Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Porch railing question

Posts

Porch railing question

#1

Porch railing question

Nat Robison

I just had my brick & cement front porch rebuilt and I'm trying to do a new railing going down the stairs. There are 3 stairs and they are built from brick so all the surfaces vary by an 1/8" or so.

I drilled holes in the brick and tried my best to register my posts off of the threaded rod....one went great but the other two posts aren't so great. It just seems there's too much variability in the surfaces to get my posts plumb and square so I can do the rest of the railing like I want to.

Anyone done anything similar with success? Is this just a matter of shimming and tweaking til it's right or is there something I'm not thinking of? Haven't tried any google searches so I'll try that next.

Re: Porch railing question

#2

Re: Porch railing question

Barry Irby

I have done railings about a hundred times. Some went well, some, not so much. The ones I have done lately on brick with treated wood posts I have drilled over sized holes in the brick and vertically in the posts. Then I bought the two part epoxy that comes in caulking gun tubes, shot some in the holes in the brick and plunged the rods into the holes, using the extra space in the holes to set the rods accurately. Then shot some in the posts and set them down over the rods, again using the extra space to finish the tune up of the spacing and getting the posts vertical.

The two part material is not actually epoxy in all cases, some of it is some other sort of plastic like acrylic. Whatever it is, it generates a lot of heat (exothermic reaction) and some of it cooks off very fast, as in seconds. If you get this variety, its nearly a two person job. In fact, it is a two person job. There is not time at all to shoot a hole, lay the gun down, insert the bolt and align it, because by that time the rest of it will have hardened in the tube on the gun. I ended up making some sort of template for each hole that accurately positioned the bolt, one of us shot the hole and the other one inserted the bolts. On later attempts, I bought the much slower setting version and waited over night for it to harden. A much calmer operation.

I have a big hammer drill that will bore a hole over two inches. My later attempts have been, drill the large hole, set the bolt in Cementitious Grout and let it set. cheaper than the epoxy/acrylic stuff.

The local borgs carry versions of both of the above. Check the area where the Anchor Bolts (Red Heads?) are and where they have the cement products.

I use heavily galvanized bolts, much better than threaded rod unless it is heavily galvanized or stainless. Wet brick and treated wood are both hard on metal parts.

Three risers don't required a railing. Four do.

Re: Porch railing question

#3

clarification

Nat Robison

I was aware of the 4-stair rule but I'd like to have a railing, nonetheless. The approach I've taken is basically what you've done but I think I need to oversize the holes in my wood so it gives me more wiggle room. I'm no expert furniture builder but it's tough to deal with all the surfaces out of square/level when you're used to much less variability.

I did buy some of the anchoring cement (in a tube) and I swear that stuff hardens in about 45 seconds. I'll try to locate some slower-curing stuff if I proceed. Thanks.

Re: Porch railing question

#4

Re: clarification

Barry Irby

I understand the frustration of working with irregular surfaces and things not square or level.

One thing I left out is that you can set the posts getting the plumb and rotated into the correct orientation, but not completely tight down against the floor. Then after your setting compound hardens, you can pack some under the post and create a small cove of it around the base. Or you can put some on the surface of the brick as you set the post and let it squeeze out and then clean it up a bit. You can also put it on the bottom of the post it you are using the caulking gun type. This really makes the posts much more solid. Without it, you are bending the threaded rod and the post is a good lever. With it, you are trying to extract the rod from the post or floor and it is much stronger.

I went to a commercial construction place and bought the slower setting version and it was MUCH easier and better. Expensive though. Don't remember how much but it was sort of stunningly expensive. I went to the Rock Hard Water Putty method. Be sure what ever you buy is rated for exterior use.

Are you building your own rails? Be sure to provide a "grip" rail. It should be about 34" above the toe of the tread.

Re: Porch railing question

#5

PS, my first mistake...

Barry Irby

When I did this about five years ago was to use five minute Epoxy. Drilled the holes in the brick only to discover I had drilled into the voids in the brick. Spent a long time pacing them with bits of brick and whatever to contain the epoxy. Set the bolts. Next day filled the holes in the posts and set them onto the bolts. Braced the posts and left. Came back later to discover the epoxy had drooled out of the posts and onto the brick and down over the sides. And then it set. What a fine mess that was (and still is). (Its on a rental house). Sometimes the obvious is not so obvious. Hindsight/Experience and all that.