Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Replacement Windows

Posts

Replacement Windows

#1

Replacement Windows

Jerry Nicholson

Is Andersen a decent choice for replacement windows? My 1966 house still has the original double hung windows with self storing storm windows and I have some dry rot on the north side of the house. Depending on cost, I probably won't be replacing all my windows at the same time.

Jerry

Re: Replacement Windows

#2

Many people say that

Merle

Andersen makes good windows and doors. I don't think much of their customer service however. FWIW

Re: Replacement Windows

#3

Re: Many people say that

Larry

Don't know where you are, but here on the west coast milgard windows are the way to go.

Re: Replacement Windows

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Replacement Windows

Jack Guzman from Maine

I'm a carpenter and have been doing it for many years. Andersens are known around here as the best. They are a good quality window and the company has a good reputation.---Jack

Re: Replacement Windows

#5

Re: Replacement Windows

Jay St. Peter

I got the Anderson replacement windows from one of their replacement window centers. They seemed to have the best design on replacement windows at the time. Not cheap though. I was very happy with the entire experience. It was 10 years ago and I don't live in that house anymore, but it would be the first place I'd go if I was starting the search again.

Jay

Re: Replacement Windows

#6

Re: Replacement Windows

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I've not been impressed with Anderson Windows. When we replaced our old wood Anderson windows we went with Great Lakes Gold All Vinyl windows and couldn't be happier. They work well, are weather tight, tilt in for cleaning, stay where you leave them when you open one. We have had two thermo pane seals fail out of 29 windows and they were replaced promptly by the company under their lifetime warranty.

Our windows all have divided light grids internal to the sealed portion so you never have to clean the grids. They are low E glass.

Lee

Re: Replacement Windows

#7

Renewal

Jay St. Peter

The windows I got were "Renewal by Anderson" brand. Somehow different, but related to Anderson. At the time Anderson didn't make replacement windows, only new construction windows. Renewal was their replacement brand. Don't know if that is still the situation as I could have sworn I saw some far less expensive Anderson branded replacement windows in one of the Borgs recently. The Renewals are composite as opposed to vinyl. Definitely nicer, but priced accordingly.

Re: Replacement Windows

#8

Re: Renewal

Dave Bair

As far as I know, Anderson Renewal Windows must be installed by their people. My experience is that the windows are excellent but that the installation was marginal. I ended up stuffing a lot of fiberglass insulation around each window after the installers left because drafts were coming into the house around them. Luckily, I had specified that I would do the interior trim work or I probably wouldn't have noticed the problem until winter. As an aside, the installers did not have a level or square with them, they set the windows "by eye". They begrudgingly reset half of them because I was there and I used a level to check their work.

Re: Replacement Windows

#9

Re: Renewal

Jay St. Peter

Yes, Renewal is only available from the Renewal showroom and has to be installed by them. In my case they did a great job. Your comments about trim are puzzling as they are meant to be replacement windows and install inside the frame of the existing windows. I had them wrap my exterior trim with aluminum so I wouldn't have to paint, but otherwise they left all trim intact. Maybe it has to do with what type of windows they're replacing.

Jay

Re: Replacement Windows

#10

Re: Renewal

Dave Bair

Mine were installed in the rough opening left when they removed the old windows, if that's what you mean a "window frame". I wanted to replace the old moldings so I had stripped all of the old trim off prior to the installation.They came with a bundle of unpainted pine quarter-round they planned to install around the borders of the new window. Since they didn't always center the replacements in the opening, I can only imagine how the final product would have looked. But the windows themselves have been trouble-free and durable.

Re: Replacement Windows

#11

Re: Renewal

Jay St. Peter

Dave,

My orignal windows were wood framed with aluminum tracks. They pulled the window panes out of the main window frame, ripped the aluminum tracks off and installed the replacement windows into the existing window frame. No trim was removed either inside or outside. The windows had to fit within the frames to a pretty tight tolerance. They had a slick measuring device they used and it took several months IIRC to get the custom made replacement windows. Each replacement was labeled with the window it replaced and they had left small stickers identifying each window at the time of measurement that matched. It all fit quite tight and they used expandable foam to fill any small gaps. Sounds far different than what you had done. But, the replacement windows have no flanges so they wouldn't have fit right into the rough opening in my house.

Jay

Re: Replacement Windows

#12

Re: Renewal

Dave Bair

Ah, now I see. My originals were all aluminum and the replacements were supposedly measured to fit into the rough opening. There was no flange and they were not all that tight a fit. There was a loose foam-rubber collar around each unit that needed extra insulation to become draft-tight.

Re: Replacement Windows

#13

Re: Replacement Windows

Jerry Samsen

Replying to an old post but we used Anderson Replacement Windows to replace 3 window and two sliding patio doors. Total cost was $12K and I would say it was way over priced. These were replacement windows so they left the old aluminum frames in place. I realize now that I could have done it myself and saved a bundle. Removing the old glass and sliding in a replacement is not exactly rocket science. Even pulling a sliding patio door and replacing is something you can get done with a helper in a couple of hours.

It's like when I paid to have my kitchen refaced before I became a woodworker. I cringe to think how much I paid now that I realize how easy it is.