Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Off topic: insulating walls

Posts

Off topic: insulating walls

#1

Off topic: insulating walls

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'd been planning, in the current remodel, to insulate the walls with sheet foam (preferably polyisocyanurate for its higher R-values) sprayed in place with the spray-in-a-can. I am now getting very confused, though about vapor barriers. Polyiso and spray foam are both very low in permeance (at least what I can get around here; can't get unfaced polyiso). That would have made the insulation the vapor barrier. However, because the walls on our old house are unsheathed, we're sheathing with 1/2" CDX on the inside of the framing, for shear strength (that is then covered with drywall). And the reading I'm doing indicates that plywood is relatively low in permeance. If I insulate with foam, am I creating a double vapor barrier that could lead to mold in the wall cavity?

Re: Off topic: insulating walls

#2

Confusing, isn't it?

John in NM

If it were me, I wouldn't be worrying about it, especially if you use the spray on stuff. For condensation, you need a temperature differential, humidity, and a cavity. If the insulation is sprayed on from the inside, the cavity is in between the two barriers, so there should be little if any moisture there. I guess if you seal it up on the hottest, most humid day in the summer there might be some condensation. But usually the problems come from having hot humid air meet a cold surface - you want the barrier placed such that it keeps the humid air away from the cold surface. Your impermeable insulation does that automatically.

Re: Off topic: insulating walls

#3

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Pretty close.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The whole idea is to design the wall system such that the dew point (condensing temperature) occurs within the insulation. Whatever the wall system, there will be a temperature gradient between the inside surface and the outside surface. If there are leaks on the inside, then the "inside" surface moves into the wall cavity, likewise if there are leaks in the outer envelope, the "outside" surface also moves into the wall cavity. If the insulation is inadequate the condensing temperature could occur inside the wall cavity, but on the surface of either the inner or outer sheathing. Moisture + food source + proper temperature = mold. This would provide the moisture, which won't readily go away unless the wall system is very leaky.

Jason

Re: Off topic: insulating walls

#4

Except...

John in NM

The two insulating materials under consideration are both relatively impermeable by Bill's account. Pretty hard to have the condensation happen in the insulation if the moisture can't travel through it. Your explanation is correct for batting and blown in insulation.

Re: Off topic: insulating walls

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: You are confusing me......

Jesper, Denmark

Sprayed in place and sheet foam are two different things.

Anyway, neither are very impermeable relative to a plastic film vapor barrier - so you need the vapor barrier on the inside of the framing, between the framing and the CDX or whatever ply you install.

Now, if you were in South Texas with high humidity and high temperature outside for a large part of the year, I am not sure what the right answer would be.......

Re: Off topic: insulating walls

#6

Bob

Re: Off topic: insulating walls

Bob

Just go with Fiberglass. Everyone wants to seal there building like a coffin You really need the air to change throughout the day especially in a shop, assuming your talking about a work shop. I just did my shop with R-13 or 14 faced fiber glass in the walls & 19 in the ceiling. I covered the walls with 5/8" Fire code sheet rock . I use a 1.5 TON unit for heat and A/C and it does a good job.

Re: Off topic: insulating walls

#7

Re: Off topic: insulating walls

Brian from Monument

If your current remodel has pulled building permits as they most likely would/should, the building department would most likely have to inspect the insulation at some point. Perhaps you should contact them to see what they want.

That is unless you didn't pull permits............ oops.

Re: Off topic: insulating walls

#8

insulating walls

A. Scott Daniels

Bill, I work in the energy conservation industry and rely heavily on cutting edge science. Rather than recommending a specific system, I would rather direct you to experts in the field. Please check this site out. It contains a plethora of easy to read and understand (and quite often humorous) articles on whole house building science. Specifically read the information on High R wall and Vapour Barrier.

Scott D

http://www.buildingscience.com/resources/vapor_barrier_code_changes