Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

HVLP vacuum template *LINK*

Posts

HVLP vacuum template *LINK*

#1

HVLP vacuum template *LINK*

Keith Newton

This is sort of off topic, in that I was using this to crank out a bunch of plastic parts, this can be used for wooden parts as well.

I have a couple of friends whom are building a business selling 3form Inc. plastics , which is getting fairly popular among the architects. They don't have a shop, so I usually work them in.

It is easier to get a good finished edge with a router, than with a saw, so when there are a lot of like parts, we will make a router template. If there are only a few, I'll just use carpet tape to hold the two together, but then, there is a need for someone to hold it down to the bench, unless I use clamps, which takes longer.

We had 56 parts to run today, so to make holding the parts to the template, I got over on the end of one of my work-tables, and cut a hole up from the bottom, which would accept the end of a shop-vac hose. Then I cut the middle out of each of the templates that we needed, and sprayed the face lightly with a light coating of spray contact. After this dried, it acted as a rubber skid resistant surface for the vacuum to pull the plastic down against.

A few years ago, I was wondering how to measure the negative pressure produced by the average shop-vac. I had tried many years before using the Hg on my vacuum press, but couldn't tell that it even moved, so came up with the idea, to just cut two 12" x 12" squares of mdf, then put my bath scales in between, with a little window cut out in the top one, so I could read the dial. I slid that into a clear plastic drum liner, then flipped the switch, while I just held the bag tight around the hose. I was surprised to read 150 # per square foot.

Since there are 144 square inches per square foot, I thought that was close enough to just round it off to expecting one psi of pressure on the bag. Or in this case, I had cut a 5" x 16" opening into the template, which would provide 80 pounds of pressure pulling the part against the template. It was quick to make, and apply and drop. My cycle time was about 80 seconds per part, which included peeling the paper off the back of each part, which wasn't stuck well enough to leave on, routing, blowing away the chips, dropping the van, and moving the parts into a new stack.

This high volume at a low pressure should be handy for some applications with wood, where the leaking, or bleed through of a higher pressure pump, pulling through a smaller hose might not be able to keep up with. Atmospheric pressure being so low, will only push just so much air through a 1/4" or 1/2" hose, whatever most of you would normally be using with your vacuum pumps.

Here are a couple of shots of this simple setup.


http://www.flickr.com/photos/7391658@N03/sets/72157634671296062/

Re: HVLP vacuum template *LINK*

#2

Ellis Walentine

Great one, Keith

Ellis Walentine

I think this will have to become a WoodCentral article. Great how-to advice.

Thanks,

Ellis

Re: HVLP vacuum template *LINK*

#3

Keith, help.

gary Smyth

I get the pressure set up and follow to the almost 1 psi. The template fits over the hose hole to hold the item. Where I go wrong is how the part is routed when the negative pressure is applied. I’m missing where the bag (or was that only for the test) is so that you can rout the part or is it that the seal is the template/part with rubber cement applied? Can you show a picture of the finished part. Maybe that would help me. I have an application where this might work if I can develop a seal strong enough for a part much smaller (less holding pressure) though.

Re: HVLP vacuum template *LINK*

#4

Re: Keith, help.

Keith Newton

Gary, There is no bag involved here, that was just a test to measure the pressure, and to satisfy my curiosity.

We had rough sawn the plastic so there was ~ 1/8" overhang all around the template. The overhang was trimmed off with a 3/4" flush trim bit with a bearing on the bottom of the bit.

I might could have done this without the spray contact, but during the dry-run, I could slide the plastic part sideways with about 50 # pressure. While the spray contact might have offered a seal, the main function was just traction.

For smaller parts, you may want to maximize the area of the vacuum inside the template. I could have used a router bit to cut grooves out from the open area closer to the edge all around.

The guys have already taken off with the parts to the job site, so no pics.

Back when I managed a plastic shop, we would use higher vacuum to hold parts to a template. We'd cut a groove just inside the perimeter, for a gasket. This was some sort of rubber bead, although I have made them since just using small surgical tubing glued into a routed groove.

My big Powematic table saw has a solid cast-iron wing on the fence side, which I have cut 3 holes in for under-mounted routers. When I needed to make some template shaped parts, I would have 3 routers all running at once. One with a 1/2" cutter with a 5/8" bearing on the end. That was for fast hogging off a blank. You really go fast to keep the chips from welding.

Then i could go right to the next station, which may be another cutter with the bearing flush to the blades, or then to another with a bullnose, for another user friendly portion of the edge. You can probably find all the vacuum valves and connecters for quick disconnects, but I'm pretty resourceful when it comes to working in a pinch. I made some stop, and waste valves for picking up and dropping parts, just using little ball valves sold in any good hardware store.

When the ball valve is open, there is a little nylon seal on both sides of the ball. I took them apart, and ground a little groove in the template side of the ball, which connected to a little hole that I drilled through the body of the valve. When it was in the closed position, air would flow in around the seal, and drop the vacuum. I could pick up a part in a second, and drop it that quick. Of course, that was at a higher vacuum, so with my pump pulling 28" Hg, I was getting -14 psi, so for a little part where I might have 2" x 6" inside the gasket, I would have 168# holding it together. Of course, if I had a square foot, I would have had a ton.

However, as I think I stated on the front end, part of the beauty of this little tip, is that probably everyone reading this forum has a shop-vac, and because of the high volume of air, any little leaks just don't matter, whereas on the high pressure vac, even a small flake across the gasket, can make a drastic difference.

Dang, sorry I got so long here. You probably didn't need any of this, but if you want to send me some photos or something more job-specific, I'll be glad to offer a suggestion. I'm a strong believer in templates. I've done plenty of things that just couldn't be done without them.

Re: HVLP vacuum template *LINK*

#5

Re: HVLP vacuum template

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

You're loading that shop vac motor pretty hard. Any concerns about over-heating?

Re: HVLP vacuum template *LINK*

#6

Thanks Ellis.

Keith Newton

Sorry that the pics weren't better. As you can see in my response to Gary below, this is not new territory for me, and I've had some other useful ideas that I haven't even tried yet. I think I may have sent you an email a couple of years ago when I put the bath scales in the bag to measure. Do you recall that? Someone new to the list was wanting advice on how to veneer some church doors. I was wondering if this would be a way for a novice to get started vacuum-bagging. As I'm sure you recall, epoxy is my choice adhesive for veneering, so a lot of pressure is not needed, so long as both faces make contact.

I have often thought about making a thin box / manifold to put on my stroke sander to hold thin / veneers down. My Oakley sander is of the type where the belt is inside out, so the table is inside the loop. If a thin, or warped part jumps the stop, it blows through the 30' long belt, and I weep,,,,,,,,,,,, not really, but I certainly try to avoid it.

If you want to hang onto this, I can clean up a bit, and find a scrap to run, and use a real camera to get some better shots. I just shot that with my iPhone.

I just got some great news from Canon. My SX50 that I bought in Jan, had gone loco on me. I had sent it in, and just found out they are replacing it.

I hope this doesn't sound like an advertisement, but if any of you creative guys out there want to add some other cool,,,,,,,,, hum,,,,,,, windowish panels into your work, you might want to do a search for that 3form site. They have some really cool plastic panels, with stuff imbedded in the middle, colors, or wild surface textures. I think my friends paid about $1000 per 4 x 8 sheet for the stuff we were using today. Ellis, please feel free to delete this part of my post, if I have crossed a line here. I just thought informing some of the guys who are looking for new materials might want to know about a fairly new material.

Re: HVLP vacuum template *LINK*

#7

Bill, it is just the opposite.

Keith Newton

I have mentioned this before. If you cover the end of the hose, and hear the motor rev up, it is not that the motor is straining, that is the sound of the motor unloaded, spinning freely. When the filter is clean, and the motor is moving the maximum amount of air, that is when it is working the hardest.

When all the flow stops, the motor is doing the least work, thus turning the highest rpm's, so not likely to run hot. The cooling fan for the motor is moving more air than at the slower speed, and the amp load is the least. It is just the opposite of a motor being pulled down by a positive load.

I'm not making this up. That is how it was explained to me by an engineer from Phelps Fan, when I set up my shop system.

Re: HVLP vacuum template *LINK*

#8

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Amurrican ingenuity at it's best....

Jesper, Denmark

Keith, you are right about the fan load, but I would be concerned about the cooling air to the fan. If the fan motor is cooled by the air going to the vacuum, then there is almost no cooling and it will run hot. If the vac. has a separate cooling fan, taking room air, then all is well.

Re: HVLP vacuum template *LINK*

#9

Just imagining.

Gary Smyth

Think of something like a chess piece but taller. Finished part fits into a metal sleeve. Probably faster on a lathe for the portion I was considering for the template. Thanks for the offer..

Re: HVLP vacuum template *LINK*

#10

Re: Cooling

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Keith, Jasper is also right. Unless the vac uses "bypass cooling" like the Fein vacs, you'll be shortening the motor life significantly by cutting off the air flow. Looking at your pics, it seems you're using a Craftsman vac which, IIRC, does not use bypass cooling for the motor.

Good "semi-production" rig. I did a similar set-up when I was making a bunch of mica-laminated cabinet doors. Saw it done in a production shop although they weren't using a shop vac for their vacuum source, and each work-holding "station" was controlled by a foot pedal valve for the operator.

Re: HVLP vacuum template *LINK*

#11

Re: Cooling

Keith Newton

I'm not sure where the intake for the motor cooling is, but there is air blowing out of the motor vent, as well as a fair amount coming out the drum exit hole. I suppose it is getting it from under the lid, since there is no gasket. This air is warm, so I'll take that as a sign that it is cooling.

I'm sure I would have gotten a whiff of the motor during the on / off cycles, if it had been getting too hot.

I guess if Ellis does put this in the shop tips, there should be a notice to feel for some air-flow coming out of the vac when it is closed.

One thing I found curious, is that the air coming through the vacuum is warmer than the ambient air, and i'm sure it didn't go through the motor.

Re: HVLP vacuum template *LINK*

#12

Re: Cooling

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"One thing I found curious, is that the air coming through the vacuum is warmer than the ambient air..."

Frictional heating?

Re: HVLP vacuum template *LINK*

#13

Re: HVLP vacuum template

John McGaw

Good idea. To me the most clever thing about it is that, unlike a regular vacuum clamping system, if some sawdust or router debris get sucked up it isn't going to block anything as would happen with a regular 'little pipe' sort of vacuum source.

Re: HVLP vacuum template *LINK*

#14

Oh, and another little bit about Vac's

Keith Newton

Sometime within the last year,I had suggested to Ben my helper about my curiosity with the shop vac pressure. We tested 4 different ones in my shop, and they all pulled water up a 3/4" clear vinyl tube about 25", if I recall correctly. Even the smallest, which is a little one gallon Sears was just as good as the two 16 gallon ones, and the Rigid 4 gallon.

Also, earlier I though Jesper and Mark were correct about the motor cooling intake not being separate. As it turns out, I just didnt look low enough on the back side. There is a small line of holes low, just above the rim, where the motor cooling air enters the housing, so there should be no worry about over heating.