Re: Some truth on wellding BS blades
Tom
"Your statistical analysis of 1 persons use does not make the statement that your blades shouldn't be breaking helpful, nor accurate to the general public. I'd estimate that many people have blades break, unless they've only been at it a few years. In 40+ years of woodworking, I've had my share with machines from 10" to 36"."
I've been at it 40 some year's too. I am sure most blade companies would also say that blades should not break. The idea a new blade breaks within a few weeks of amateur use is a cause of concern to me. I would be putting more work into figuring out why that happened, than on how to become an expert welder. Except on the basis that on many machines the blade that they come with should be tossed out of hand.
"I prefer the propane torch because it will not overheat the flux or silver solder. Instant high heat would make the solder time and flame position so critical that success would be more problematic. Never said it was superior, just works well for me."
+1/2 I didn't say it didn't work well for you. However the idea that a cooler flame is better is not good info. People make bikes with propane torches, and if you have one with a 1" bore, it may even be configured in an optimal way. But there is this general fear of getting stuff hot out there, that comes from the intersection of a lot of unrelated ideas. Like say that grinding draws temper which it can. Someone hears that and in some completely different field like welding 4130 aircraft frames come out on the wrong side of it. I have several hobies that overlap this area and I come across this stuff a lot.
The reality is that you have to get the stuff up to the heat where the brazing can occur. It takes longer with less heat, which means the heat spreads over a larger area, it imperils the flux, and so forth. When it works, it works, it just isn't a better system. Probably a good function of the jigs is to act as a heat sink, which has it's pros and cons.
""Oddly hotter is better because the heat is there in an instant part of the heat affected zone formula is time,"
Can't comment, don't know what this sentence means."
The ability to control the application of heat is better with a hotter flame (I don't like MAPP gas though it works OK as an alternative to Propane, but it is not more hot enough to really mater, but it does seem to be dirtier). There are plenty of people who prefer oxy acetylene, over oxy propane just for that reason, and either of those combo is way hotter than plain propane. The difference is evident even at that rarefied level. One interesting property of steel that is important to many of the ways we work it is that it is not that great at conducting heat. This makes it easy to weld, or in the case of brazing to limit the region affected by the heat. So a small very hot flame is a lot more controllable. And another factor may be that the products in question are for the most part designed for oxy fuel torch use.
"The heat discussion is not bogus, as you mention in the final line about carbon steel may be an issue. Any heat discussion is necessary when a range of steel and steel alloys is being talked about. I've never used a high speed steel band saw blade, nor a carbide tipped. So the heat discussion has value to others like myself."
Keep in mind that the bogosity affects both sides of the argument. Part of the reason why a generally poor technology like pure propane is not so bad a deal is because the blade isn't that sensitive. Bi-meta blades are pretty commonplace these days. But even with high carbon, you are talking about a very small region in the blade, possibly not including adjacent teeth where skip teeth woodworking tooth type blades are involved. Just grinding the weld smooth could draw any temper in the blade that would lead to subsequent breakage. The standard industrial process is arc welding without a shield gas, that pretty much says it all.