Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Which Direction To Route

Posts

Which Direction To Route

#1

Which Direction To Route

Stuart Johnson

I've not used a template for routing before and don't know if I should be going clockwise or counter clockwise.

The router is in a table, the bit has a bottom guide so in my case the template is on top. I know to use a starter pin but that is about all. The template is very similar to the attached.

Re: Which Direction To Route

#2

Understand the theory

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You want the cutting force of the bit to resist the your force of feeding the stock. In this situation you have control. Hence, push against the direction the cutter tip is traveling. Think of it like pushing uphill. the ball can't roll away from you and get loose.

If the cutting force adds to your pushing force the piece will be pulled away from your grasp and you will have no control.

Re: Which Direction To Route

#3

Re: Which Direction To Route

Keith Newton

In a table router, you should go counter-clockwise, with the work piece between you and the cutter.

It would be a good idea to saw within ~ 1/8" of the pattern, so the router is only making a cleanup cut. Even then, there are certain parts of the cutting where you can expect a high chance of tear-out. That would be when cutting against the grain just before the grain becomes tangent to the / any arc.

Re: Which Direction To Route

#4

Re: Which Direction To Route

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I've routed similar pieces and I can state for a fact that you will need to route certain sections with a climb cut to avoid blowout. Attempting to route the entire piece in one direction will result in failure. Where the cutting edge of the blade meets the wood grain at exactly 90 degrees, the cutting edge will be compressing the the wood instead of cutting it which will result in severe chipping or blowout. Where the cutting edge is lifting the grain you may see tear out even when taking very light cuts. The areas to watch most closely will be the two long sloped areas.

Climb cutting does tend to self feed and can be dangerous to the uninitiated so taking light cuts is essential and you have to insure you have good safe control of the work piece. You can't tell from the photo how big this piece is so you may need to add auxiliary grips to safely control the work piece and to keep your hands free of the cutter.

Lee

Re: Which Direction To Route

#5

There is another issue, too, though

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If you route into the grain, you will get exploding wood. That is, if the bit as it rotates encounters the end grain of the wood straight on, it will splinter out the wood like you would not believe. The shape in question is likely to have some of that as you travel around it.

Climb cutting - moving the bit or the wood in the direction that the bit's rotating - is a theoretical solution, but I'd be very nervous about that freehand routing on a table. A better theoretical solution would be to have two templates, one on each side of the wood, so you could flip it over and stay always down-grain. The problem here would be registering two templates so that they were aligned.

In my opinion, the best solution, if this is a one-off or small run, is to bandsaw nearly to shape and use a spokeshave, rasps, and files to finish. With these, you can always run down-grain.

Re: Which Direction To Route

#6

One Template, bearing over, and bearing under

Keith Newton

This allows you to flush cut on the same template, while having the rotation favorable to the grain.

If you are getting poor results across the end-grain, it may be from using too small a diameter bit. The cutting edge geometry is too steep and they are more prone to flex and chatter than the larger sizes.

Re: Which Direction To Route

#7

Re: Which Direction To Route - thanks

Stuart Johnson

Thanks for all the help. I'm going to attach handles to the template and hopefully have better control. This is one of those simple projects that has once again teaching me to never say "sure I'll make up some for you". No one step is difficult but when added together become a nightmare.