Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

Posts

Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#1

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

I'm thinking of making some "build it yourself kits" - something that is shipped flat and is glued together by the buyer. The parts are all 1/2" Baltic Birch Plywood. The parts are small - the assembled item would fit in a 10"x10"x10" cube.

The typical buyer won't have access to clamps - so I'm thinking of shipping some rubber bands (Hey! Quit laughing - you're hurting my feelings! :)) Maybe the wide kind that actually can exert a bit of force.

Now, using Titebond or similar glues I'm pretty sure this would be a problem. If I understand correctly the joints require some reasonable clamping pressure to develop strength. And I doubt rubber bands would provide that.

Soooo... I'm wondering if there is an adhesive that doesn't require much clamp pressure. And that would work for bonding baltic birch. All the joints are dados, rabbets, or dowel in socket connections.

Any thoughts appreciated!

Mark

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#2

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I use stretchy things to "clamp". Ace bandages are great for irregular things, Ditto rubber tubing and yes rubber bands.

I have made rub joints with Titebond regular and got more than 50% wood failure on testing. None of the joints you listed require any more clamp pressure than what is necessary to pull the joint together. it is the sides of these joints where the long grin bond forms and clamp pressure has no effect on this surface. Hence, I see no concern so long as the thing can be assembled and brought together by any means, even hand pressure.

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#3

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

The first longbow I built, I clamped the laminations to the bow form with very long strips of inner tube cut 1" to 1.5" wide. The glue was epoxy. I've been told that it's possible to apply too much pressure to epoxy and end up with a starved joint.

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#4

craigd

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

craigd

I like to use rubber bands or blue tape when I can, easy and works.

White PVA would be nice glue to be able to recommend and would probably work just fine if there are no edge joints or if the object basically wants to stay together when assembled dry. BB wants to hoover glue (lots of end grain) so it might be possible for a novice to get somewhat dry joints.

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#5

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

Stuart Johnson

Several rubber bands will give sufficient clamping pressure. They are used very frequently when gluing up segmented turning segments.

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#6

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

Ralph Lipeles

Rubber bands would probably work but would take some skill and care to get into the right position. The 2 legs of the rubber band would have to be tensioned equally to prevent distortion of the pieces being glued. I prefer pieces of masking tape. Just put it into place and if the joint does not look to be correct, remove and change the placement of the tape

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#7

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Thanks for the suggestions everyone.

Sounds like rubber bands, tape, and even Ace bandages can work. Tape sounds like a good choice.

The part that still has me puzzled is the clamping pressure necessary if I want to use Titebond or even Elmer's. Here's what they say on the Titebond site about clamping pressure:

Appropriate clamp pressure is essential for a successful bond. We recommend the following guidelines:

For softwoods (pine, poplar): 100-150 psi

For medium density woods (cherry, soft maple): 150-200 psi

For hardwoods (oak, birch): 200-300 psi

I think I'll have to glue up a few using low clamping pressure and strength test them myself.

Mark

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#8

reread my post

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

you said "All the joints are dados, rabbets, or dowel in socket connections."

The pressures you quote are for edge joining. None of the joints you claim to be using require, or benefit from, any clamping pressure beyond what is required to bring the joint together. So if the rubber bands, tape , whatever is capable of bringing the joint together that is sufficient.

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#9

Re: reread my post

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've watched several of the YouTube videos of Japanese masters who glue up panels using nothing more than perfectly matched edges and wrapped with twine.

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#10

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Re: reread my post

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

This is what I don't understand...

Why is the clamping pressure different in any one of these cases:



Obviously the overall surface area is different. And some are less prone to slip before the glue is set up. And some may have end grain versus side grain. But why would one require more pressure than the others?

Thanks,

Mark

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#11

joint analysis

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Reading left to right...

This edge joint mates long grain to long grain and the only thing that holds the assembly together is glue strength. Bringing the surfaces together to get intimate contact and to squeeze out excess glue will result in a joint stronger than the wood. The glue companies recommend a large clamping pressure to achieve this result.

The middle joint is of no value to achieve joint strength. There is no mechanical interlocking. Both mating surfaces are long grain to end grain. Because end grain is mostly empty space a perfect bond will never be nearly as strong as the wood. Hence this joint is never used by itself to hold something together. Add some nails or screws and it works to hold the back of furniture on. If machined perfectly I suppose clamping in one direction of the other might provide some marginal increase in strength of the cured joint, but at best it is weak.

The last joint is mechanically strong. Add shoulders to the "male" part and it is even better. The strength of this joint comes from a tight fit and the mechanical interlocking. The only function of the glue is to keep the joint from pulling out. Even though it is long grain to end grain the bond at the sides of this joint is sufficiently strong to hold it together if it is machined tightly. If not, a typical wood glue will not hold it together. No clamp orientation can improve this bond. This joint is not typically machined or hand cut to expect any significant bond on the end. I typically don't even apply glue to this surface. This is the only direction that any clamp force could be applied. If the sides are a tight fit any additional bond from the end is irrelevant, clamped at 150 psi or 10 psi. A clamp may be necessary to bring this joint together while the glue on the sides sets.

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#12

more

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The third picture mechanically could also represent a mortise and tenon and bridle joint. Unlike a shelf dadoed into a side piece these joints have long grain to long grain on the faces. The M&T is never clamped across the faces. Again the glue's only function is to keep the joint from withdrawing. The interlocking and shoulders provide the strength which does not rely on the glue. The bridle joint might be clamped across the faces if it wasn't sawed accurate in order to bring the faces together.

A half lap is similar to case 2 . The strength of this joint relies entirely on the glue strength. However, because the joint is long grain to long grain it can be clamped to bring the surfaces together to make a stronger than wood joint . It must be machined to enable the faces to come into close alignment just like the edge joint.

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#13

rub joints

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Rub joints are made by rubbing the wood surfaces together to squeeze out the excess glue and then left to cure. I have gotten 50% wood failure on test joints. Good enough for glue blocks. One can do better with clamps and that is why they are recommended on edge joints which depend on a strong bond.

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#14

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Re: more

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Bill,

Thank you for your thoughtful answers. I understand what you are saying.

In my case I'm using CNC cut joints in Baltic Birch plywood. Typically something like this:


I wonder if the alternate grain directions of the plywood laminations affects this discussion at all. Does this have any effect on strength or the need to impart greater pressure? I understand from what you've written that the mechanical aspect of these dados are what give the joint it's real strength. So it sounds like the effect of these alternate layers is really negligible. And the clamping is just to pull the joint together.

The other aspect of CNC work is fit tolerance. I typically mill the joints so there is 0.005" of play per side, or 0.01" of extra space across the width of a dado. This results in what I consider an excellent fit, although the depth of these dados is only 0.25". I hope these will be strong enough.

The case of the dowel connection at the top is also interesting. Dowel stock varies in diameter (a lot). It's more often than not slightly elliptical in cross section. I know Lee Valley sells dowel stock that is said to be more accurate, but it's more than twice what we pay for the "regular" stuff. So we are probably stuck with the poor fit. In that case, the gap may be much larger than 0.01". Also, the dowel is hardwood so the end is pure end grain. I guess the only point is this is likely to be a relatively weak joint!

Next step... make some of these assemblies, press the joints together with hand pressure, rubber bands and tape, and test how difficult they are to pull apart!

Thanks again for your detailed comments.

Mark

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#15

Re: more

William Duffield

Have you considered through wedged dowel connections? Of course, then your customers would need a flush cut saw or a bit of sanding. You would get away with mistakes in the orientation of the wedge, since you are wedging into plywood, and therefore not worried about splitting the end board.

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#16

comments, many

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1. bash the dowel through a dowel sizer, bought or home made.

2. 0.01" is twice too much gap for good joinery. You should be able to just force the joint together by hand pressure. Chamfer the edges slightly so the customer can get it started easily.

3. The dowel provides little useful strength to this structure. Don't worry about its fit.

4. Make a deeper dado. !/4" is too shallow. With the precision you have available you can run the depth nearly to the opposite side.

5. With a well fit joint this thing will be structurally fine. There is "tons" of gluing surface to hold it together.

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#17

PS, #4

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Don't make the dado, actually I might call this joint a mortise and tenon as it is drawn, so deep that hydraulic pressure blows the plies off the opposite face if the customer adds too much glue. It could add expense but a shoulder on the male part would add rigidity and provide a reservoir for excess glue at the bottom of the joint.

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#18

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Re: comments, many

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Comments on your comments...

1. A dowel plate is an interesting suggestion. If I can control it well, so the thinner part has a consistent shoulder and depth, that could work nicely. I also have to worry about "bashing" one end of the dowel that's already been carefully sized and not deforming it at all. (Both ends of the dowel need to fit in mortises).

2. Hmmm... I'll have to experiment. I'll cut some at 0.005 and some at 0.01 and push them together with glue in the joint and see which works better for both assembly and strength. Unless there is a shoulder (as suggested in your other comment) then the "tenon" has to be the same depth as the "mortise". In that case excess glue has to escape or the joint can't go fully together. With a shoulder I could leave the tenon a bit shorter.

3. Yeah, the dowel just needs to not come loose. It's the handle so everything is hanging from it and there'll be a bit of torsion as well. I think you're right that even if it came loose the case would stay together.

4. Yes, good suggestion. I'll cut them 3/8" deep instead of 1/4".

5. Good :)

Thanks again for the feedback.

Mark

Re: Using Rubber Bands for Clamps - Best Glue?

#19

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Re: more

Mark Meier (Ann Arbor, MI)

Yes, that's an interesting idea. It would make it nice and tight and be cool looking as well.I wonder if the average person could be counted on to not botch it during assembly.

Thanks for the suggestion.

Mark