Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Wooden Door, PIC

Posts

Wooden Door, PIC

#1

Wooden Door, PIC

Mike Rubes, Cary, NC

Hi all,

Here's a simple door. This was the first project to come out of the shop in my new place. A buddy had this storage room off the back of his house and is trading me hour for hour in landscaping (he is a landscaper) for the time it took me to make his door. It is about 6x3 and made out of 8/4 southern yellow pine. Crazy heavy, but that was what he wanted.

No finish in this pic, but he is going to paint it.

Thanks for taking a peek.

Mike

Ready to get to my own projects now in Cary, NC!


Re: Wooden Door, PIC

#2

How did you hinge it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Heavy wide doors are a challenge to hing without sag.

Re: Wooden Door, PIC

#3

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It would look neat with some of those large-headed forged nails on he battens.

Re: Wooden Door, PIC

#4

Re: How did you hinge it

Mike Rubes, Cary, NC

Hi Bill,

I just used some 3 1/2 inch heavy duty hinges from the local hardware store. I mortised them into the door, but due to the aluminum wrapping on the frame, we just screwed them straight into the frame over the aluminum wrapping part on the frame. Honestly, this was the most worrisome part to me, but the guy who's door it is suggested it rather than mortising it in. It's his door, so I said ok. I did use 3 inch wood screws into the framing, but that might not be enough. The frame was in pretty poor shape and the framing material was pretty soft. I believe I will have to revisit it in the next month or so and come up with something a little more permanent.

I didn't want to make it too ornate as he told me all along he planned to paint it.

Thanks for your comments,

Mike

Taking the kids to school this morning means no run in Cary, NC...

Re: Wooden Door, PIC

#5

Re: Wooden Door, PIC

Keith Newton

Mike, I see a few things that I would have done differently that I will share.

The first, is that it looks like you glued the boards together before applying the braces. For this kind of door, they would normally have been just dry fitted together, so that each can expand and contract with the seasons, rather than forcing all the movement to happen from edge to edge. Just taking a wild off the top of my head guess, could be 1/2". If your lumber was nice and dry when you built it, that could jamb it tight, making it impossible to open, not to mention what it will do to the fasteners. If the lumber dries beyond its starting MC, then it will likely split down the grain.

Also, if you just used butt hinges, then you probably had to screw into the end grain of the cross rails, which is less than desirable. If they fail, maybe you could go back with a pair of T-strap hinges to replace them.

Re: Wooden Door, PIC

#6

Re: Wooden Door, PIC

William Duffield

To add to Keith's comments, board and batten doors are usually made from T&G planks, or at least shiplapped. Instead of screws, the battens are usually attached with clenched nails, which have quite a bit more holding strength than screws. A downside is that they are almost impossible to disassemble later. Also, I may be wrong, but I think you want your diagonal batten in the other diagonal ("S", not "Z"). Gravity will pull the unhinged side of the door downwards, especially with a door this heavy. You want the diagonal batten in compression, with its ends against the horizontal battens, to counteract this force. As it is, its ends will separate from the ends of the horizontal battens as the screws bend and the boards slide (assuming the boards are not glued together, as Keith has pointed out).

Re: Wooden Door, PIC

#7

Ditto

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Did a new door and window "shutters" for an open-out basement of a friend's stone-walled barn that backs up to a small river. The river floods and the water can reach half way up the door. Items were made out of 5/4 x 6 PT decking using 3/4" shiplapped "joints" then battens fixed at the center of each vertical board. Hinged with heavy strap hinges that were set in the face of the jambs and carriage-bolted through. They've withstood 3 floods so far ;)

Re: Wooden Door, PIC

#8

The diagonal doesn't matter

John in NM

I lived for years in a house with two gates into the backyard, each one with opposite diagonal braces. In spite of the conventional wisdom seen everywhere (that the diagonal should go to the bottom hinge) the gate that was made as this door was made never gave me any trouble. The other one always sagged.

Granted it was a dry climate and that had some effect, but I have to conclude that whoever first wrote that bit of conventional wisdom the first time had zero experience with building doors or gates. Sadly I see that old saw repeated everywhere.

One day I would like to build one of each and try them out for a few years where it is humid, I think the conclusion will be that it really doesn't matter at all which way that brace goes. In dry climates it works best to do it as the OP did with this door.

Of course there are a couple thousand other things I want to try one day, so this one may fall by the wayside :D

Re: Wooden Door, PIC

#9

Re: The diagonal doesn't matter

William Duffield

Were your gates board and batten with clenched nails, or some other material or some other construction method? It makes a big difference whether the individual components are strong under tension or under compression or under twisting or bending or stretching forces. Also, the flexibility of the connectors is critical to the failure analysis.

Re: Wooden Door, PIC

#10

How about this solution?

Stuart Hough

Put the diagonal one way on the outside, and the other way on the inside. The inside piieces would probably have to be a bit shorter overall, to fit inside the door frame. Might be overkill, but it would work.

Disclaimer! I have only built one small gate for a fence, but this worked well for me.

Re: Wooden Door, PIC

#11

Re: The diagonal doesn't matter

basil

"Of course there are a couple thousand other things I want to try one day, so this one may fall by the wayside :D"

The wayside of my road through life is thoroughly trashed with those....don't feel lonesome :D

Re: Wooden Door, PIC

#12

Re: The diagonal doesn't matter

John in NM

Both gates were just boards screwed to 2x4 battens, made by some handyman or another when the wall around the yard was built. The one that followed the textbook method tended to sag excessively in use, as the diagonal did not prevent sagging as the wood dried and the screw holes became sloppy.

The one with the "wrong" diagonal would only sag far enough to close the gaps in the vertical boards. Because of the diagonal orientation, it pulled the boards together and once they were as dry as they were going to get, the gate was stable for years.

Put another way, the "right" one allowed the vertical boards to fall away from one another, and the wrong one pulled them together and keep the whole mess from sagging.

The "right" way has always struck me as overly theoretical and not consistent with wood shrinking and other effects of use and abuse over the years. Of course, this was in Arizona, in Washington state the whole situation may be reversed. But I'm going to stick with my assertion that it will not matter in a humid climate which way that diagonal goes.

I don't believe using clenched nails rather than screws will make any difference, but feel free to explain the reasoning, there may well be something I'm missing there.

Re: Wooden Door, PIC

#13

Re: The diagonal doesn't matter

William Duffield

Probably, the additional strength of the clenched nails is only temporary. With expansion and contraction of the wood with the seasons, The nail heads will eventually compress the wood and start to pull through. Screw threads just do it a bit sooner.

If your diagonal brace is in tension, then the direction shown in the photo, that you advocate is best, as long as you can keep it in tension, for example, if you use a steel cable brace with a turnbuckle.

Re: Wooden Door, PIC

#14

No need for the extra hardware...

John in NM

The brace's function in this orientation is not to resist sagging so much as pull the vertical boards together as they shrink. Once they have done shrinking, the pull of gravity is resisted horizontally by those boards resisting compression. The diagonal brace is in this case redirecting the pull of gravity rather than resisting it, and I believe that is why it worked well the one time I've seen it done that way.

Now if the vertical boards saw a large shrink-swell cycle, this set up might not work so well.