Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Been thinking of a spindle sander...

Posts

Been thinking of a spindle sander...

#1

Been thinking of a spindle sander...

John in NM

I used to use a floor model Bridgewood OSS at work, and it was a pretty handy thing to have. Those are still imported under other labels, but at upwards of $1200 I'm looking for other options.

Then there is a very similar looking bench model for around $600, looks like this:


Also, the Home Despot sells these that do both spindle and belts:



For the $200 price, I'm tempted to try one.

Anyone have either of these tools, or just observations, good or bad?

Intended use is trimming end grain to a curve on grips I make. Mostly I use a tall pattern bit in the router, with walnut and beech, that works most of the time, though it is a bit scary. Maple and hickory, and figured walnut have all given me problems, usually ruining the grip blank. Though a sander would be slower, it wouldn't be as slow as a rasp and trial & error.

Re: Been thinking of a spindle sander...

#2

Ridgid

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Have had one for about 6 years. Great buy at $200 (mine was $149 floor special)! I use both the spindle and the belt unit. Dust collection could be better but it's still adequate. I made a sled with a miter arm to replace the POS bity miter gauge. That also corrected a slight fault in that the belt surface was a shade over 90° to the table. The table does tilt but I've never needed it. The sled is shimmed at the outside to give a precise 90° to the work piece edges.

With pretty regular use I had one service call. The oscillator broke a tooth. Emerson replaced the entire motor unit, no charge, and sent it back to me.

Buy one. At $200 you'll like it.

Re: Been thinking of a spindle sander...

#3

Re: Ridgid

John Lucas

I spent a week working on the Delta and the Rigid spindle sander. I prefered the Rigid and when I got back picked one up used. I don't know how I got along without a spindle sander. Dust collection isn't great but it's better than the Delta.

Re: Been thinking of a spindle sander...

#4

Ridgid x 3

Bob Entwisle in NJ

John,

I've got the Ridgid and am happy with it.

Can't beat the price and mine came with a lifetime warranty, (takes a couple of careful jumps through hoops to properly register it), not sure if they still offer that warranty or not. I have never had to use the warranty, but I recall reading, maybe here on WC, about a couple of folks who had good warranty experiences with this machine.

It's done everything I've asked of it, smoothing curves etc, and the belt sander is a nice feature too. I had to tweak it a bit (as with ay machine) to get things square to the table, but once that's done it's fine.

For 200 bucks you cant go wrong.

Bob in NJ

Re: Been thinking of a spindle sander...

#5

Re: Been thinking of a spindle sander...

Jesse Cloud

I have one of the Rigid's and have used the Jet model at school. Fine Wood Working had a review a couple of years ago that pretty much nailed it. Spindle Sanders come in 2/3 grades - The $200 grade (Rigid), the $1,200 grade (Jet), and the industrial grades that are way higher. FWW recommended the Rigid in the $200 range on the basis that you get a belt sander thrown in.

Bottom line - if dead on square is important to you, take a look at the mid grade, otherwise plan to tweak the $200 wonder (and probably loose some depth in the process).

Drop by next time you are in central NM and kick the tires on my Rigid. Not the best tool in the shop, but useful and probably worth the $$.

Re: Been thinking of a spindle sander...

#6

You guys are making it easy

John in NM

Looks like I'll give that Ridgid a try :D

I just realized, the only downside is my wife will be annoyed that I didn't buy it sooner - she made some curved molding for our guesthouse project for which that machine would have been perfect :D

Thanks for the input!

Re: Been thinking of a spindle sander...

#7

Re: Been thinking of a spindle sander...

del schisler

if you get the ridgid be sure and keep the lock nut loose when you are done with eather the belt sander or spindle, if not that nut will get so tight that you will not be able to get it loose, i have one of those ,this is the 2nd one, the first one i left the locking nut tight and couldn't get it loose with pipe wrench? i took it back and they gave me a new one, this has be a few yrs ago, i have had no problum's with it , be sure and regester it by phone and not on line, it make's a difference, for the life time warrenty, good luck don't forget the nut, also get a new nut in the mean time the rubber will start to deterate also , not a big deal

Re: Been thinking of a spindle sander...

#8

Re: Been thinking of a spindle sander...

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

I used to have the Jet bench top model you posted a picture of. I bought it before the Rigid came out, but I looked at all the other models in that price range. At that time the Jet was a much more solid machine and it uses taller sanding drums than many of the others, a well has having an optional 4" diameter from. That Jet made me a lot of money before I wore it out.

The short coming of the jet and i'm guessing most of the other non industrial models is that the oscillating mechanism does not ride in an oil bath. With heavy use it eventually developed too much run out.

I replaced my worn out Jet with a used MAX industrial that I stole for $600. I would stool highly recommend the Jet, for most it would last a lifetime.

Robin

Re: Been thinking of a spindle sander...

#9

Re: Been thinking of a spindle sander...

Thomas S Stockton

John

I have the Jet but got it new for about $300. I looked at the Rigid and Delta also and it came down tho the jet or rigid. The jet was just way more machine for an extra $100, at $600 I would have gotten the rigid and been plenty happy.

Tom

Re: Been thinking of a spindle sander...

#10

Re: Been thinking of a spindle sander...

William Duffield

My impression is that my JET JBOS-5 is equipped with a sealed, oil-filled precision ball bearing transmission. That, and the tilting top (Also a feature of the Ridgid) are the main reasons I chose it over the alternatives available at the time. Woodcraft offers it for $490.

I think it is a sturdy, well-built machine. Replacement parts are available through the standard channels.

Dust collection is not great, but I improved it with a homemade hood above the table, in conjunction with the stock below-the-table dust port.

I use the 3" drum (additional cost accessory) more than all the other drums combined.

Re: Been thinking of a spindle sander...

#11

Re: Been thinking of a spindle sander...

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

Your right it is a well made sturdy machine but it does not have an oil bath lubed mechainisim. If it did I would have never wore mine out. To the best of my knowledge the only oil bath lubed spindle sanders still available new are made by State Mfg, and Max which is owned by Tannowitz.

Robin

Re: Been thinking of a spindle sander...

#12

The Jet JOVS-10 has an oil bath mechanism


Re: Been thinking of a spindle sander...

#13

Re: The Jet JOVS-10 has an oil bath mechanism

William Duffield

Aha! That explains, but does not excuse, my misinformation. I should have checked my documentation. The manager of the store where I worked owned a JOVS-10 (floor-mount JET oscillating spindle sander, around $1275), and we just assumed, incorrectly, that this feature was also implemented in the lower cost bench mount model. The JBOS-5 does have sealed ball bearings and an oiled worm gear drive mechanism, but is not as robust as the mechanism in the JOBS-10.

Depending on which parts of the oscillating mechanism wore out, rebuilding it might cost $50 to $120, or maybe a bit more, with parts from ereplacementparts.com. For many people, that might be a viable option, though not for Robin, considering the machine he replaced it with.

Before purchasing the Ridgid, you might want to study and compare the parts diagrams for the two machines. I will withhold my opinion of their comparative robustness, because the diagrams are not as clear as I would like. I've rebuilt a few machines I "wore out," but there are others that would not be worth the effort, and may as well be set out on the curb.

Details you should compare, beyond price, include motors (induction vs. universal), base material (welded steel vs. injection molded plastic), table material (surface ground cast iron vs. ???), size and type of bearings, etc. Note also that the split table on the Ridgid tilts only with respect to the belt sanding operation, not the spindle sanding operation. In other words, the Ridgid can only sand concave surfaces perpendicular to the face of the work. This is a significant disadvantage vs. the tilting tables of the JETs.