Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

welding bandsaw blades

Posts

welding bandsaw blades

#1

welding bandsaw blades

Edward in Vancouver

I'm still "making friends" with my bandsaw, but last week I managed to break a blade. Yes I know, I was turning too tight a radius with a "Viking" 3/8" x 3 tpi blade and yes, it is my fault.

Still.... The blade has only been used maybe 3-4 hours, and that on spruce and fir. Don't want to sound cheap, but the blade was over $20 and I want to squeeze some more life out of it, if possible. Blade broke right at the weld. L.V. sells silver soldering bandsaw blade repair kits.

Is it worth it?

Re: welding bandsaw blades

#2

Re: welding bandsaw blades

Bill Tindall, E.TN.

every place that I buy blades from guarantees the weld. Any break there is fixed free. Find a local source that welds blades from stock rolls. My 141" blades are only about $12 from local shop.

Re: welding bandsaw blades

#3

I've soldered and welded blades...

John in NM

Soldering will work fine, with some practice. Once you get good at it, soldered is as good as welded. At a guess, I'll estimate that "good at it" takes 50-100 blades? I did about 12 before a friend gave me a blade welder to fix up, so I never got good at the soldering. About half the time, the solder joint actually lasted long enough that the blade was pretty dull once it broke. The others broke first.

So, to sum up, look for a sharpening shop that will weld blades. Might cost $10.

On the other hand, the friend who gave me the blade welder has a much bigger one. He bought it from the local sharpening shop, who sold it because they were sick of re-welding blades they had sold.

Re: welding bandsaw blades

#4

I had better luck brazing

Keith Newton

Not much difference, except stronger fill, a little higher heat, but with such thin metal, no problem.

Re: welding bandsaw blades

#5

Re: I've soldered and welded blades...

Dick Coers

Always remember this is silver or "hard" soldering. It is more like brazing than what most consider soldering. The kits work fine, or go to any welding supply for flux and silver solder. A cheap propane torch works just fine on those thin blades. You do have to angle grind the blade before silver soldering. I use my disc sander and the miter gage to sand complimentary 45 deg angles on each side of the blade. That gives you a much longer skive joint and gives the solder plenty to grip compared to the weld butt joint. I silver solder all my own blades, and even touch up the teeth with a Dremel at least 3 times before they go to the recycler. So, I can definitely relate to your frugal side!

Re: welding bandsaw blades

#6

A scarf joint was the next thing to try...

John in NM

I've heard that does work a lot better. I doubt I would have purchased a blade welder, but it was free for the making of a few parts, so why not? :D

Re: welding bandsaw blades

#7

Silver solder works great

John Lucas

You need an overlapping joint. I thin the blade similar to a scarf joint clean them, put some flux on the joint and then solder. You'll need a hotter torch. I use a MAPP gas torch. Silver solder comes in hard, medium, and soft but that doesn't describe the joint, just the temperature it takes to melt each one. Any of them will work at least in my experience.

Re: welding bandsaw blades

#8

Re: Silver solder works great

John Lucas

Sorry meant to tell you that you need a jig to keep everything aligned. easily made out of some angle iron. You should be able to do a search for band saw blade soldering and find all you need. I think either Rockler or Woodworkers supply used to sell you everything you needed.

Re: welding bandsaw blades

#9

Re: Silver solder works great

Edward in Vancouver

Thanks for all the replies

I've got the broken blade all coiled up and waiting in a drawer, when I have a few T.S. blades I'll try my luck with my local sharpening service. The kit L.V. sells is around $30, I think. If I break another blade though, I'll probably bite the bullet and get the kit.

I gotta say though, that I'm having fun with the Band saw. Put weather stripping on the doors and popped another hole in the lower door for better dust extraction. After balancing the wheels, trueing the tires, replacing the pulley with a balanced (and true) one, and putting in a link belt, the machine runs smooth and passes the "nickel test".

Now I just gotta learn how to use it..............

Re: welding bandsaw blades

#10

Paul Kramer

Question: Does the heating make the blade brittle?

Paul Kramer

I've read the responses and I didn't see any mention of any sort of tempering of the weld/braze/solder area afterward to prevent brittleness and subsequent breakage in the same area. I've heard about this problem but I've never had any experience with this.

Re: welding bandsaw blades

#11

Welding yes, soldering no...

John in NM

At least that is how I understand it. Silver soldering or brazing does not involve as much heat as welding.

Blade welders have an annealing setting, you use it to re-heat the weld area after welding.

Re: welding bandsaw blades

#12

Re: Question: Does the heating make the blade brit

Dick Coers

Traditional blade welding requires a reheat after the weld to reduce the brittleness around the weld. It is like arc welding, and gives an intense sudden heat. Silver soldering gives it a gentle soak of heat and cooling, and does increase the brittleness of the carbon steel.

Re: welding bandsaw blades

#13

Re: Some truth on wellding BS blades

Tom

- Your blades shouldn't be breaking. I had a 14" and a 18" and virtually never had a blade break. I also have a 4" one, one of those that is hand held. It doesn't break blades, though I have heard small bandsaws may.

- The reasons there are welders is so that blades can be inserted through holes like pierced work with a scroll saw, welded on the spot, and then broken again when the cut is done, and so on. This is common in metal work. Welds are perfectly strong, obviously, and then can be done as butts. Band welders aren't out there because routine blade breakage is an acceptable thing.

- Silver solder allows folks who can't weld to scraf and braze the blades. A propane torch is fine, but it does not have enough heat to do the job in such a way that one can fuss on about how superior it is. You need either pretty neato aspirating burners for that (not relevant to this discussion) or an oxy torch of some type. Oddly hotter is better because the heat is there in an instant part of the heat affected zone formula is time, so cold propane torches are not an uptick. They probably are doing a great job if the whole thing is like a dream. It should go up to heat, liquefy the braze, and everything looks shiny and smooth when one is done, and the flux was always nice and clean. If it isn't all that much fun, then you are doing it wrong, or it wasn't hot enough. But blades are pretty small so it should be ok.

- The other reason the whole heat discussion is a little bogus is that the better blades tend not to be affected by heat. Obviously the ones with HSS in them, but also ones that have inserts, the band may not be high carbon since it does not really have any advantage, and costs more and creates other problems. It is higher tensile strength, but that really isn't the main issue since presumably the section is sufficient not to go past yield anyway. If the band is high carbon steel there may be an issue.

- Silver solder for bands is readily available at your local welding supply. I buy off ebay. Silver is pretty expensive so shop around. 56% is nice. I use 45% for reasons not related to this. Get a no cadmium wire. If you are getting it off ebay, be sure it isn't some old cadmium stuff. I use safetysilv flux.

Re: welding bandsaw blades

#14

Some good info here...

John in NM

A very good synopsis.

Couple points to add....

Welded blades break when used hard, or when the butt isn't quite lined up before welding. Both situations are less than ideal, but they do happen. One shop I worked for had a saw that was a chronic blade breaker. I wasn't interested enough at the time to make a study of where the blades broke though. I hated that saw :D

I'd forgotten all about the propane torch problem. That is exactly what spurred me to fix up the welder, I was out of acetylene and tried a propane torch :D I must be getting old... Anyway, I wouldn't recommend propane, it's too slow on a 1/2" band, so unless one is very practiced, I doubt they would get a strong joint.

My old welder came off a junked DoAll saw. Original purpose was exactly what you describe, lucky for me a friend was working for a used machine vendor and got all sorts of good junk :D

I'm a little perplexed by your post title though, it implies to me that there was a bunch of "un-truth" posted prior that required correction. Perhaps I'm imagining things, that does happen from time to time :D

Re: welding bandsaw blades

#15

Re: Some truth on wellding BS blades

Dick Coers

- Your blades shouldn't be breaking. I had a 14" and a 18" and virtually never had a blade break. I also have a 4" one, one of those that is hand held. It doesn't break blades, though I have heard small bandsaws may.

Your statistical analysis of 1 persons use does not make the statement that your blades shouldn't be breaking helpful, nor accurate to the general public. I'd estimate that many people have blades break, unless they've only been at it a few years. In 40+ years of woodworking, I've had my share with machines from 10" to 36".

- Silver solder allows folks who can't weld to scraf and braze the blades. A propane torch is fine, but it does not have enough heat to do the job in such a way that one can fuss on about how superior it is. You need either pretty neato aspirating burners for that (not relevant to this discussion) or an oxy torch of some type. Oddly hotter is better because the heat is there in an instant part of the heat affected zone formula is time, so cold propane torches are not an uptick. They probably are doing a great job if the whole thing is like a dream. It should go up to heat, liquefy the braze, and everything looks shiny and smooth when one is done, and the flux was always nice and clean. If it isn't all that much fun, then you are doing it wrong, or it wasn't hot enough. But blades are pretty small so it should be ok.

I prefer the propane torch because it will not overheat the flux or silver solder. Instant high heat would make the solder time and flame position so critical that success would be more problematic. Never said it was superior, just works well for me.

"Oddly hotter is better because the heat is there in an instant part of the heat affected zone formula is time,"

Can't comment, don't know what this sentence means.

- The other reason the whole heat discussion is a little bogus is that the better blades tend not to be affected by heat. Obviously the ones with HSS in them, but also ones that have inserts, the band may not be high carbon since it does not really have any advantage, and costs more and creates other problems. It is higher tensile strength, but that really isn't the main issue since presumably the section is sufficient not to go past yield anyway. If the band is high carbon steel there may be an issue.

The heat discussion is not bogus, as you mention in the final line about carbon steel may be an issue. Any heat discussion is necessary when a range of steel and steel alloys is being talked about. I've never used a high speed steel band saw blade, nor a carbide tipped. So the heat discussion has value to others like myself.

Re: welding bandsaw blades

#16

Re: Some truth on wellding BS blades

Tom

"Your statistical analysis of 1 persons use does not make the statement that your blades shouldn't be breaking helpful, nor accurate to the general public. I'd estimate that many people have blades break, unless they've only been at it a few years. In 40+ years of woodworking, I've had my share with machines from 10" to 36"."

I've been at it 40 some year's too. I am sure most blade companies would also say that blades should not break. The idea a new blade breaks within a few weeks of amateur use is a cause of concern to me. I would be putting more work into figuring out why that happened, than on how to become an expert welder. Except on the basis that on many machines the blade that they come with should be tossed out of hand.

"I prefer the propane torch because it will not overheat the flux or silver solder. Instant high heat would make the solder time and flame position so critical that success would be more problematic. Never said it was superior, just works well for me."

+1/2 I didn't say it didn't work well for you. However the idea that a cooler flame is better is not good info. People make bikes with propane torches, and if you have one with a 1" bore, it may even be configured in an optimal way. But there is this general fear of getting stuff hot out there, that comes from the intersection of a lot of unrelated ideas. Like say that grinding draws temper which it can. Someone hears that and in some completely different field like welding 4130 aircraft frames come out on the wrong side of it. I have several hobies that overlap this area and I come across this stuff a lot.

The reality is that you have to get the stuff up to the heat where the brazing can occur. It takes longer with less heat, which means the heat spreads over a larger area, it imperils the flux, and so forth. When it works, it works, it just isn't a better system. Probably a good function of the jigs is to act as a heat sink, which has it's pros and cons.

""Oddly hotter is better because the heat is there in an instant part of the heat affected zone formula is time,"

Can't comment, don't know what this sentence means."

The ability to control the application of heat is better with a hotter flame (I don't like MAPP gas though it works OK as an alternative to Propane, but it is not more hot enough to really mater, but it does seem to be dirtier). There are plenty of people who prefer oxy acetylene, over oxy propane just for that reason, and either of those combo is way hotter than plain propane. The difference is evident even at that rarefied level. One interesting property of steel that is important to many of the ways we work it is that it is not that great at conducting heat. This makes it easy to weld, or in the case of brazing to limit the region affected by the heat. So a small very hot flame is a lot more controllable. And another factor may be that the products in question are for the most part designed for oxy fuel torch use.

"The heat discussion is not bogus, as you mention in the final line about carbon steel may be an issue. Any heat discussion is necessary when a range of steel and steel alloys is being talked about. I've never used a high speed steel band saw blade, nor a carbide tipped. So the heat discussion has value to others like myself."

Keep in mind that the bogosity affects both sides of the argument. Part of the reason why a generally poor technology like pure propane is not so bad a deal is because the blade isn't that sensitive. Bi-meta blades are pretty commonplace these days. But even with high carbon, you are talking about a very small region in the blade, possibly not including adjacent teeth where skip teeth woodworking tooth type blades are involved. Just grinding the weld smooth could draw any temper in the blade that would lead to subsequent breakage. The standard industrial process is arc welding without a shield gas, that pretty much says it all.