Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

OT, Anybody broken a rib, Healing Question?

Posts

OT, Anybody broken a rib, Healing Question?

#1

OT, Anybody broken a rib, Healing Question?

Barry Irby

Six or eight months ago I fell through a hole in the floor of a house we were working on and landed on a rib on a floor joist. (It was the second floor) Broke a rib. The Doc I went to xrayed it and said it was broken and that they did nothing for a single broken rib. ($601 well spent, I knew it was broken and if he had told me they did nothing up front I would have gone home and spent part of the money on pain killers)

I think the fall (the sudden stop part) knocked the rib loose from the cartilage where it hinges at the breast bone. Sometimes that spot is still tender and a bit lumpy under the skin. Has it not healed? Does it ever? Any idea how long it takes? I'm 64, will it heal before Medicare kicks in?

Re: OT, Anybody broken a rib, Healing Question?

#2

Re: OT, Anybody broken a rib, Healing Question?

Nat Robison

If it was X-rayed and they didn't find your concern, I guess I would lean against your self-diagnosis. Do some google searches regarding cartilage......I just did a quick one and the consensus seems to be that cartilage will not self-repair. Not sure what a doctor would do to cartilage that isn't torn but merely separated from a bone.

A friend of mine broke 2 ribs this spring after a fall from his mountain bike. They basically didn't do anything for him except some pain meds. They no longer wrap you up since the wrapping can cause you to breathe shallower and possibly lead to pneumonia/fluid buildup. Just have to gut it out.

Disclaimer: I am an unqualified, unlicensed medical professional who generally believes what doctors tell me.....unlike my mother-in-law who is an unqualified, unlicensed medical professional who can self-diagnose anything, rarely believes what doctors tell her, and rarely believes that prescribed medicines are warranted;)

Re: OT, Anybody broken a rib, Healing Question?

#3

Get fit.

Rod Peterson—Ormond Beach, FL

Ryder Hesjedahl broke his rib in a crash on the first day of this year's Tour de France. He finished le Tour in Paris three weeks later.

Even more dramatic was Gerant Thomas, who, in the same crash (if I remember) suffered a fracture of his pelvis and not only finished le Tour, he was an active domestique in support of Chris Froome's winning ride.

And tied for the most dramatic was Tony Martin, who went down in the same crash and surrendered a whole lot of skin to the race. The pictures shown afterward were painful to look at. He was carted off at the finish of the stage on a gurney to an ambulance where he spent time in the hospital. Five days later he won the Individual Time Trial to Mont St. Michel in convincing fashion (he is the world TT champion). He also finished in Paris.

As your physician intimated, there are no bandages for rib (or pelvic) fractures. Martin would have had some dressings for his road rash, but at least he didn't break anything.

All those cyclists rode the same 3,000 km everyone else did. Remarkable athletes. If you start training right now...

Re: OT, Anybody broken a rib, Healing Question?

#4

Feel your pain!

Tony - Memphis

No suggestions as I am not qualified, but I AM nursing a "bruised" rib. I dropped a bar with 200#'s on it a little too rapidly and my left side couldn't keep up and it banged me. Didn't seem too bad at the time, but.... This is my second go around. A few years back, I was doing leg lifts (no weights!) and pulled a rib muscle (can't recall the official name of that injury, but it is quite common. I did wear a compression strap thing and I think it helped. Lots of ibuprofen (max dosage for me). The doc gave me darvocet the first time (which is off the market now), but I couldn't tell it helped and there were side effects I could do without. Anyway, sorry to babble, but I hope you get this figured out.

If you figure out who got your tools, pop them right in the ribs! Then, make them laugh and sneeze a lot! Ha! THat'll be worse than jail.

Tony

Re: OT, Anybody broken a rib, Healing Question?

#5

Kneale Brownson

Re: OT, Anybody broken a rib, Healing Question?

Kneale Brownson

I got knocked down from behind by another skier maybe 45 years ago and fell on the upturned edges of his skis. Separated several ribs from the breastbone. Took maybe 20 years for the pain to go away when I bent over backward, which had been one of my favorite exercise routines prior to the injury.

I have broken ribs several times. When the bone ends calcify, maybe six months later, they don't continue to cause pain.