through. This practice was typical of Chippendale chairs. The disadvantage is it is more difficult to implement, and not as strong as a through dovetail.

Re: Joint issue on the desk- dovetail something arced

#6

Clint Searl

Gimme a break...

Clint Searl

It ain't gonna make a whit of difference in performance how that joint is laid out. The half dovetail will lock it in, and the joint will handle any stresses that will ever occur.

Re: Joint issue on the desk- dovetail something arced

#7

Re: Joint issue on the desk- dovetail something ar

Michael Wilkins

From an aesthetics point of view, having the tails parallel to the stretcher just plain looks better. It seems to make the joint flow if the ends are lined up on the rail, like it is following in line with the grain.

My opinion, like others, is free of charge. Good luck and watch those fingers.

Re: Joint issue on the desk- dovetail something arced

#8

Lotta stress on that joint

Jesse Cloud

Actually, I think that joint is likely to get some serious stress. People don't pick up a desk or table to move it, they slide it, putting huge stress on the legs and stretchers, especially if the desk is covered with books, etc.

A good hard yank on the desk to get to the electric plug behind it could challenge the short grain in the joint.

Re: Joint issue on the desk- dovetail something arced

#9

The joint will be on underside

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Looks is not important . It comes down to what can be executed most reliably.

Re: Joint issue on the desk- dovetail something arced

#10

full dovetail

paul in AZ

Chiming in late on this. Purely as a speculation I wonder if the advantage of a full dovetail is that there is a second shoulder to help resist racking. No data to support this. Just a guess.

Re: Joint issue on the desk- dovetail something arced

#11

No question the full dovetail is stronger, but

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....does it need to be stronger?

Beyond strong enough then the choice becomes which is easier to execute well. There is always the thought that an easily fit, and hence more perfect, half tail might be stronger than an ill fit full dovetail. Or, the half tail would be more than strong enough for the application. In my application I don't know.

But in assembling drawer dividers it is vast overkill to use full dovetails in a chest of drawers, for example. And the half dovetails are so much easier to fit tight when cutting them by hand. Yet, the facts are that few use half tails.....out of tradition, or habit?

The shop I learned in used half tails and I never considered the alternative.

I am avoiding the "looks" consideration because I rarely expose a dovetail.

Re: Joint issue on the desk- dovetail something arced

#12

...does it need to be stronger?

paul in AZ

Good question.

I've always used full dovetails out of habit. Admittedly vast overkill from the strength perspective for virtually anything I do.

I occasionally expose the joints and do like the look. But that is a decor consideration and nothing to do with function.

Next time it comes up I'll have to play with half 'tails.

Re: Joint issue on the desk- dovetail something arced

#13

Re: ...does it need to be stronger?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Well they are easy to fit for one has a straight side to plane shavings from until it slides together ever so smoothly.