Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

How to make figured look 3D.

Posts

How to make figured look 3D.

#1

How to make figured look 3D.

David Frame

Hi everyone,

Please clue me in on how to make highly figured woods look more three dimensional. Is it oils or light fast dyes?

Thanks for your time,

David

Re: How to make figured look 3D.

#2

Re: How to make figured look 3D.

paul in AZ

No idea of what wood you are asking about but boiled linseed oil pops the grain out on most woods.

i'm also one of those folks who thinks that smearing dye on beautiful wood is sacrilege.

Re: How to make figured look 3D.

#3

various approaches

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Anything that absorbs differently in end grain vs flat grain will enhance the grain differences. Oil, varnish and stains all will enhance the grain.

The oil and varnish are easy to deal with. Just slather it on. One must learn to use stains. It is all too easy to get them too dark or not uniform. ALWAYS experiment with stain on a nearly identical test piece.


Shown in the picture is crotch mahogany that has been stained with two colors of water soluble dye followed by a bath in linseed oil. While it takes some practice to get it right most find the result attractive. This piece became a door panel in a Federal wall cabinet.

Re: How to make figured look 3D.

#4

How to make figured wood look 3D.

David Frame

I have used linseed oil in the past, but it takes so long to dry. Once dry, do I use a polyurethane finish on the top for protection? Will Danish oil act like linseed oil?

The woods I am referring to are heavily curled maple, velvet curl koa, crotch grain walnut and mahogany, heavily mottled bubinga, and elm and redwood burl.

Re: How to make figured look 3D.

#5

Re: various approaches

David Frame

I have used linseed oil in the past, but it takes so long to dry. Once dry, do I use a polyurethane or oil varnish finish on the top for protection? Will Danish oil act like linseed oil?

The woods I am referring to are heavily curled maple, velvet curl koa, crotch grain walnut and mahogany, heavily mottled bubinga, and elm and redwood burl.

By the way, the crotch grain mahogany photo you sent is absolutely beautiful. Did you air brush dyes on it or was it dyed in two stages?

Re: How to make figured look 3D.

#6

Re: How to make figured wood look 3D.

paul in AZ

I'm not sure how long is long. I wipe it on, smear it around for a while and then wipe it clean with no remaining wet spots. It is usually dry by the next day.

An intermediate step in finishing can be to put on a coat of diluted dewaxed shellac [AKA sanding sealer] to provide a solid bond for your surface finish. I most often do.

If worried about finish or adhesion always test on a scrap of the same wood.

Re: How to make figured look 3D.

#7

Chatoyancy is the term you need to search for.

Keith Newton

You can find lots of info by googling it.

Basically, it is best when there is a strong polarized light source, like the Sun, or a good spot light hitting the wood from one direction, preferably from the side, rather than end-grain. The light reflects best, when there is a reciprocal angle between the light, the cell walls, and your eye. In a figured wood, as you move any of those three things, there appears to be movement in the wood, because the relative changes.

i think it is enhanced by really wetting the cell walls with a penetrating finish, like oils, or wipe on poly, or thinned sealers. If you want to use poly for the top coat, then you might as well use a wipe on poly, like minwax, followed by the full strength, but there are lots of other options.

I had a finisher many years ago that always tried to start with a light misting of lacquer. It was dry as it landed on the surface, and would just kill anything under it. His idea of a great finish, was a shiny surface over a dark stain. I can't tell you how mad I would be when i went to check on my projects sometimes.

It may appear that sometimes you can see into the wood 1/4", but that is an illusion. It does no good trying to soak the wood with so much oil as to penetrate that deep. It will only lead to problems of the oil taking forever to dry, or poor adhesion from whatever follows.

You can find lots of good info on finishing options, but my best advice, is to play with the lighting when it goes to its final location. The light is probably the most important aspect of showing it off.

If the finished product hangs on a wall, the light should be out a foot or two in front from above, but not so much that the reflection / glare from the topcoat mirroring the light blocks the wood behind.

Re: How to make figured look 3D.

#8

Be careful with the redwood

John in NM

It's more porous than a hardwood, oil seems to darken it to the point of turning black. Some is very light in color and this is less of a problem, but I suspect even a light piece will darken greatly over the years if a finish like linseed oil is used. Try a test of your intended finish on a scrap if at all possible.

Re: How to make figured look 3D.

#9

Re: How to make figured wood look 3D.

David Frame

Ok Paul, here is the deal. I am working on is a cane made mostly of crushed velvet Koa. Because Koa is not an ideal wood for a cane, like Cocobolo or Ebony, to keep it from breaking, it will be cut in half and a 3/16" diameter stainless steel rod will be epoxied through the center of it. There are four 5/32" Gabon ebony inlay strips cut on an angle from the collar to the end tip, so when I turn it, it will appear to have a slight twist around the stem, an ebony collar between the handle and the stem, and an ebony end tip at the bottom, plus tip hardware.

The handle is 1" thick in the shape similar of a Derby style walking cane. The stem will go from 1" at the collar, to 7/8" at the end tip. This is what it will look like. You get the idea. This type of Koa is about $100 per board foot. There is not a lot of room for error or for testing finishes.

Now, what I want to do is make the crushed velvet or tightly curled Koa stand out as much as possible. It will also need to be protected. Probably with spar varnish. What bothers me most is the spar varnish has UV inhibitors in it. I am afraid the figure in the wood will look flat because of the inhibitors.

I live in Lafayette, Louisiana. I am originally from New Orleans. Needless to say, we are surrounded by water. The average relative humidity year round here is about 72%. I know that boiled linseed oil is a reactive finish and has nothing to do with evaporation. So is oil, poly, conversion varnish. This includes the waterbornes. The last time I used linseed oil, it took three days to dry. It may have had something to do with the linseed oil. By the way, I use dewaxed shellac to seal my work most of the time.

So, what I've gathered so far, is to first use boiled linseed oil. Then seal it with dewaxed shellac. After that, put on two or more topcoats of what kind of finish? If I use lacquer, the finish will look deep, but will not have the protection of a varnish. Believe me when I tell you that canes take one hell of a knocking. I know, I use one.

This one has been a tough one for me. When it comes to canes, I normally use more dense woods. Once they have been sanded to 1200 grit, I usually wax, then high speed polish. That's it. I was asked by a friend in Hawaii to make this cane for barter in crushed velvet Koa.

Please let me know what you think.

Thanks for your time,

David

Re: How to make figured look 3D.

#10

recommendations

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Bob Flexner once said, I think, that oil under varnish was redundant. It would seem that you could find some small piece of material to test this theory. How about experimenting with the finish before turning the cane, for example.

If the top coat is a solvent based varnish do not use shellac. No need to and it just provides an opportunity for adhesion problems to oil. And yes it is prudent to allow oil to cure for several days, until there is no smell, if the next step is shellac.

There are two approaches to durability. The gun stock route would be to just oil it, linseed or tung, then wax. When it became scuffed, oil it some more. The problem with this approach would be that the cane owner would need to know how to maintain an oil finish.

Alternatively, finish with something durable and scuff resistant. That would not be spar varnish. To get flexibility it is formulated to be soft. I would use a urethane varnish for this application, or any floor finish.

A dull finish will subdue the figure. If you go the varnish route use gloss and keep it glossy.

Finish it on the lathe. Slow speed turn and a brush that holds a bunch of finish, or a piece of soft foam.

UV inhibitors will have no visible effect on the appearance of the finish. Why did you think they would be an issue?

Re: How to make figured look 3D.

#11

Re: How to make figured wood look 3D.

paul in AZ

Wow! that is a challenging project.

Bill's comments pretty much nailed it. I like his idea of experimenting on the wood before you do anything else- i.e. on surfaces that will be cut away anyway.

If your linseed takes forever to dry could it be that the oil is too old? Try a fresh can. I've fallen into that hole.

Spar varnish is too soft for this and it also has the effect of coloring the surface. Some of it is quite amber.

I would think of a finish with the toughness of something you'd use on a hardwood floor. Many solvent based varnishes will yellow a bit over time which can be a pleasing patina or a detraction, depending on how you approach the esthetics.

Anything other than glossy will have 'stuff' in it that will cloud the figure so I'd go high gloss and the clearest varnish you can find. That may mean a water borne varnish in which case that means an intermediate layer of clear shellac.

Post a photo of the result.

Re: How to make figured look 3D.

#12

Re: How to make figured wood look 3D.

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

some yellowing of the finish on this brown wood will not result in an unpleasing color change. Solvent based urethanes tend to be hardest and toughest.

Re: How to make figured look 3D.

#13

Re: recommendations

David Frame

Dear Bill,

I guess I can put a proper finish in the material before I turn it. This material is barely 1 3/32" square. It

has to finish off at 1" to 7/8."

Thanks for your time,

David