Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

OT - gas line question

Posts

OT - gas line question

#1

OT - gas line question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I added a leg to our residential natural gas system in about February as part of a (slow*) remodel, putting a ball valve rated at 600 PSI water or gas in at the beginning of the leg as a disconnect, so that I could work on the room without turning the gas off every time I messed with the stubout. The company's website indicates the valve is rated for shutoff for gas systems.

Brand new black pipe, and the ball valve's never been opened since I ran the pipe. I did pressure test that leg to 10 PSI using compressed air. Earlier this week, I removed the pressure test manifold to do some work, and got an immediate whiff of the odorant they put in the natural gas. No pressure - that is, no indication the seals have failed.

Is a certain amount of seepage past the seals normal, or do I have a defective valve? I have a call in to the manufacturer's technical staff, but no call back so far.

*Thank goodness the building department in my little town is OK, as long as I show progress every six months. This permit's now about three years old, for various phases of Trying to Get the House Kind of Done.

Re: OT - gas line question

#2

Re: OT - gas line question

del schisler

sound's like you didn't get the right valve it should be this LP/Natural Gas Ball valve nothing to do with water at all, they are different

here is a link that show one

http://www.zorotools.com/g/00069602/k-G0944815?utm_source=google_shopping&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=Google_Shopping_Feed&kw={keyword}&gclid=CLPTzLf1zbgCFZOk4Aodc20ANg

Re: OT - gas line question

#3

JL

Re: OT - gas line question

JL

A proper ball valve with decent seals should not leak.

I've used many a gas ball valve for many a different type of gas and they haven't leaked. Some of the gases have been exotic. Some have been toxic.

Re: OT - gas line question

#4

Re: OT - gas line question

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I would procure some gas leak detector. Not sure exactly what area / where you are smelling the odor. If it is at a valve that is shutoff and the open end is exposed you can use the leak detector to cover the open pipe and see if it blows a bubble. If it is in the area you had pressurized, you can re-pressurize the system to just a few pounds (3 or 4 is sufficient as the pressure in a gas line in your home is less than 1/4 psi for natural gas). Then you can test the lines at the coupling areas, valves etc. for "bubbles". If as you say the valves are AGA approved, they are fine for natural gas or propane. I have had some very minor "seepage" from new ball valves - this usually disappears after the valves are actuated a couple times to seat the ball into the seal.

Re: OT - gas line question

#5

Re: OT - gas line question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Bill,

If you haven't gotten an answer that meets your needs by Monday, I'll show your post to our natural gas staff and get their suggestions.

Re: OT - gas line question

#6

Interesting you say that, Del,

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

because the valve to which you linked has a "water or gas" rating...

Re: OT - gas line question

#7

Re: Interesting you say that, Del,

RobCarr

Smell of natural gas (mercaptan) can be detected at a concentration of parts per trillion... a couple of mercaptan molecules is all it takes and mercaptan molecules are smaller then gas, so it's very possible mercaptan made it past the seals when no gas or pressure did. If you have zero pressure, then you don't have a leak and I bet as someone else mentioned, just cycle the valves a couple of times to get it to fully seat properly will be all it takes.

Re: OT - gas line question

#8

Re: Interesting you say that, Del,

del schisler

i didn't see any mention of water, or i missed that some where all i seen was this ? LP/Natural Gas Ball Valves

Re: OT - gas line question

#9

Re: OT - gas line question

john Veerkamp

Mercaptan will soak into the black iron pipe and leave a smell permanently.

Re: OT - gas line question

#10

Re: OT - gas line question

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Believe that! When I was a young lad I worked for a propane company for about a year. Occasionally we had to empty a 500 or 1000 gal tank and insert a fitting into the bottom for liquid feed (Some 1 million btu + grain dryers use liquid - will freeze a tank in less than an hour on vapor).

The "stink" additive is actually a liquid, some settles in the bottom of the tank, and you always got some on your hands / tools when removing the bottom fitting. It stays with you better than permanent ink! If you got any on clothing it took several washings to remove it. After working with propane you become insensitive to the odor and can no longer smell small leaks.

I also did a lot of Natural gas installations for over 20 years as a contractor. I installed of all the Sears products in my area, + another Water Softener supplier and installed electrical entrances, wired homes, and installed furnace / air systems. This was my side job while I worked as a manufacturing Engineer for 39+ years in Industry.

Re: OT - gas line question

#11

Re: OT - gas line question

Tom

It isn't normal for small amounts of gas to seep. The thing the fitters always, do, and I do as a welder when I adjust my rig, is the soap test. If you are getting bubbles you are getting a leak, if you are not getting bubbles then you are seemingly OK. I have observed this as a protocol, I have no idea whether it is sufficient as I am not a fitter. I just have never seen them do anything else.