Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Twisted wood chest top

Posts

Twisted wood chest top

#1

Twisted wood chest top

Rick

I made a walnut blanket chest and somehow ended up with a slight twist of about 3/8" in the chest top from corner to opposite corner. I'm looking for ideas on the best way to correct it. The top is 3 pieces of 1" x 8" X 46" walnut glued together. I considered clamping it flat and wetting it and then let it dry, not sure if that will work or make it worse.

Re: Twisted wood chest top

#2

Re: Twisted wood chest top

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I considered clamping it flat and wetting it and then let it dry, not sure if that will work or make it worse. ....That will not work. To "move" the wood you would need to get it both hot and wet. I would be inclined to live with it.

Re: Twisted wood chest top

#3

Re: Twisted wood chest top

Merle

You could try adding battens to the underside of the lid. Clamp if flat, then glue and screw the battens (maybe 3 of them) to the top. After 24 hours, release it and see how it behaves. I would make the battens about an inch wide and an inch and a half thick.

Re: Twisted wood chest top

#4

Re: Twisted wood chest top

Don Stephan

Battens will create cross grain construction which could lead to other problems.

What's the background on the wood? Was it suitably dry before milling and gluing? Were the boards allowed to acclimate to workshop environment before milling? After assembly were all surfaces given the same finish?

An option is to saw the joints apart and evaluate the individual pieces. If they are twisted, and flattening will leave them too thin, make another top. If they are flat then the edges may not have been straight and square to the face. Re joint and re glue.

Re: Twisted wood chest top

#5

Re: Twisted wood chest top *LINK*

John McGaw

Is this chest a long-completed project that has just recently displayed the twist problem or is it something that is in-progress? If it is in-progress then I'd put it into the ambient conditions where it will live long-term and evaluate what happens. It will either improve, do nothing, or get worse and you can go from there.

In some big blanket boxes and chests I've made front-to-back battens have been my primary method of preventing warping but they will do little for a corner-to-corner twist unless a batten is diagonal to counteract the movement. It might be possible to install a half-lapped "X" batten arrangement, allowing for wood movement by using only screws for attachment in over-bored holes. This method could be prettied up to appear decent in a more rustic piece but might be a bit much in a more refined one.


Chest with front-to-back lid battens

Re: Twisted wood chest top

#6

Re: Twisted wood chest top

Roger Rayburn

About a million years ago I made some rail and stile doors for some cabinets. Several of them warped and twisted. On a crap shoot, I wet them down and then clamped them down hard with a diagonal fulcrum corner to corner on the corners opposite the ones with the twist. I clamped them with about 2 times the correction I wanted. That time it was successful and stayed successful. I have done that same process since. Sometimes it works, sometimes it does not work. I've never attempted it on a glued up top by itself, only on rail and stile doors.

Re: Twisted wood chest top

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

A couple thoughts

Jack Guzman from Maine

Rick,

Just a couple thoughts to ponder on. Lay the top on the chest and hold the front edge tight to the chest; Then scribe a line on the back of the chest parallel to the bottom edge of the lid following the twisted lid. Then remove the excess material from the chest back so the twisted lid lies flat.

Another thought. Cut the glue lines in the lid and reposition the three pieces to try to lessen the twist. I think this second idea is a little unlikely but it is a thought.Good luck---Jack

Re: Twisted wood chest top

#8

Was it correct when glued?

Gary Smyth

When did it warp? 3/8" is major. Did you just get a bad board? Would a wide belt sander and a resulting thinner top be an alternative? If you don't want to make a new top you might try to minimize the look by shimming or resetting hinges to reduce the distance. another help might work by adding weight(s) to the offending corner and doing a long (long) term wait. A relatively small amout of weight, say ten pounds, over a couple of seasons might solve the problem for you. Some tops will never change and months later will still spring back, but I've had others that will settle on the chest edges just as planned and stay there. If I have a minor misfit sometimes loosening the screws on the hinges a turn helps. After the top settles a bit over time they can be redrilled or retightened with no viewable difference..

Re: Twisted wood chest top

#9

Making it Flat

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

If you insist on its being dead flat,and don't mind losing some thickness, find someone with a wide drum/belt sander. Make a 24" wide x 54" sled from flat ply or MDF with a stop ledger at one end. Place your lid on the sled and shim the high corners equally (3/16" thick wedges). Run the piece through the sander to get the top surface dead straight and flat using very light "cuts" so as to not flex the workpiece. Remove the panel from sled, flip, and run through the sander (without the sled) to get the second side parallel with the first.

You'll have removed 3/8" of thickness but your top panel will be dead flat. Now you can apply battens to fit the interior dimensions of the chest carcase with a fitted lid "just like you planned it that way." :D

Re: Twisted wood chest top

#10

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You can do essentially the same thing using a router-planer with a sharp planing bit, but the sander is much easier.

Re: Twisted wood chest top

#11

Good Question

Howard Acheson

So, was it initially flat? If so, did it warp after you assembled the item? Have you applied any finish to it? Have you moved the item to a different part of the house?

Try propping the cover up so that air can freely circulate to both sides of the top.

Re: Twisted wood chest top

#12

Re: Twisted wood chest top

Yonak

Here's an idea : you could mount a real strong electro-magnet at the offending front corner. Don't put any handles on the lid but put a switch for the magnet on the under side of the chest. When the magnet is on, it couldn't be opened, but when switched off the top corner would pop open. Voila .. no more problem .. now it's a feature. :)

Re: Twisted wood chest top

#13

How would battens take out twist?

Dick Coers

cup maybe, but not twist.

Re: Twisted wood chest top

#14

Rip it apart and start over......

Dick Coers

but this time, glue up on a flat surface and check it as soon as the clamps are tightened up.

Re: Twisted wood chest top

#15

Re: Twisted wood chest top

Rick

Thanks to everyone for your good suggestions on my twisted walnut chest lid.

After considering all the ideas and work involved I discovered that it takes about 6 lbs pressure to pull the high corner down flat. So I decided to install a strong neodymium magnetic catch on the inside of high corner. I think it will work. Maybe eventually the twist will relax.

Thanks again.. Rick

Re: Twisted wood chest top

#16

good plan

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think it will relax some over time and over time you will forget about it. I don't think the "permanent" fixes are worth the risk or effort. Viewed from top I presume the twist is not noticeable.

How about a picture of the chest.....?

Re: Twisted wood chest top

#17

Re: Rip it apart and start over......

gary peterson

Save the sweat, make a new top by following all the advice on wood moisture, acclimation, glue up, etc. I would think much easier than a fixit upper rube goldberg attack.