Re: OSHA deniers - let me tell you a story
Dave Bair
I guess that's a "Right-to-Work" state.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: OSHA deniers - let me tell you a story
Dave Bair
I guess that's a "Right-to-Work" state.
Slight error
Bill Howatt
There is a slight error in your post.
"which is where the western world was 150 years ago..." isn't quite right, a lot of the conditions you describe were what was happening in the mining, and other, industries even in the first half of the 20th century. Freezing in company-town shacks, forced to buy everything at inflated prices at the company-store, lack of safety, etc.
Indeed, there has to be checks and balances in the system. Ironically, the groups that fight the existence of trade-unions and regulations are the same groups that caused them to come into being, reaping what they have sowed.
Bill
Re: Those who live in the dream land...
GolfSteve in Calgary
I don't deny that the application of regulations is sometimes over the top.
One important principle is that in our priviledged lives we can choose to work with a dangerous tool. Many people do not have a choice and are forced to work in unsafe conditions.
My father and grandfather used a firewood saw very similar to the one in the video that sparked this discussion. It is a huge labour saving device. With a little bit of guarding, it could become a reasonably safe labour saving device.
The saw in the video is much better than the saw my father used. The saw we used had a fixed platform where you had to slide the log into the blade. If you twisted the log you could bind the saw. The swinging platfom on the saw in the video is a big improvement over what we used:

in the 1970s
Bob Lang
I went to work in cabinet shops in the early 1970s. This was a few years after OSHA was created, and they did implement some silly rules and regulations.
About half of the older cabinetmakers at that time were missing digits, or portions of digits and the ones who had apprenticed in Europe had some real horror stories about machines that could easily take off an arm.
In my generation of cabinetmakers there are far fewer guys who can't count to ten on their fingers. Government regulation of safety is far from perfect and it can go too far. But leaving workplace safety in the hands of those motivated solely by the bottom line is far worse, in my opinion.
Bob Lang
I agree with that...
John in NM
We have a great deal of luxury in the civilized world, not the least of which is the ability to do largely as we please when it comes to working environment. There is little impediment these days to voting with one's feet if it comes to that.
As I said about the video, that unguarded flat belt is the thing that really gives me pause. The danger of an unguarded blade is intuitive, unguarded flat belts much less so. They don't look scary, and a guy can go a whole lifetime without getting snagged by one (the splice staples are usually what grabbed you). But belt accidents usually only happened once in a lifetime, if a person survived their working life was generally over. With the advancements of V-belts and even non-stapled flats the problem has largely disappeared.
Thank you for stating it so well Charlie!!
Re: Some bull in the barn
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
I did work in factories before OSHA, NOT in management. I worked in Tuthill spring company in Momence, IL in 1959. No OSHA - also spent a few years in the Youngstown Steel mills in the early 60's. I am not, nor did I ever deny things are much safer now. I will restate that most of the improvements I have seen in the last 50 years are NOT due to OSHA (or any Government entity). I do believe a great deal(by far the bulk) of the improvements were made just as improvements are made by technology improvements in our daily lives. Better ways were found to get things done that were much safer, faster and produced better products. I do grant that the Unions were needed in the beginning of the industrial revolution, as the pendulum swings however, almost everything goes too far, before returning to normal - then swings the other way too far. I just feel that most businesses (owners / operators) today do not ever want to see someone harmed and do all they can to prevent it. I don't feel the government has ever done a very effective job of anything they attempt. I also feel many of the current OSHA regulations do nothing to protect the worker, just cost the consumer extra money for the products produced - and taxes to pay the OSHA watchdogs.
Re: Some bull in the barn
charlie belden
Putting workers in harms way, unneccessarily, was not limited to "old manufacturing" jobs.
I worked in a Silly Cone Valley research lab with Stanford EE Phds. We were using Hi-Vac systems, high voltage induction heating units and electron beam guns, to VAPORIZE metalsl onto substrates - mylar tape, ends of laser crystals, and base metal "packaging" for connecting chips to. We also used various "solvents" to prepare samples to vaporize onto - solvents like Sulfuric Acid, Nitric Acid, Hydrochloric Acid and Hydrofluoric Acid, along with Toluene, MEK and Acetone. We worked with these solvents under a hood and in a sink that drained into a "scrubber" before entering the sewer system
Fortunately I'd had a lot of chemistry classes so I had some knowledge of what these "solvents" could do to skin, eyes and lungs, if not handled and used carefully. And I had a VERY healthy respect for HF, which can etch glass - and can get through the pores of your skin and "burn inside" without you knowing it - for a while.
When I was told to etch a substrate with HF I put on chemical proof gloves to protect my fingers and hands and went to the hooded sink to do what I was told to do. That's when the guy in charge of the Chem Room read me the riot act about wearing any kind of gloves when working with HF. He felt that gloves gave you a false sense of security and could have one or more pinholes through which HF could get to my skin - and I wouldn't know it - for a while. I stronlgy disagreed with him - noting that people who make chemical proof goves wouldn't sell gloves that didn't do their job. And if I was to play with HF, I'd make sure the gloves I was going to use were brand new and still in their individual packaging. Almost lost my job for that, and HAD TO work with HF without chemical proof gloves.
We had a Stanford Metallurgy Phd stand on a Hi Vac table to look into a viewing port on top of the vac bell that was at 10 to the minus 6 microns of mercury vac, and stared down at a pool of gold being vaporized by a radio frequency heater - that couples a lot of electrical energy to any conducting metal close enough to the electical field - looking through a thousand dollar optical pyrometer. The RF field coupled to the gold rims of his glasses - heating his glasses up very quickly and to a very high temperature. The Phd threw both his glasses and the optical pyrometer acrossed the vac lab - and danced around and cussed a lot.
When we first got our Electron Beam Gun unit, the Powers That Be had me set it up in one of our smaller, older vacuum bells. The bell was 1/4" thick stainless steel, 30" in diameter and about 30" tall. We pulled a vacuum down to the usual 10 to the minus six microns of vac. The head of the lab, also a Phd, with 15 years of experience in hi-vac metallurgy took the honor of firing up the EB gun and playing with it.
Being the lowest person on the lab's pecking order, I was on the other side of the bell.
Now you'd think that if you're about to play with an electron beam gun - that - when the beam is focused by using controllable magnetic fields, SOMEONE would have read the operating instructions. You see, when the EB gun is first turned on, the electron beam IS NOT focused, scattering beams all over the space inside the hi vac bell. So you can only see where the beam is when it's been focused a bit, making it visible. And you CAN do that safely - if you sneak up on it - have a SS cylinder with a hole for looking inside it to focus on and get it into the crucible you plan to vaporize metal from. When you see where the beam is, your have a few seconds to get it in the crucible before you burn through the SS cylinder.
Despite not knowing anything about an EB gun other than it could vaporize metals, I was able to SEE a 1" circle of glowing red hot metal on the surface of the SS vac bell - on my side - where the beam was focused. I also happened to be standing next to the hi vac vac release switch - which I hit immediately while yelling ITS GLOWING RED HOT ON THIS SIDE OF THE BELL!
After an ass chewing for shutting the game down without permission - and spoiling all the fun - I got a chance to explain why I'd shut things down - without permission. It was only then that we all, Phds and common folk, realized what WOULD have happened had the vac bell been burned through in another couple of seconds. (can you say IMPLOSION boys and girls?)
Then there was the "very expeprienced" Briitish chemist - who poured a 1000 ml beaker full of hot MEK into the top opening of a metallurgist flat lap table, thinking it was a sink. Stored under the its cabinet - you guessed it, boxes of granulatled cleaning crystals. Guess who got to clean THAT mess.
Then there was the Phd Metallurgist computer geek who came into the Hi Vac lab durihng our lunch time, moved an RF generator over to a vac bell nearby - the generator being on wheels - hooked it up and fired it up. UNFORTUNATELY - he'd inadvertently thrown a loop in the 6" wide braided copper ground strap for the generator. When he fired things up the loop induced a lot of electro power into the rebar in the lab's cement floor - and got that rebar VERY HOT - VERY QUICKLY. Blew a pizza sized hole in the floor - and made a loud noise - that the head lab tech i the break room to drop his coffee and run to put out a flaming Phd.
Now all the hi vac techs that worked in the hi vac lab had been given safety instructions - that had included why a loop in the ground strap was FORBIDDEN. Unfortunately, the Phd "didn't ge the memo". He also shouldn't have been in the hi vac lab unaccompanied either. A subsequent memo - which had to be acknowledge as having been received, read and understood took care of that happening again. Good thing his lace up shoes, with the metal shoe lace grommets, didn't have his foot in that ground strap loop when he turned on the machine.
A little knowledge is a dangerous thing. A lot of knowledge - of a very narrow field - accompanied by a belief that a Phd from Stanford meant you knew EVERYTHING - is even more dangerous. Subsequent OSHA rules required that ground straps had to accordian and their length limited - and that made them very difficult to "loop".
Not sure OSHA could have preventedsome of these accidents because nothing can be made Idiot Proof, since some "idiots" have Phds. But I think letting the lab techs set up and test new stuff - after they've read and understood the users manual, paying particular attention to the Safety section - would go a long ways towards that end.
You can complain about OSHA and Government Beauracrats all you like. But you can only begin to imagine a world of laissez-fare. Put The Jungle by Upton Sinclair, or The Octapus by Frank Norris, on your reading list if you haven't already read it.
Re: Some bull in the barn
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
Nothing new there to me Charlie. I also worked in High Vac, metal deposition in 1967-68. We made "Thin Film" precision resistors to Military standards. (Mil 10509D) The core for these were produced in a bell jar, with the vacuum pumped down mechanically then reduced farther to 10 to -7 torr, using a liquid nitrogen ventura pump, Aluminum and another trace metal was vaporized in the vacuum jar and deposited on the substrates. I also worked a lot with 1,1,1-trichloroethane, Acetone, MEK, Toulene, Hydrofluoric acid, (I used it to etch glass plates to produce stamps on tampon style printers. earlier had worked with PCB oil (used in transformers and high voltage switch gear) at a Motor repair shop. Also worked with Carbon tetrachloride, and still smoke (over 50 years of that bad habit), cleaned and wire wheel buffed many asbestos brake shoes while working at service stations (side jobs when I was young).
I am 72, if you believed all the standards for exposure set by OSHA, I should have been buried several years ago. I do not deny that there are dangers at work-sites, I have had friends that were Ironworkers, worked several stories in the air. Sons and other relatives in the service, some on the police force. Also had friends and relatives that work on high power, high lines. There is also danger in my shop, using my chain saws, climbing ladders, even mowing.. However the most danger almost all of us face is driving our vehicles.
Most of the "accidents" you referred to in your post would have happened today- if the individuals do the dumb thing you cite. OSHA - nor any other entity can cure "Stupid".