Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Advantages in getting 3 ph table saw?

Posts

Advantages in getting 3 ph table saw?

#1

JL

Advantages in getting 3 ph table saw?

JL

I am "unhappy" with the current table saw at the Playhouse. It is an old Delta contractors saw. It has stamped steel wings, the arbor is pretty much stuck in the raised position and it won't tilt. It is a single phase 120 V saw.

There is an auction with a 3 hp 3 ph General table saw. We do have 3 phase power at the Playhouse. I could tap off the box that also feeds the dimmer rack and have a long cord over to the work area. Net cost $100 or so for the box and the cord.

Are there significant advantages in getting a 3 ph saw as opposed to a single phase saw?

For home use in a shop without 3 ph, I wouldn't consider a 3 ph saw. The Playhouse on the other hand has a 3 ph box adjacent to the work area so it can be considered - but only if there are enough advantages.

Re: Advantages in getting 3 ph table saw?

#2

Re: Advantages in getting 3 ph table saw?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Three phase power is considered more efficient. For an application like yours, that's probably trivial.

What is important is that three phase discourages a lot of buyers, because, to use it in a setting without three phase, you have to invest in additional stuff to make it work. So the price may be lower than an equivalent single phase saw.

Re: Advantages in getting 3 ph table saw?

#3

Re: Advantages in getting 3 ph table saw?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

The advantages are: 1) Motor may be slightly more efficient as Bill has said. 2) Motors are cheaper to purchase and more reliable as they do not require "starting windings or capacitors" 3) Again a repeat of Bill's post - usually the 3 phase equipment is quite a bit cheaper to purchase used as there is far less demand. Three phase users usually buy new (tax write off and reliability) while hobbyist purchasers either have to purchase additional equipment to obtain 3 phase or convert the equipment. The only downside to three phase is that the switches and control circuits are usually more expensive (and usually heavier duty).

Re: Advantages in getting 3 ph table saw?

#4

nobody will steal it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Limited demand, but that is good at auction.

Re: Advantages in getting 3 ph table saw?

#5

Re: Advantages in getting 3 ph table saw?

Bill Howatt

The only real advantage is if you can get it and install it at a good price. In your case, this assumes you aren't going to overload the supply with the extra device.

Should the motor fail, you should be able to find a used replacement for a reasonable cost. Often hear stories of 3-phase motors being junked because nobody wants them.

Bill

Re: Advantages in getting 3 ph table saw?

#6

Rick L

Re: Disagree with your home shop theory...

Rick L

completely. Having three phase machines in a home shop can be cheaper to purchase and higher quality.

Re: Advantages in getting 3 ph table saw?

#7

Re: Advantages in getting 3 ph table saw?

Tom

At one point I used to have a 3hp General. I got rid of it. It was sorta dangerous, and I do understand the ins and out of table saw use better than most. This is not a 3 phase issue, as much as going that powerful. If the saw is used by a variety of people who are volunteers, etc.... I think someone will get seriously hurt. I have always found 1hp saws more than powerful enough for my uses which include both sheet goods and mostly heavy hardwoods. Production would have to go up with the more powerful saw, but the saw owns you, not the other way around.

The General 350 I had was a quality made tool, but it is at the same pinnacle of safety as 1940s cars. More power doesn't help with that. Not to say it isn't exactly what you want.

Re: Advantages in getting 3 ph table saw?

#8

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Check the voltage......

Jesper, Denmark

Three phase motors for industrial installation are usually 380/400 volt power. For home or hobby use 220V.

If the place of installation is supplied like a typical home installation, a 380 volt motor will not work.

Some can be wired for 220 or 380 volt - but check it.