Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Finishing help!

Posts

Finishing help!

#1

Finishing help!

Marty

I have a 100 year old rocking chair. I have had sanded it down to bare wood, or roughly there abouts. My neighbor thought it was Mahog.,however it resembles white wood to me. It does have a "red tint" to it,so I will be puting a Rust-oleum "Black Cherry" stain on this chair.

My question,is sanding sealer then stain,or stain then sanding sealer? After I had this chair in 15 pieces my neighbor then tells me that "It was my fathers, grandfathers" if I had known that I would have not even attempted this. so if someone could please help me. Thanks, Marty.

Re: Finishing help!

#2

Re: Finishing help!

Gary Smyth

I hope I understand your specific situation. If the chair was pre finished why use a sanding sealer? What was on it before you sanded it down? Paint? Shellac? Varnish? I found two brief articles that may lend you assistance.

Michael Dresdner via Woodworker’s Journal: “Sanding sealer is never mandatory — it is an option that saves time and material in some situations, and is unnecessary in others. Some woods, like cedar, spruce, and poplar, are so porous that they tend to suck up the first few coats of sprayed lacquer as if nothing were applied. Other woods, such as walnut and mahogany, require a good bit of sanding to level the pores even when pore filler is used. In both cases, the material of choice would be something that builds up quickly and is very easy to sand. Enter sanding sealer.

“Sanding sealer is lacquer, or some other basic coating, with zinc stearate added. The stearate, which is a soft, fluffy soap, adds loft to the lacquer, making it build up and fill in pores much faster. It also makes the lacquer softer, and acts as a lubricant when sanding, so that sanding sealer powders off quickly and easily. These characteristics make it ideal for trimming both the number of coats and the amount of time spent sanding them. This is especially helpful when you are trying to build a perfectly flat, pore-free finish. It is useless, in fact, counterproductive, for the open pore “natural” look finishes more popular today.

“A word of warning is in order. The stearates make sanding sealer rather soft. If you put a hard, brittle finish, like lacquer, over a thick, soft one, like sanding sealer, it is much more likely to chip and crack. For that reason, if you use sanding sealer, stick to one or two coats at the most, and plan to sand most of it back off. For the same reason, and because it tends to shrink as it cures, it is not advisable to use sanding sealer instead of pore filler.”

From Minwax: A sanding sealer is not the same as a wood conditioner. Whereas a wood conditioner is a pre-stain treatment that reduces blotchiness when staining, a sanding sealer is applied only to bare wood that is not going to be stained. A sanding sealer can be used on bare, unstained floors, doors, furniture and cabinets prior to applying either an oil-based or a water-based clear finish. It is designed as a base coat that will dry quickly, seal the pores, and sand easily with fine sandpaper to create an ultra-smooth foundation.

My experience is that sanding sealer limits penetration of stain. That may be what you are looking for but you have to decide for the project you're working on.

Re: Finishing help!

#3

T'was A 100 Years Ago Today . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

it was most likely finished with a dark shellac and little else.

If you and the owner are intent on the "red" look of false cherry, apply your stain and get aggressive in rubbing off the excess. Let the piece sit for 5 days to let the oil in the stain dry well. Now come back with Dark Garnet dewaxed shellac, applied by spray or padding. Build some visual depth with 3 applications. If you and the owner wish to go further, you can topcoat with either a waterbase or oil base coating (poly or varnish) for some durability.

Re: Finishing help!

#4

Re: Finishing help!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Well, you stain before sealing except when you want to control the amount of stain uptake and then one does a partial seal before stain. Confused?

The best advice I can offer is don't do chemistry experiments (finishing is chemistry) on a 100 year old chair. Perfect what you propose to do on some test piece.

Re: Finishing help!

#5

Re: Finishing help!

David Yoho

Marty, with the information you gave us, here's my take on it. Not knowing what you did to get to the "sanded to bare wood" stage, I'll assume all you did was sand (not strip and sand). Given the age, my guess is the old finish more than likely was straight shellac or a tinted shellac.

If you simply sanded off the old finish, there's a good chance some of it remains in the pores, which will have an effect on how the bare wood absorbs a new stain. With that, I think the best you can do is try your stain and see how it goes on. If you're satisfied with the resulting coloration, simply apply the top coat of your choice and you're done.

If you were concerned about staying true to the age of the chair with your effort then I think shellac is the obvious choice. However, if you've never worked with it, shellac can be very difficult to get right. Perhaps a better choice would be a varnish like General Finishes Arm-R-Seal or something similar. This can be wiped on, which makes it easy to apply and avoids runs brushing can cause.

Re: Finishing help!

#6

Re: Finishing help!

Marty

AH HA, Thank you one and all. Upon further investagation,and some sanding,the "white wood with a redish tint" seems to be cherry. I have had two other woodworkers look at the wood and that is what both came up with. I did hand sand the old finish off,was it ever blackish,and sticky. Looked like old black tar. So now I will stain the back side of the corner braces and see what happens, after approvial of the owner. Thank You one and all. If I knew how to post pictures, I would when the rocker is finished. Marty

Re: Finishing help!

#7

Warning!!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Cherry is difficult to stain. The result will depend on how well you can sand and the stain you choose. Any rough or torn grain, or sanding scratch will stain dark and look ugly. There is great risk in staining.

If the wood is cherry consider oiling it with linseed oil, dry for a few days and top coat with wipe on varnish or something similar. Or better, set in sun for a few hours before oiling to darken it ( but if it is old it may already be darkened.

Re: Finishing help!

#8

Re: Finishing help!

Howard Acheson

Sanding is never a good way to remove a prior finish if you intend to re-stain as part of the refinishing process. Sanding will not remove the stain that has been absorbed into the wood. Any residual stain or finish will inhibit the even absorption of a new stain leading to uneven coloring and maybe adhesion problems.

The best way to remove an existing finish is to use a chemical paint stripper containing methylene chloride. This will do the best job of preparing the surface for a new stain.