Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Wood Flooring Recommendation

Posts

Wood Flooring Recommendation

#1

Wood Flooring Recommendation

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

Looking at replacing existing hardwood flooring with new wood. Carlisle Wide Plank Floors has caught my bride's eye. She likes the ash, hickory and white oak. We have large dogs. Any one of these choices better than the other with the dogs? Anyone have any experience or knowledge of Carlisle's product? Any special problems with wide planks for hard wood flooring cupping or warping more than the narrower stuff? They offer two kinds, one is solid hardwood and, the other is on Baltic birch plywood substrate. Both are supposed to have the same amount of wood to sand off to refinish as wear requires. I'd think the plywood substrate may be more stable over time. This is going over a crawl space with vapor barrier and, not over concrete. I'd appreciate your comments so we can do this project right.

Re: Wood Flooring Recommendation

#2

JL

Re: Wood Flooring Recommendation

JL

A suggestion - if you like it - how about bamboo?

A friend of mine with several dogs put bamboo in his home. I've been surprised at how well it has held up.

Re: Wood Flooring Recommendation

#3

Re: Wood Flooring Recommendation

Merle

Take a look at the Janka hardness scale. It might help you make a decision.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Janka_hardness_test

Re: Wood Flooring Recommendation

#4

Re: Wood Flooring Recommendation

paul in AZ

While hardness is significant the thing that will go quickly with abuse is the finish. Scratches and scuffs and the like.

Seems that many of the prefinished products use some sort of super-duper varnishes that are much more resistant to scratching than ordinary varnish.

Something to add to the mix of variables in this equation.

I am a fan of engineered floors for stability and durability. Part of my house was refloored in prefinished maple on a concrete slab.

Re: Wood Flooring Recommendation

#5

Re: Wood Flooring Recommendation

John in NM

Do you expect it to look new forever? Many people do and are disappointed by wood flooring.

I kind of prefer the look of a lived on floor, but then I grew up in older houses, so that is what seems normal to me. Come to think of it, I prefer old tools and old(er) cars too. I think I see a trend :D Its all mom's fault, she'd always stop at junk stores in old barns when we lived in Maine.

Re: Wood Flooring Recommendation

#6

Re: Wood Flooring Recommendation

Sophie in Gold Beach OR.

Hi Doug,

When Becky and I installed new floors at our old house up there we used 2.25 in. solid red oak. Funny thing was we got it from a place called King Floors up in I believe the Surry BC. area. It was about 1/4 the price the locals here in the US wanted and when we got it and looked on the back side every piece was stamped "Made In Missouri".

Sophie